Share
Embed
Transcript
33 slides
-
Batch correction • Batch correction makes the same tissue appear
similar across slides • Includes “normalization” and “harmonization” • Challenging because slides differ in their composition • Due to differences in tissue composition and type 3 Unnormalized Normalized MAP06025 MAP00083 MAP03361 Bottom of crypt Interior of crypt Stroma Top of crypt -
Systematic differences in image intensities • Image/cell histograms reveal differences
in image intensities and cell populations 4 -
Review of batch correction methods • Transformation – transforms data
to make it more amenable to downstream analysis • Normalization – adjusts data distribution to make it more similar across batches • Harmonization • adjusts data distribution conserving covariate effects to make it more similar across batches • Uses information across slides 5 -
Common transformations • Need transformations that respect the range of
the data (non- negative or strictly positive) • Ideally, yields reasonable visual separation of expressed and unexpressed cells 6 Type Formula c Range log y!" = log#$ (𝑥!" + 𝑐) 1 [0, ∞) tanh y!" = tanh(𝑥!" /𝑐) 2 (−∞, ∞) asinh y!" = asinh(𝑥!"/𝑐) 5 (−∞, ∞) For slide i and cell/pixel j. -
Common normalizations 7 Type Formula Parameters Range Mean division y!"
= log#$(𝑥!"/𝜇! + 𝑐) y!" = tanh 𝑥!" 𝑐𝜇! c=1,2; 𝜇! =mean [0, ∞) Min/max scaling 𝑦!" = 𝑥!" − min " 𝑥!" max " 𝑥!" − min " 𝑥!" [0, ∞) Quantile 𝑦!" = 𝑥!"× 𝑞 𝑥 ⋅" 𝑞 𝑥!" 𝑞 𝑥 ⋅# - quantile all images 𝑞 𝑥!# - quantile image i [−∞, ∞) For slide i and cell/pixel j. -
Comments about normalization • Mean division assumes non-negative data –
based on Poisson noise • Min-max scaling is bad • Pointless if images are bounded by precision of the image (e.g. 8 bit precision) • Maximum is usually a noisy parameter and technically unbounded – highly volatile normalization • Normalizations that result in normally distributed data do not get good separation of expressed and unexpressed cells (anecdotally) • Z-normalization does not respect boundedness of the data 8 -
Common harmonization • None have been developed for mIF data
• Closest option is ComBat-seq for negative binomial (count) data 9 Zhang et al., NAR Gen and Bioinf, 2020 -
Investigation of normalization in mIF • We explored combinations of
batch correction and transformation 10 Johnson et al. Biostatistics 2007; Fortin et al., Neuroimage 2017; Wrobel et al. Neuroimage 2020; Harris et al., Bioinformatics 2022 Harmonization method Transformation/Normalization -
New batch correction evaluation framework • Most spatial-omics data lack
ground truth for evaluating slide effects • Cole Harris established a framework to evaluate batch correction 1. Alignment of marker densities 2. Cell phenotyping discordance 3. Proportion of variance due to slide 11 Alignment of marker densities -
Cell phenotyping discordance Logic of the procedure: • There are
no batch effects within a slide – assigned phenotypes are unaffected by batch • Apply phenotyping within slide and across slides for a each batch correction method and measure discordance 12 Across slide negative Across slide positive Within-slide negative (-, -) (-, +) Within-slide positive (+, -) (+, +) -
Proportion of variance due to slide • Random effects model
quantifying slide effect 𝑦<= = 𝛽 + 𝛾< + 𝜖<= • Intraclass correlation (ICC) is proportion of variance due to slide ICC = 𝜎> ? 𝜎> ? + 𝜎@ ? • Lower is better 14 Proportion of variance due to slide -
mxnorm: an R package for normalization of spatial-omics data •
Users can easily evaluate normalization procedures in their own data • Default normalization options (from Harris et al. 2022) or user specified • mxnorm can be used to evaluate new normalization methods in future papers • Available on CRAN 15 Harris, Wrobel, Vandekar, JOSS, 2022 -
Summary of batch correction methods • Transformations and normalization are
widely used and adapted from other fields • Harmonization-based batch correction methods have not been well developed or evaluated • It is likely that normalization is insufficient • Room for new methods development 16 -
CD8+ cells CD8+ cells P(CD8>0)=0.04 P(CD8>0)=0.4 Cell phenotyping- defining cell
types • Marker gating – cell types defined by individual markers • Subjective 18 -
Cell phenotyping- defining cell types • Marker gating – cell
types defined by individual markers • Subjective • Clustering – cell types defined via clustering • Manually intensive • Recently developed semiautomated methods • ASTIR (Geuenich et al., Cell Systems, 2022) • HALO Inform phenotyping 19 UMAP 1 UMAP 2 Leiden clustering -
Semiautomated methods overview • Inform – proprietary, semiautomated (requires manually
annotated training data) • ASTIR – unsupervised clustering, but takes a yaml file defining cell types • A mixture model assuming transformed data are log-normal • Uses variational Bayes for estimation with neural networks as variational distribution • GammaGateR – semi-supervised marker gating 20 -
GammaGateR – semiautomated marker gating in R • GammaGateR fits
gamma mixture models to perform automated marker gating separately to each channel and slide • It takes user-specified constraints to obtain consistent model fit to each slide • Returns probability of being marker positive for each channel 21 -
Advantages of GammaGateR • Limitations of existing methods • Designed
for less noisy data • Don’t consider underlying distribution • Benefits of Gamma mixture model • Can accommodate skewed distributions • Incorporates zero-inflation • Model incorporates biological information as a prior 22 CD3D cell expression -
NAKATPase cell expression Advantages of GammaGateR • Limitations of existing
methods • Designed for less noisy data • Don’t consider underlying distribution • Benefits of Gamma mixture model • Can accommodate skewed distributions • Incorporates zero-inflation • Model incorporates biological information as a prior 23 -
GammaGateR performs competitively 24 GammaGateR Posterior GammaGateR Marginal Biological prediction
error (C-index) for ovarian cancer stage Comparison to silver-standard manual labels -
GammaGateR model fit • Component zero is proportion of zeros
• Component 1 is unexpressed cells 26 -
GammaGateR model fit • Component zero is proportion of zeros
• Component 1 is unexpressed cells • Component 2 is expressed cells 27 -
GammaGateR model fit • Component zero is proportion of zeros
• Component 1 is unexpressed cells • Component 2 is expressed cells • Mode is location of peak 28 -
GammaGateR model fit • Component zero is proportion of zeros
• Component 1 is unexpressed cells • Component 2 is expressed cells • Mode is location of peak • Lambda is proportion in each cell type 29 -
GammaGateR contraints • User-specified constraints improve model fit across slides
30 Boundary for expressed cell mode Boundary for unexpressed cell mode -
Constraints improve the model fit • Green – unconstrainted •
Red -- constrained 31 -
GammaGateR in subsequent analyses • GammaGateR yields posterior probabilities of
cells being in the “expressed” population • These can be used to compute cell proportions, thresholded to define cell types, or used directly in downstream analysis • QR code links to tutorial using Julia’s ovarian cancer dataset 32 -
Thank you • Colleagues: Robert Coffey, Ken Lau, Martha Shrubsole,
Eliot McKinley, Joe Roland, Qi Liu, Coleman Harris, Ruby Xiong • Funding: Vanderbilt Ingram Cancer Center GI SPORE: P50CA236733, NLM 5T32LM012412-05, R01MH123563 Simon Vandekar 33