Share
Embed
Painless UI Testing
What if you could get your UI tests to run as fast as your unit tests?
Using patterns of yore (like Martin Fowler's supervising controller, effective use of presenters and view model state) we're going to tackle everyday-real-annoying impediments to UI testing. We'll address what parts of the UI need testing and effective ways of testing them.
Kaushik Gopal
August 28, 2015
Transcript
38 slides
-
Why is it Painful? Human beings suck at repetitive work
courtesy: soundtrackdreams.com -
Why is it Painful? Human beings suck at repetitive work
GUIs are tightly linked to the framework Tools and framework Speed - Test feedback loop -
Try testing as much as you can off the device
2 Suggestions? Use the JVM! -
• Passive View • Supervising Controller The Fowler way! http://martinfowler.com/eaaDev/PassiveScreen.html
http://martinfowler.com/eaaDev/SupervisingPresenter.html http://martinfowler.com/eaaDev/ -
LOGIN Login Activity Button .OnClick() LoginController.java .onLoginButtonClicked( username, password) interface
ITalkToLoginScreen .showError(errorMsg) .moveToWelcomeScreen() Activity Controller View Interface AuthService.java .checkUsername() .checkPassword() Some Service Presenter implements ITalkToLoginScreen .showError -> setText(errorMsg) .moveToWelcomeScreen -> switch Fragments LoginPresenter. java .getErrorFor(code) -
JVM Testable LOGIN Login Activity Button .OnClick() LoginController.java .onLoginButtonClicked( username,
password) interface ITalkToLoginScreen .showError(errorMsg) .moveToWelcomeScreen() Activity Controller View Interface AuthService.java .checkUsername() .checkPassword() Some Service Presenter implements ITalkToLoginScreen .showError -> setText(errorMsg) .moveToWelcomeScreen -> switch Fragments LoginPresenter. java .getErrorFor(code) -
LoginController.java .onLoginButtonClicked( username, password) ITalkToLoginScreen.java .showError(errorMsg) .moveToWelcomeScreen() Controller View Interface
controller = new LoginController(talkToLsMock); verify(_talkToTLSMock) .showError("Asking to get hacked?"); controller .onLoginButtonClicked( "[email protected]", "superWeakPassword" ); controller = new LoginController(talkToLsMock); controller .onLoginButtonClicked( "[email protected]", "superWeakPassword" ); R.string.error_message @Test -
LoginController.java .onLoginButtonClicked( username, password) ITalkToLoginScreen.java .showError(errorMsg) .moveToWelcomeScreen() Controller View Interface
verify(_talkToTLSMock) .moveToWelcomeScreen(); @Test controller = new LoginController(talkToLsMock); controller .onLoginButtonClicked( "[email protected]", "M4Y_the-‐4Ce_Be_W1tH_U_!@#" ); controller .onLoginButtonClicked( "[email protected]", "M4Y_the-‐4Ce_Be_W1tH_U_!@#" ); -
LoginPresenter.java .getErrorFor(code) Presenter LoginPresenter presenter =
new TaskListPresenter(); assertThat(presenter.getErrorCode(enumCode) .isEqualTo("[Wed] 9:00 AM [1985]"); -
public class TaskCreatePresenter {
} public String getDueDateText( DateTime dueDateTime){...} Example 1 Fuzzy due dates public String getDueDateDiffText( DateTime dueDateTime) {...} -
@Test public void IncreaseBy_6HRS() { TaskCreatePresenter taskCreatePresenter =
new TaskCreatePresenter(); } assertThat(taskCreatePresenter .getDueDateText(dueDate)) .isEqualTo("Aug 25 [Tue] 12:58 AM"); assertThat(taskCreatePresenter .getDueDateDiffText(dueDate) .isEqualTo("(~6 Hrs)"); Example 1 Fuzzy due dates DateTime dueDate = now.plus6Hours(); @Test public void IncreaseBy_6HRS() { TaskCreatePresenter taskCreatePresenter = new TaskCreatePresenter(); } DateTime dueDate = now.plus6Hours(); assertThat(taskCreatePresenter .getDueDateText(dueDate)) .isEqualTo("Aug 25 [Tue] 12:58 AM"); -
TaskCreateFragment @OnClick(R.id.increase_hr) @OnClick(R.id.increase_hr) public void onIncreaseBy1HrClicked() {
taskCreateController.changeDueDateBy(PLUS, HOURS, 1); } Example 1 Fuzzy due dates -
TaskCreateFragment @OnClick(R.id.increase_hr) TaskCreateController.java public void changeDueDateBy(...) { dueDateTime
= now + changes in time; String dueDateText = (from presenter) String dueDateDiffText = (from presenter) iTalkToTaskCreateScreen (view interface) .updateDueDateDisplay(dueDateText, dueDateDiffText); } Example 1 Fuzzy due dates -
TaskCreateFragment @OnClick(R.id.increase_hr) TaskCreateController.java void changeDueDateBy() { iTalkToTaskCreateScreen .updateDueDateDisplay() } interface
ITalkToTaskCreateScreen.java .updateDueDateDisplay() .closeCreateScreen() Example 1 Fuzzy due dates TaskCreatePresenter TaskCreatePresenter. java -
TaskCreatePresenter TaskCreatePresenter. java TaskCreateFragment @OnClick(R.id.increase_hr) TaskCreateController.java void changeDueDateBy() { iTalkToTaskCreateScreen
.updateDueDateDisplay() } Example 1 Fuzzy due dates public interface ITalkToTaskCreateScreen { void updateDueDateDisplay( String dueDateText, String dueDiffDisplayText); void closeCreateScreen(); } -
Fuzzy due dates TaskCreateFragment @OnClick(R.id.increase_hr) TaskCreateController.java void changeDueDateBy() { iTalkToTaskCreateScreen
.updateDueDateDisplay() } interface ITalkToTaskCreateScreen.java .updateDueDateDisplay() .closeCreateScreen() implements ITalkToTaskCreateScreen .updateDueDateDisplay -> setText(date + diff) .closeCreateScreen -> popBackStack Example 1 TaskCreatePresenter TaskCreatePresenter. java -
implements ITalkToTaskCreateScreen .updateDueDateDisplay -> setText(date + diff) .closeCreateScreen ->
popBackStack TaskCreateFragment @OnClick(R.id.increase_hr) TaskCreateController.java void changeDueDateBy() { iTalkToTaskCreateScreen .updateDueDateDisplay() } interface ITalkToTaskCreateScreen .updateDueDateDisplay() .closeCreateScreen() @Override public void updateDueDateDisplay(dueDateText, dueDiffDisplayText) { _dueDisplay.setText(dueDateText + dueDiffDisplayText); } @Override public void closeCreateScreen() { getFragmentManager().popBackStack(); } Example 1 Fuzzy due dates TaskCreatePresenter TaskCreatePresenter. java -
