Share
Embed
Unlocking Potential of Property Based Testing with Ractor
RubyKaigi 2024
- Event page: https://rubykaigi.org/2024/presentations/ohbarye.html
- Ruby gem: https://github.com/ohbarye/pbt
Masato Ohba
May 15, 2024
Transcript
89 slides
-
✅ &BTZUPXSJUFBOEVOEFSTUBOE ✅ 6TFGVMUPFOTVSFPVSQSPHSBN XPSLTBTFYQFDUFE ❌ 0OMZ fi OETCVHTUIBUB
QSPHSBNNFSQSFEJDUFE &YBNQMFCBTFEUFTUJOH 8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH 8IBUJGBOFNQUZBSSBZJTHJWFO -
w (FOFSBUFIVOESFET UIPVTBOETPGUFTUJOQVUT BUSBOEPN w %FTDSJCFUFTUUBSHFUT QSPQFSUZ OPUBOFYBNQMF 1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH
8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH 3BOEPNJTO`USFBMMZSBOEPN$POUSPMMFEBOESFQSPEVDJCMFSBOEPNOFTT -
1SPQFSUZ 8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH w "QSPQFSUZDBOCF FYQSFTTFEBTGPMMPX w GPSBOZ Y Z
TVDIUIBU QSFDPOEJUJPO Y Z IPMET QSFEJDBUF Y Z JT USVF 2 -
4ISJOLJOH 8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH w *UUSJFTUPTISJOLUIF GBJMFEWBMVFTPUIBUZPV DBOEFCVHXJUIFBTF w *USFQFBUTTISJOL QSPDFTTVOUJMJU
fi OET UIFNJOJNVN DPVOUFSFYBNQMF 3 -FUTTFFEFNPMBUFS -
#FOF fi UTPGQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH 8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH w $BOUFTUNPSFJOQVUT w $BOUFTUNPSFEJWFSTF JOQVUT
w $BOF ff PSUMFTTMZ fi OE DPVOUFSFYBNQMFT -
8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH &YBNQMFCBTFEUFTUJOH 1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH $PEFMJOFT ❌3FEVOEBOU ✅$PODJTF $PWFSBHF ❌%FQFOETPOQSPHSBNNFST ✅.PSFEJWFSTFJOQVUT
-FBSOJOHDVSWF ✅&BTZUPVOEFSTUBOE ❌)BSEUPNBTUFS &YFDVUJPOUJNF ✅'BTU ❌5BLFTNPSFUJNF $PNQBSJTPO -
2%PFTJUSFQMBDFFYJTUJOHUFTUTDPNQMFUFMZ "/P 8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH 5IFPSJHJOBMDIBSUJTIUUQTNFEJVNDPNDSJUFPFOHJOFFSJOHJOUSPEVDUJPOUPQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHGE &YBNQMFCBTFEUFTUJOHIFMQTVT CFDPO fi EFOUUIBUPVSDPEFQFSGPSNT BTXFFYQFDU
1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHIFMQTVT FYQMPSFUIFCFIBWJPSPGBQSPHSBNUP TFFXIBUJUDBOBOEDBOUEP BOE EFUFSNJOFXIFUIFSPVSBTTVNQUJPOT BSFDPSSFDU -
w *UTIJTUPSZJTMPOH w IUUQTJFFFYQMPSFJFFFPSH EPDVNFOU w IUUQTEMBDNPSHEPJBCT
w IUUQTEMBDNPSHEPJ 2%PFTJUIBWFUSBDLSFDPSET ":FT BMPU 8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH -
w 'V[[JOHJTGFFEJOHBQJFDFPGDPEF GVODUJPO QSPHSBN FUD EBUB GSPNBMBSHFDPSQVT QPTTJCMZEZOBNJDBMMZHFOFSBUFE QPTTJCMZ
