Share
Embed
Forward Modeling IGRINS Spectra with Starfish
My vision for leveraging modern statistical and computational tools to analyze high resolution near infrared stellar spectroscopy from IGRINS.
gully
November 12, 2015
Transcript
31 slides
-
Forward modeling IGRINS spectra with Starfish Michael
Gully-‐San/ago Kavli Ins/tute for Astronomy & Astrophysics IGRINS Data Workshop and Science Mee7ng Seoul Na7onal University, Korea; November 9-‐14, 2015 Created by Muneer A.Safiah from the Noun Project Created by OliM from the Noun Project 0.36 0.32 0.28 0.24 [Fe/H] 6280 6320 6360 6400 Te↵ [K] 4.80 4.95 5.10 5.25 v sin i [km s 1] 0.35 0.30 0.25 [Fe/H] 4.80 4.95 5.10 5.25 v sin i [km s 1] -
the problem: The high spectral grasp of IGRINS is both
a compe//ve advantage and an analysis challenge: How do we use all the informa-on content in an IGRINS spectrum? -
goal: Compare IGRINS spectra of young stars to pre-‐computed stellar
model grids, to derive accurate fundamental stellar proper7es. -
why? Models provide a physical basis for the interpreta7on of
spectra. ...besides, Empirical stellar atlases in the near-‐IR with high spectral grasp do not exist yet -
Starfish is a tool for spectral inference. Likelihood Function intrinsic
stellar parameters flexible polynomials multiply model to adjust flux calibration data global and local kernels identify and downweight residuals in noise matrix + = Emulator reconstruction of model spectrum covariance matrix describing probability of spectra composite covariance matrix is sum of emulator and noise matrices model [Appendix A] extrinsic stellar parameters delivers [Section 2.2] [Section 2.3] [Section 2.3.1 & 2.3.2] [Section 2.3.3] [Section 2.2] [Section 2.1] P ✓? w C ⌅ M D ✓ext 0.6 1.2 1.8 2.4 data model 5140 5150 5160 5170 5180 5190 5200 [˚ A] 0.5 0.0 0.5 residuals f ⇥ 10 13 [erg cm 2 s 1 ˚ A 1 ] Czekala et al. 2015 hHp:/ /arxiv.org/abs/1505.01850 -
One of the main virtues of Starfish is its ability
to automatically identify and downweight spectral line outliers Czekala et al. 2015 hHp:/ /arxiv.org/abs/1505.01850 -
Current progress of Starfish on IGRINS I reproduced results from
Czekala et al. 2015 on the high resolu7on op7cal spectrum of WASP-‐14. -
Current progress of Starfish on IGRINS I have iden7fied and
corrected minor bugs in the code, and submiWed them as Pull Requests on GitHub. -
Current progress of Starfish on IGRINS I ran Starfish on
an IGRINS spectrum of GJ876, a known planet host star. The result was poor because of telluric absorp/on present in the spectrum, but unaccounted for in our model. Residual -
Current progress of Starfish on IGRINS We have acquired 10000
SUs of supercompu7ng 7me on Maverick at the Texas Advanced Compu7ng Center. -
The path forward for Starfish on IGRINS 1. Fix the
telluric absorp7on in the atmosphere (???????) 2. Coarsely flaWen spectra in the pipeline (Jae-‐Joon?) 3. Examine many spectra from the IGRINS stellar atlas project (Jeong-‐Eun Lee, Sunkyung Park, Gully) 4. Examine weak-‐lined T-‐Tauri Stars for veiling (Gully, Kidder?) 5. Recover known spectroscopic binaries (Gully, Gullikson?) 6. Examine weak-‐lined T-‐Tauri Stars for starspots (Gully, Herczeg) 7. Examine Class I spectra for photospheric lines. (Gully, KASI+) 8. Catalog and interpret spectral line outliers. (Gully, Deen?, Jaffe?, Sneden?) 9. Improve Starfish local covariance kernels (Gully, Czekala?) 10.Compare APOGEE, IGRINS, iSHELL + Starfish (Gully, iSHELL?) -
Longer 7me-‐horizon projects 11.Semi-‐empirical model grids from spectral outliers
12.Fold in many more calibra7on parameters: infer blaze func7on, telluric 13.Line-‐by-‐line Starfish to get log g 14.Line-‐by-‐line Starfish to get individual elemental abundances 15.Coordinate with modelers on new line iden7fica7on, log gf's 16.Accre7on models? 17.Cool stars and Brown dwarfs: BT SeWl models -
P ✓? w C ⌅ M D ✓ext How will
we actually accomplish all of this? It will be easy to model physical phenomena that are linear superpositions. e.g. Star 1 + Star 2 = net spectrum (binaries) Star 1 + Star 2 = net spectrum (starspots) Star 1 + disk = net spectrum (veiling) Star 1 + accretion = net spectrum (but what is the accretion spectrum?) Existing model Revised model θ∗2 w 2 P ✓? w C ⌅ M D ✓ext -
P ✓? w C ⌅ M D ✓ext It will
be hard to model physical phenomena that effect the emergent photosphere e.g. Star 1 w/ Magnetic fields = net spectrum ??? Existing model Revised model? P ✓? w C ⌅ M D ✓ext -