Example 2 Alternate & Distinct Week coloring Week 1 Week
2 Week 4 Week 5 Week 0 Week 6 Week 10 Week 12 1 2 Consecutive weeks - different color Not necessarily directly consecutive -
Example 2 Alternate & Distinct Week coloring 1 Consecutive weeks
- different color @Test public void DueDateTimeColor_ShouldAlternateBetweenDifferentWeeks() { DateTime someFutureDate = ...; } @Test public void DueDateTimeColor_ShouldAlternateBetweenDifferentWeeks() { DateTime someFutureDate = ...; } List<Task> tasks = new ArrayList<>(); Task t1 = aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate)) Task t2 = aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(8))) tasks.add(t1); tasks.add(t2); int firstColor = presenter.getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(tasks, 0); int secondColor = presenter.getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(tasks, 1); assertThat(firstColor).isNotEqualTo(secondColor); List<Task> tasks = new ArrayList<>(); Task t1 = aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate)) Task t2 = aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(8))) tasks.add(t1); tasks.add(t2); int firstColor = presenter.getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(tasks, 0); int secondColor = presenter.getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(tasks, 1); -
Example 2 Alternate & Distinct Week coloring 2 Not necessarily
directly consecutive @Test public void DueDateTimeColor_ShouldAlternateBetweenDifferent_NotNecessarilyConsecutiveWeeks() { } int taskColor1 = presenter.getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(tasks, 0); int taskColor2 = presenter.getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(tasks, 1); int taskColor3 = presenter.getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(tasks, 2); int taskColor4 = presenter.getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(tasks, 3); // .... @Test public void DueDateTimeColor_ShouldAlternateBetweenDifferent_NotNecessarilyConsecutiveWeeks() { } DateTime someFutureDate = ...; List<Task> tasks = new ArrayList<>(); tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate)).build()); // t1 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(6))).build()); // t2 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(7))).build()); // t3 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(8))).build()); // t4 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(9))).build()); // t5 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(12))).build());// t6 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(13))).build());// t7 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(14))).build());// t8 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(28))).build());// t9 DateTime someFutureDate = ...; List<Task> tasks = new ArrayList<>(); tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate)).build()); // t1 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(6))).build()); // t2 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(7))).build()); // t3 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(8))).build()); // t4 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(9))).build()); // t5 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(12))).build());// t6 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(13))).build());// t7 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(14))).build());// t8 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(28))).build());// t9 -
Example 2 Alternate & Distinct Week coloring 2 Not necessarily
directly consecutive assertThat(taskColor1).isEqualTo(taskColor2); // 6 day difference (within week) assertThat(taskColor2).isNotEqualTo(taskColor3); // 1 day diff (crosses to next week) assertThat(taskColor3).isEqualTo(taskColor4); // 1 day diff (same week) assertThat(taskColor4).isEqualTo(taskColor5); // 1 day diff (same week) assertThat(taskColor5).isEqualTo(taskColor6); // 1 day diff (same week) assertThat(taskColor6).isEqualTo(taskColor7); // 1 day diff (same week) assertThat(taskColor7).isNotEqualTo(taskColor8); // cross to next week assertThat(taskColor8).isNotEqualTo(taskColor9); // cross to 2 weeks from last task tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate)).build()); tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(6))).build()); tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(7))).build()); // t3 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(8))).build()); // t4 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(9))).build()); // t5 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(12))).build());// t6 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(13))).build());// t7 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(14))).build());// t8 tasks.add(aTask().withDueDate(getDateFor(someFutureDate.plusDays(28))).build());// t9 -
Example 2 Alternate & Distinct Week coloring 2 Not necessarily
directly consecutive public class TaskListPresenter { @ColorRes public int getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(List<Task> tasks, int position) { } } // or return R.color.blue; // or return R.color.gray_2; // write the fancy logic and // .... return R.color.orange_1; public class TaskListPresenter { @ColorRes public int getDueDayTimeColorIdFor(List<Task> tasks, int position) { } } -
More examples github.com/kaushikgopal/rem still private send me a tweet @kaushikgopal
and i'll add you to the repo 3 -
Conclusion • I mean... would you really do this? •
So no Espresso ? • Data Binding? • Some things are just plain hard to test • Flaky tests are worse than no tests • Don't test Android SDK or libraries