EFQFOEFOUPOUIFSFTVMUTPGFYFDVUJPOPOQSFWJPVTEBUB JOPSEFS UPTFFXIFUIFSJUGBJMT w 1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHJTUIFDPOTUSVDUJPOPGUFTUTTVDIUIBU XIFOUIFTFUFTUTBSFGV[[FE GBJMVSFTJOUIFUFTUSFWFBMQSPCMFNT XJUIUIFTZTUFNVOEFSUFTUUIBUDPVMEOPUIBWFCFFOSFWFBMFECZ EJSFDUGV[[JOHPGUIBUTZTUFN 28IBUBCPVUGV[[JOH 8IBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH IUUQTIZQPUIFTJTXPSLTBSUJDMFTXIBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH -
w $BTFXIFOSVOOJOHTPNF$16 CPVOEJTPMBUFEUBTLT w "TGPS5ISFBE BOVNCFSPG QBSBMMFMJTNJTBUNPTUEVFUP(7- .VMUJUISFBEJOHEPFTOUTQFFEVQ $16CPVOEUBTLTJOHFOFSBM
w #VU3BDUPSDBOQBSBMMFMJ[FVQUPB OVNCFSPG$16DPSFT 8IBULJOEPGVTFDBTFJTTVJUBCMFGPS3BDUPS )PXEPFT3BDUPSVOMPDLUIFQPUFOUJBM -
w *USVOTIVOESFETPGUFTUDBTFT w &BDIDBTFEPFTOUEFQFOEPO QSFWJPVTPSTVCTFRVFOUDBTFT w -PUTPGUBTLTUIBUEPOU JOUFSGFSFFBDIPUIFS 8IBUBCPVUQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH
)PXEPFT3BDUPSVOMPDLUIFQPUFOUJBM 5IJTUBMLGPDVTFTPOTUBUFMFTTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHPOMZ *UTFFNTBHPPEDBOEJEBUFPGBVTFDBTFPG3BDUPS -
w *GFBDIJUFSBUJPOUBLFT NT PWFSBMMFYFDVUJPO UBLFT/UJNFTTMPXFS w &YJTUJOHNPTUQSPQFSUZ CBTFEUFTUJOHUPPMTSVO UFTUTTFRVFOUJBMMZ
)PXEPFT3BDUPSVOMPDLUIFQPUFOUJBM $PEFMJOFT ✅-FTTDPEF $PWFSBHF ✅.PSFEJWFSTFJOQVUT -FBSOJOHDPTU ❌)BSEUPNBTUFS &YFDVUJPOUJNF ❌5BLFNPSFUJNF 3FDBQQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHTXFBLQPJOUT -
1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHUPPMIUUQTHJUIVCDPNPICBSZFQCU 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT $SFEJU3VCZFDPTZTUFNBMSFBEZIBTQSJPSXPSLT IUUQTHJUIVCDPN2RXZSVCZQSPQ@DIFDL IUUQTHJUIVCDPNSBOUMZSCSBOUMZ w 5IFHFNEPFTOUBJNUP w TQFFEVQFYJTUJOHFYBNQMFCBTFEUFTUT
w SFJNQMFNFOUBUFTUJOHGSBNFXPSL w 5IFHFNBJNTUP w BMMPXZPVUPXSJUFQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUT XJUIFBTF w SVOUIPTFUFTUTDPODVSSFOUMZJGOFDFTTBSZ -
5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 1SPQFSUZ !QSFEJDBUF !BSCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL SVO 3VOOFS BTTFSU
DIFDL 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS !SVO@EFUBJMT SFQPSU@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL 3VOOFS*UFSBUPS !SVO@FYFDVUJPO !QSPQFSUZ 3VO&YFDVUJPO !GBJMVSFT !FYFDVUJPO@USFFT UP@SVO@EFUBJMT $SFEJU*SFGFSSFEGBTUDIFDLTEFTJHOIUUQTGBTUDIFDLEFW *OUFSOBMEFTJHOPG -
5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 1SPQFSUZ !QSFEJDBUF !BSCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL SVO 3VOOFS BTTFSU
