Spring Kafka beyond the basics - Lessons learned on our Kafka journey at ING Bank

Slides for my talk at Spring I/O.

https://2022.springio.net/sessions/spring-kafka-beyond-the-basics-lessons-learned-on-our-kafka-journey-at-ing-bank

Source code demo: https://github.com/j-tim/spring-io-barcelona-2022-spring-kafka-beyond-the-basics

Transcript

1. Spring Kafka beyond the basics Lessons learned on our Kafka journey at ING Bank Tim van Baarsen SPRING I/O BARCELONA – MAY 27TH 2022
2. Who am I? Tim van Baarsen Software Engineer @ ING Netherlands The Netherlands Team Dora Amsterdam
3. ING is active in more than 40 counties 3
4. Kafka @ ING 4 Frontrunners in Kafka Running in production: • 7 years • 5000+ topics • Serving 850+ Development teams • Self service topic management
5. Kafka @ ING 5 0 100.000 200.000 300.000 400.000 500.000 600.000 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Messages produced per second (average) Messages produced per second (average) Traffic is growing with 10%+ monthly
6. Agenda 6 • Kafka in a nutshell • Spring Kafka essentials • Scenario: Poison pill / Deserialization exceptions • Scenario: Lack of exception handling • Testing • Monitoring • Wrap-up • Questions
7. Kafka in a nutshell 7 Consumer Consumer Producer Kafka client Kafka broker Consumer Kafka client 0100101001101 0100101001101 poll send Responsibilities: - subscribe - deserialization • key • Value - heartbeat Not responsible for: • Type checking • Schema validation • Other constraints Responsibilities: - send - serialization • key • value 0 1 2 3 4 5 old 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 0 1 2 3 topic: ‘stock- quotes’ Partition 0 Partition 1 Partition 2 Data in a Kafka topic are just stored as bytes! new Responsible for: • Append only log • Distribute • Replicate
8. Kafka in a nutshell Consumer Consumer Producer Kafka client Kafka broker Consumer Kafka client 0100101001101 0100101001101 poll send 0 1 2 3 4 5 old 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 0 1 2 3 topic: ‘stock- quotes’ Partition 0 Partition 1 Partition 2 new Confluent Schema Registry REST API Load schema Responsible for: • Schema validation • Avro • Protobuf • Json schema KafkaAvroSerializer KafkaAvroDeserializer
9. Spring for Apache Kafka - essentials 9 Kafka Kafka Clients Listener Container Error Handling Deserializer spring-kafka- test User Code Error Handler ConsumerRecord Recoverer KafkaTemplate @KafkaListener Consumer Producer Kafka Spring Kafka Your code @EmbeddedKafka https://spring.io/projects/spring-kafka Kafka Streams @EnableKafkaStreams
10. Spring Kafka & Spring Boot - Producer 10 @Component @Slf4j public class StockQuoteProducer { @Autowired private KafkaTemplate<String, StockQuote> kafkaTemplate; public void produce(StockQuote stockQuote) { kafkaTemplate.send("stock-quotes", stockQuote.getSymbol(), stockQuote); log.info("Produced stock quote: {}", stockQuote); } }
11. Spring Kafka & Spring Boot - Consumer 11 @Component @Slf4j public class StockQuoteProducer { @Autowired private KafkaTemplate<String, StockQuote> kafkaTemplate; public void produce(StockQuote stockQuote) { kafkaTemplate.send("stock-quotes", stockQuote.getSymbol(), stockQuote); log.info("Produced stock quote: {}", stockQuote); } } @Component @Slf4j public class StockQuoteConsumer { @KafkaListener(topics = "stock-quotes") public void on(StockQuote stockQuote, @Header(KafkaHeaders.RECEIVED_PARTITION_ID) String partition) { log.info("Consumed from partition: {} value: {}", partition, stockQuote); } }
12. Spring Kafka & Spring Boot – Kafka streams 12 @Configuration @EnableKafkaStreams public class KafkaStreamsConfig { @Bean public KStream<String, StockQuote> kStream(StreamsBuilder streamsBuilder) { KStream<String, StockQuote> branchedStream = new KafkaStreamBrancher<String, StockQuote>() .branch((key, value) -> value.getExchange().equalsIgnoreCase("NYSE"), kStream -> kStream.to("stock-quotes-nyse")) .branch((key, value) -> value.getExchange().equalsIgnoreCase("NASDAQ"), kStream -> kStream.to("stock-quotes-nasdaq")) .branch((key, value) -> value.getExchange().equalsIgnoreCase("AMS"), kStream -> kStream.to("stock-quotes-ams")) .defaultBranch(kStream -> kStream.to("stock-quotes-exchange-other")) .onTopOf(streamsBuilder.stream("stock-quotes")); return branchedStream; } }
13. Spring Kafka & Spring Boot – Configuration (application.yml) 13 spring: application: name: producer-application kafka: bootstrap-servers: localhost:9092 producer: key-serializer: org.apache.kafka.common.serialization.StringSerializer value-serializer: io.confluent.kafka.serializers.KafkaAvroSerializer client-id: ${spring.application.name} properties: schema.registry.url: http://localhost:8081
14. After the honeymoon phase is over 14 🧨 😱 🚀 😎 Traps Lessons learned The hard way! Apply in your own project(s) Share with your fellow developers Tips & Tricks 👩💻‍‍
15. 🚀 Tip: Local development setup 15 • Docker • Kafka Cluster • Zookeeper • Confluent Schema Registry • CLI Tools • Kafka CLI, Confluent CLI, Kafka cat • UI Tools • Confluent Control Center • Kafka UI • Conduktor • etc