DIFDL 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS !SVO@EFUBJMT SFQPSU@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL 3VOOFS*UFSBUPS !SVO@FYFDVUJPO !QSPQFSUZ 3VO&YFDVUJPO !GBJMVSFT !FYFDVUJPO@USFFT UP@SVO@EFUBJMT 3VOOFS3VOOFS*UFSBUPS 1 5IFZIBOEMFUIFUFTUJOH fl PX (FOFSBUFJOJUJBMWBMVFT 3VOBUFTU 3FDPSESFTVMU 4ISJOLJGBUFTUGBJMT -
5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 1SPQFSUZ !QSFEJDBUF !BSCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL SVO 3VOOFS BTTFSU
DIFDL 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS !SVO@EFUBJMT SFQPSU@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL 3VOOFS*UFSBUPS !SVO@FYFDVUJPO !QSPQFSUZ 3VO&YFDVUJPO3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS 3VO&YFDVUJPOIPMET UFTUSFTVMU 'BJMFEWBMVFTBOE FYDFQUJPOTFUD 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS GPSNBUTSFTVMUGPS QSPHSBNNFST 2 3VO&YFDVUJPO !GBJMVSFT !FYFDVUJPO@USFFT UP@SVO@EFUBJMT -
5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 1SPQFSUZ !QSFEJDBUF !BSCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL SVO 3VOOFS BTTFSU
DIFDL 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS !SVO@EFUBJMT SFQPSU@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL 3VOOFS*UFSBUPS !SVO@FYFDVUJPO !QSPQFSUZ 3VO&YFDVUJPO !GBJMVSFT !FYFDVUJPO@USFFT UP@SVO@EFUBJMT 1SPQFSUZ 3 -
5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 1SPQFSUZ !QSFEJDBUF !BSCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL SVO 3VOOFS BTTFSU
DIFDL 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS !SVO@EFUBJMT SFQPSU@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL 3VOOFS*UFSBUPS !SVO@FYFDVUJPO !QSPQFSUZ 3VO&YFDVUJPO !GBJMVSFT !FYFDVUJPO@USFFT UP@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ 4 -
5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 1SPQFSUZ !QSFEJDBUF !BSCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL SVO 3VOOFS BTTFSU
DIFDL 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS !SVO@EFUBJMT SFQPSU@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL 3VOOFS*UFSBUPS !SVO@FYFDVUJPO !QSPQFSUZ 3VO&YFDVUJPO !GBJMVSFT !FYFDVUJPO@USFFT UP@SVO@EFUBJMT %JWFJOUP"SCJUSBSZ -
5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 1SPQFSUZ !QSFEJDBUF !BSCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL SVO 3VOOFS BTTFSU
DIFDL 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS !SVO@EFUBJMT SFQPSU@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL 3VOOFS*UFSBUPS !SVO@FYFDVUJPO !QSPQFSUZ 3VO&YFDVUJPO !GBJMVSFT !FYFDVUJPO@USFFT UP@SVO@EFUBJMT %JWFJOUP1SPQFSUZ -
*OUFSOBMEFTJHO8IZ 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 1SPQFSUZ !QSFEJDBUF !BSCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL SVO 3VOOFS
BTTFSU DIFDL 3VO%FUBJMT3FQPSUFS !SVO@EFUBJMT SFQPSU@SVO@EFUBJMT "SCJUSBSZ HFOFSBUF TISJOL 3VOOFS*UFSBUPS !SVO@FYFDVUJPO !QSPQFSUZ 3VO&YFDVUJPO !GBJMVSFT !FYFDVUJPO@USFFT UP@SVO@EFUBJMT 1 2 3 4 $PODVSSFODZJTBCPVUTUSVDUVSF XIFSFBTQBSBMMFMJTNJTBCPVUFYFDVUJPO &YJTUJOH3VCZHFNTGPSQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHEPFTOUIBWFBTUSVDUVSFGPSUIBU IUUQTHPDPNJYJOHVQDPODVSSFODZBOEQBSBMMFMJTN -
4VQQPSUNVMUJQMFDPODVSSFODZNPEFMT 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 5IJTGFBUVSFJTGPSBCFODINBSLSBUIFSUIBOVTBCJMJUZ-FUTMPPLJOUPJUMBUFS w OPOF w SBDUPS w QSPDFTT
w UISFBE 5IJTGFBUVSFVTFTQBSBMMFMHFNXIFOVTJOHAQSPDFTTAPSAUISFBEAIUUQTHJUIVCDPNHSPTTFSQBSBMMFM 3 -
w 6TF1SJTN w *UIBTBGFBUVSFUPXBMLUISPVHI BOZOPEFPGBTZOUBYUSFF w 5IJTGFBUVSFBMMPXTVTUPPCUBJO BDPEFGSPNBOZQBTTFEQSPD )PXUPPCUBJOBVTFSEF
fi OFEDPEFCMPDLBT4USJOH 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT -
"DUVBMDPEFMPPLT 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT w *OPSEFSUPEF fi OF BNFUIPEXJUI DMBTT@FWBM XF
OFFENFUIPE QBSBNTBOECPEZ BT4USJOHT -
4UJMMOPUFOPVHI 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT *GZPVXBOUUPSFBEUIFBDUVBMDPEF TFFIUUQTHJUIVCDPNPICBSZFQCUQVMM 34QFDVTFTABVUPMPBEACVUJUTQSPIJCJUFEUP ASFRVJSFAJOB3BDUPS*OFFEUPQSFMPBE 34QFDNBUDIFSTFUTNPEVMFWBSJBCMFT 4LJQJUJOOPONBJO3BDUPSBOEDBMMJU MBUFSJONBJO3BDUPS
5IFTFNBHJDTBMMPXVTUPVTF 34QFD.BUDIFSJO3BDUPS -
#FODINBSLGPSDPODVSSFODZNPEFMTYUFTUUBSHFUT 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT 8PSLFS 8PSLFSDPVOU *OUIJT CFODINBSL 3BDUPS PGDBTFT
PSNPSF 1SPDFTT PGDPSFTPOBNBDIJOF 5ISFBE PGDPSFTPOBNBDIJOF /POF 0OF+VTUSVOTBMMDBTFT TFRVFOUJBMMZ -
4JNQMFUBTL 4JNQMFUBTLCVUGBJMVSF w /FJUIFS$16CPVOEOPS*0CPVOE w *UKVTUSVOTBUFTUUJNFTGPSFBDIHFOFSBUFEWBMVF w /FJUIFS$16CPVOEOPS*0CPVOE w
4ISJOLJOHIBQQFOTUJNFTXJUIBHJWFOTFFE UFTUUBSHFUT 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT -
$16CPVOE *0CPVOE w 5BSBJGVODUJPOXJUI XIJDIDBVTFT UJNFTNFUIPEDBMMT
w 5IJTCFODINBSLVTFTADPOTUBOUABSCJUSBSZ UP fi YJOQVUWBMVFT w *USFBETB fi MFUIBUDPOUBJOTQBSBHSBQIT XPSET CZUFT w *XBOUFEUPDBMMBOFUXPSL%#DBMMIFSFCVU XBTOUBCMFEVFUP3BDUPSTMJNJUBUJPOT 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT -
*UFSBUJPOTQFSTFDPOECFODINBSL IUUQTHJUIVCDPNPICBSZFQCUCMPCDFGBFBFBBDGBCCGCFODINBSL3&"%.&NE w NBD04 "QQMF.1SP DPSFT QFSGPSNBODFBOE
F ffi DJFODZ w SVCZ SFWJTJPO DDE ./ <BSNEBSXJO> w QCUDPNNJUIBTI FDBFDDFCB FECBEGG EDGEB 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT -
1028 1534 2425 w 4FRVFOUJBMQSPDFTTJOH JTGBTUFOPVHI w 3BDUPSFNFSHFTBTB DIBNQJPOXIFOBUFTU
UBSHFUJT$16CPVOE w .VMUJQSPDFTTUISFBE XPOOPOFPGSBDFT 0WFSBMMPCTFSWBUJPO 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT -
1028 1534 2425 UJNFT GBTUFS UJNFT TMPXFS UJNFT TMPXFS
UJNFT TMPXFS w 3BDUPSJTYGBTUFS GPSUIF$16CPVOE UBTL w 3BDUPSJTYY TMPXFSGPSPUIFSUBTLT 3BDUPSWTTFRVFOUJBM 5FTUJOHUPPMJNQMFNFOUBUJPOUPWFSJGZUIFIZQPUIFTJT -
w *OCFODINBSLT 3BDUPSXJOT$16CPVOEUBTLPOMZ w %J ff i DVMUJFTBOEJTTVFTPG3BDUPSJOSFBMXPSME
$BO3BDUPSVOMPDLUIFQPUFOUJBMPGQSPQFSUZCBTFE UFTUJOH 'JOEJOHT 'JOEJOHT 1 2 -
w 1BSUJBMMZ ZFT w "CPVUYGBTUFSUIBOTFRVFOUJBMUFTUQSPDFTTJOH w 0OMZXIFOUIFUFTUUBSHFUNFFUTUIFTFDPOEJUJPOT w $16CPVOE
w 3BDUPSDPNQBUJCMF $BO3BDUPSVOMPDLUIFQPUFOUJBMPGQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH 'JOEJOHT -
w !LPTBOQPJOUFEPVU JTTVFTJO3VCZ,BJHJ w 5IFOEJTUIFCJHHFTU JTTVFUPVTFSTMJLFNF %J ffi DVMUJFTBOEJTTVFTPG3BDUPSJOSFBMXPSME
'JOEJOHT IUUQTBUEPUOFUdLPBDUJWJUJFT@SVCZLBJHJQEG IUUQTSVCZLBJHJPSHQSFTFOUBUJPOTLPIUNM 2 -
w *UTIBSEUP fi OEPVUBO JOEFQFOEFOUBOEJTPMBUFE QSPDFTTJOHUBTL PSUP SFGBDUPSPVSDPEFUPCFTP 3BDUPSTMJNJUBUJPOT
'JOEJOHT IUUQTTQFBLFSEFDLDPNN@TFLJMFBSOSBDUPS IUUQTSVCZLBJHJPSHQSFTFOUBUJPOTN@TFLJIUNM .PTU3VCZDPEFUIBUXFXSJUFVTFEPFTOUXPSLPO3BDUPS -
$BOULOPXXIFUIFSB3VCZ DPEFJT3BDUPSDPNQBUJCMF PSOPUBUBHMBODF 5PXBSET3BDUPSDPNQBUJCMFFDPTZTUFN 'JOEJOHT 3BDUPSDPNQBUJCJMJUZMBCFMPSBTTFSUJPO 3BDUPSXFMDPNFMBCFM &WFOJGOPOVTFSDPEFJTOPU 3BDUPSDPNQBUJCMF
TIPVME XF fi YJUPOVQTUSFBN w 3BJTFBOFSSPSTBZJOH*UTOPU3BDUPSDPNQBUJCMF XIFOSVOOJOHPOOPONBJO3BDUPS w 4UBUJDBOBMZTJTPS$* HFNTQFD SVCZTQFDFUD w .BLJOHJU3BDUPSDPNQBUJCMFNBZSFRVJSFTJHOJ fi DBOUDPEF DIBOHFT w "UMFBTUGPSTUBOEBSEEFGBVMUCVOEMFEHFNT *EMPWFUPLOPX BQPMJDZPGXIFUIFSJUETVQQPSU3BDUPS -
3FGFSFODFT1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH w 5FTUJOH"TZODISPOPVT"1*T8JUI2VJDL$IFDL w IUUQTXXXFSMBOHGBDUPSZDPNTUBUJDVQMPBENFEJBQCUFSMBOHGBDUPSZQQUYQEG w 2VJDL$IFDL"4JMWFS#VMMFUGPSUFTUJOH w