16. 🧨 Scenario: ‘Poison Pill’ (Deserialization exception) 16 💊 💀 Corrupted record What is a Poison Pill? Deserialization failure A record that always fails when consumed, no matter how many times it is attempted. Different forms: ❓
17. 🧨 Scenario: ‘Poison Pill’ (Deserialization exception) 17 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 old new Kafka topic: ‘stock-quotes’ Producer Kafka client Kafka broker Consumer Kafka client KafkaAvroDeserializer KafkaAvroSerializer StringSerializer 0100101001101 0100101001101 poll send Producer Kafka client send >_ 💊 Confluent Schema Registry REST API Load schema Register schema 010001101
18. 🧨 Scenario: ‘Poison Pill’ (Deserialization exception) 18 Scenario: • Consumer of topics • Someone produced a ‘poison’ message • Consumer fails to deserialize • Consequence • Blocks consumption of the topic/partition • application can’t ‘swallow the pill’ • Try again and again and again (very fast) • Log line for every failure AAPL NASDAQ $243.65 INGA AEX €10.34 NFLX NASDAQ $280.30 INGA AEX €10.66 💊 PILL ? Consumer Kafka client Consumes from: Kafka topic: ‘stock-quotes’ Consumer Another Consumer (different application)
19. 🧨 Scenario: ‘Poison Pill’ (Deserialization exception) 19 • Result: log file will grow very fast, flood your disc • Impact: High • How to survive this scenario? • Wait until the retention period of the topic has passed • Change consumer group • Manually / Programmatically update the offset • Configure ErrorHandlingDeserializer (Provided by Spring Kafka) 👎 👍 👎 👎 AAPL NASDAQ $243.65 INGA AEX €10.34 NFLX NASDAQ $280.30 INGA AEX €10.66 💊 PILL ? Consumer Kafka client Consumes from: Kafka topic: ‘stock-quotes’
20. 🧨 Scenario: ‘Poison Pill’ - Demo 20
21. 🧨 Scenario: Lack of proper exception handling 21 Scenario: • Consumer • Exception is thrown in the method handling the message Result (by default) • Records that fail are: • Retried • Logged • We move on to the next one Consequence • You lose that message! • Not acceptable in many use-cases! @KafkaListener(topics = "stock-quotes") public void on(StockQuote stockQuote) { if ("KABOOM".equalsIgnoreCase(stockQuote.getSymbol())) { throw new RuntimeException("Whoops something went wrong..."); } }
22. 🧨 Scenario: Lack of proper exception handling 22 Impact • Dependents on your use-case How to survive this scenario? • Replace / configure DefaultErrorHandler by: • CommonLoggingErrorHandler • ContainerStoppingErrorHandler • Use backoff strategy for recoverable exceptions • Configure ConsumerRecordRecoverer • Dead letter topic • Implement your own recoverer
23. 🧨 Scenario: Lack of proper exception handling - Demo 23
24. Testing 24 • Support for Integration testing @EmbeddedKafka @EmbeddedKafka @SpringJUnitConfig public class EmbeddedKafkaIntegrationTest { @Autowired private EmbeddedKafkaBroker embeddedKafkaBroker; @Test public void yourTestHere() throws Exception { // TODO implement ;) } }
25. Testing – Alternatives to EmbeddedKafka 25 • Test containers • Focus on unit test first • Kafka streams • Topology test driver
26. Testing – Test topology test driver 26 @Test void stockQuoteFromAmsterdamStockExchangeEndUpOnTopicQuotesAmsTopic() { StockQuote stockQuote = new StockQuote("INGA", "AMS", "10.99", "EUR", "Description", Instant.now()); stockQuoteInputTopic.pipeInput(stockQuote.getSymbol(), stockQuote); assertThat(stockQuoteAmsOutputTopic.isEmpty()).isFalse(); assertThat(stockQuoteAmsOutputTopic.getQueueSize()).isEqualTo(1L); assertThat(stockQuoteAmsOutputTopic.readValue()).isEqualTo(stockQuote); assertThat(stockQuoteNyseOutputTopic.isEmpty()).isTrue(); assertThat(stockQuoteNasdaqOutputTopic.isEmpty()).isTrue(); assertThat(stockQuoteOtherOutputTopic.isEmpty()).isTrue(); }
27. Monitoring - Three Pillars observability 27 Tracing Logging Metrics (Aggregatable) (Events) (Request scoped) Micrometer + Prometheus Spring Cloud + Zipkin Sleuth
28. Monitoring – Metrics 28 • Out of the box Kafka metrics • consumers • producer • streams • Micrometer • Spring Boot Actuator Metrics
29. Monitoring – Metrics 29
30. Monitoring – Distributed tracing 30
31. Monitoring – Distributed tracing 31
32. 🎓 Lessons learned 32 • Invest time in your local development environment (fast feedback loop) • Use Spring Kafka but also understand the core Kafka APIs • Consumer: • Expect the unexpected! • Handle Deserialization exceptions a.k.a. ‘poison pills’ • Proper exception handling • Validate incoming data • Producer: • Don’t change your serializers • Leverage Apache Avro + Confluent Schema registry • Don’t break compatibility for your consumers!
33. 🎓 Lessons learned 33 • Security • Who can produce data to your topics? • Who can consume? • Monitor your topics, consumer groups & applications in production • Micrometer • Spring Cloud Sleuth • Don’t overdo integration test!
34. Questions 34 🤔 ❔
35. Thanks for joining my talk! https://github.com/j-tim/spring-io-barcelona-2022-spring-kafka-beyond-the-basics @TimvanBaarsen https://www.medium.com/@TimvanBaarsen