IUUQTIUNMQSFWJFXHJUIVCJP IUUQTSBXHJUIVCDPNTUSBOHFMPPQMBNCEBKBNNBTUFSTMJEFT/PSUPO2VJDL$IFDLIUNM w *OUSPEVDUJPOUP1SPQFSUZ#BTFE5FTUJOH w IUUQTNFEJVNDPNDSJUFPFOHJOFFSJOHJOUSPEVDUJPOUPQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHGE w 1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHPGQSJWJMFHFEQSPHSBNT w IUUQTJFFFYQMPSFJFFFPSHEPDVNFOU w 1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHBOFXBQQSPBDIUPUFTUJOHGPSBTTVSBODF w IUUQTEMBDNPSHEPJBCT w 2VJDL$IFDLBMJHIUXFJHIUUPPMGPSSBOEPNUFTUJOHPG)BTLFMMQSPHSBNT w IUUQTEMBDNPSHEPJ w 8IBUJT1SPQFSUZ#BTFE5FTUJOH w IUUQTIZQPUIFTJTXPSLTBSUJDMFTXIBUJTQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOH w IUUQTGBTUDIFDLEFW w 1SPQFSUZ#BTFE5FTUJOHXJUI1SPQ&S &SMBOH BOE&MJYJS w IUUQTQSBHQSPHDPNUJUMFTGIQSPQFSQSPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHXJUIQSPQFSFSMBOHBOEFMJYJS -
3FGFSFODFT1SPQFSUZCBTFEUFTUJOHUPPMT w 3VCZ1SPQ$IFDL 3VCZ w IUUQTHJUIVCDPN2RXZSVCZ QSPQ@DIFDL w
3BOUMZ 3VCZ w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNSBOUMZSCSBOUMZ w TUSFBN@EBUB &MJYJS w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNXIBUZPVIJEF TUSFBN@EBUB w QSPQDIFDL &MJYJS w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNBMGFSUQSPQDIFDL w 2VJYJS &MJYJS w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNQSBHEBWFRVJYJS w GBTUDIFDL +BWB4DSJQU 5ZQF4DSJQU w IUUQTGBTUDIFDLEFW w SBQJE (P w IUUQTHJUIVCDPN fl ZJOHNVUBOUSBQJE w HPQUFS (P w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNMFBOPWBUFHPQUFS w UFTUDIFDL $MPKVSF w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNDMPKVSFUFTUDIFDL w 4DBMB$IFDL 4DBMB w IUUQTTDBMBDIFDLPSH w 1SPQ&S &SMBOH w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNQSPQFSUFTUJOHQSPQFS -
3FGFSFODFT3BDUPS w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNSVCZSVCZCMPCW@@EPDSBDUPSNE w IUUQTEPDTSVCZMBOHPSHFONBTUFS3BDUPSIUNM w 3BDUPS3FDPOTJEFSFE w IUUQTBUEPUOFUdLPBDUJWJUJFT@SVCZLBJHJQEG
w IUUQTSVCZLBJHJPSHQSFTFOUBUJPOTLPIUNM w -FBSO3BDUPS 3VCZ,BJHJ w IUUQTTQFBLFSEFDLDPNN@TFLJMFBSOSBDUPS w IUUQTSVCZLBJHJPSHQSFTFOUBUJPOTN@TFLJIUNM w 3VCZιʔείʔυશղઆୈষεϨου w IUUQTJMPWFSVCZOFUKBSIHCPPLUISFBEIUNM w QBSBMMFM w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNHSPTTFSQBSBMMFM w MPVQF w IUUQTHJUIVCDPNWJOJTUPDLMPVQF w IUUQTSVCZLBJHJPSHUBLFPVUQSFTFOUBUJPOTWJOJTUPDLIUNM w IUUQTSTQFDJOGPGFBUVSFTSTQFDDPSFDPNNBOEMJOFPSEFS -
3FGFSFODFT3BDUPS w ./εϨουʹΑΔܰྔͳฒߦॲཧͷઓ w IUUQTHJIZPKQBSUJDMFSVCZNOUISFBET w 3VCZʹΑΔฒߦฒྻϓϩάϥϛϯά w IUUQTSVCZXPSMEDPOGPSH
fi MFTBQEG w 3VCZͷฒྻฒߦॲཧͷ͜Ε·Ͱͱ͜Ε͔Β w IUUQTUFDIMJGFDPPLQBEDPNFOUSZ w ϓϩͱಡΈղ͘3VCZ/&84 w IUUQTUFDIMJGFDPPLQBEDPNFOUSZ w 3VCZͷ3BDUPSΛࣗຫ͍ͨ͠ w IUUQTUFDIMJGFDPPLQBEDPNFOUSZ w 3VCZʹ4PGUXBSF5SBOTBDUJPOBM.FNPSZ 45. ΛೖΕΑ͏ͱࢥͬͨ w IUUQTUFDIMJGFDPPLQBEDPNFOUSZ