Starfish: Normalization “ We discussed the (frequently arising) point that
the spectra have bad continuum normalization (or, equivalently, bad calibration) and so it is hard to compare the models to the data at the precision of the data. This problem is not easily solved; many investigators "do the same thing" to the data and the models to match the continuum normalizations. However, these continuum procedures are usually signal-‐to-‐noise-‐dependendent; models are rarely at the same signal-‐to-‐noise as the data! Anyway, we proposed a simple plan […] We will instantiate many nuisance parameters (to cover calibration issues), infer them simultaneously, and marginalize them out.” -‐ D. Hogg, Hogg Blog 2015/04/22 -
Marley & Robinson ARA&A 2015 H08-Marley ARI 16 July 2015
12:23 Table 3 Ultracool modeling schools School Key characteristics (chemistry; cloud; opacity) Selected papers Barman True chem. eq.; defined clouds; sampling Barman et al. 2011 Burrows True chem. eq.; defined cloud; sampling Burrows et al. 2002, Currie et al. 2011 Marley/Saumon Rainout eq.; eddyseda; correlated-k Saumon & Marley 2008, Stephens et al. 2009 PHOENIX True chem. eq.; various cloudsb; sampling Witte et al. 2011 Tokyo True chem. eq.; UCMc; band model Sorahana & Yamamura 2012, Tsuji 2005 aEddy-sedimentation, a cloud physics model (Ackerman & Marley 2001). bVarious cloud physics models, including DUSTY (Allard et al. 2001) and DRIFT (Witte et al. 2011). cThe Unified Cloud Model, a defined cloud model (Tsuji 2002). data. Because we know from the comparisons with the cloudless T dwarfs that the atmospheric I am using the PHOENIX model grid. Model inter-‐comparisons are a likely avenue for future work. -
PHOENIX model grid Husser et al. 2013 A&A 553, A6
(2013) stars with has been s of NLTE 000). The have been extra-solar prehensive ed for use following PHOENIX he current of state as is allowed lly of cool A full dis- ublication cal geom- sequence and reso- g existing Table 1. Parameter space of the grid. Variable Range Step size Teff [K] 2300–7000 100 7000–12 000 200 log g 0.0–+6.0 0.5 [Fe/H] −4.0−−2.0 1.0 –2.0–+1.0 0.5 [α/Fe] –0.2–+1.2 0.2 Notes. Alpha element abundances [α/Fe] 0 are only available for 3500 K ≤ Teff ≤ 8000 K and −3 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ 0. Table 2. Sampling of the spectra in the grid. Range [Å] Sampling 500–3000 ∆λ = 0.1Å 3000–25 000 R ≈ 500 000 25 000–55 000 R ≈ 100 000 -
73 effective temperature values, 13 surface gravity values,
9 metallicity values -
[α/Fe] = 0 73 effective temperature values, 13 surface
gravity values, 9 metallicity values, 8 alpha-‐enchancement values (for a restricted volume) -
! 8541 synthetic spectra with [α/Fe] = 0 73 effective
temperature values, 13 surface gravity values, 9 metallicity values, 8 alpha-‐enchancement values (for a restricted volume) 22386 synthetic spectra with [α/Fe] ≠ 0 ➔ 30927 synthetic spectra -
Tools for comparing spectra to models. • MOOG (Sneden 1973)
• SPC (Buchave et al. 2012) • SME (ValenE & Piskunov 1996) • Forward model/χ2 (CoHaar et al. 2014) • Starfish (Czekala et al. 2015) -
Created by useiconic.com from the Noun Project SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION RESEARCH
Teff 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00 CCF median (+- 0.05) 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 Error in Teff (K) log(g) 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00 CCF median (+- 0.05) 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 Error in log(g) [m/H] 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00 CCF median (+- 0.05) 0.00 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.10 0.12 Error in [m/H] vsin(i) 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00 CCF median (+- 0.05) 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Error in vsin(i) (km/s) Supplementary Figure 1. Internal error estimates for SPC as a function of normalized cross correlation peak height (CC for effective temperature, surface gravity, metallicity and rotational velocity. The uncertainties are estimated following 29, Section 6, by determining empirical uncertainty estimates for targets with multiple observations. Each point in the diagram is the 1 σ uncertainty of the parameter for a subset selected by using a moving average centered around the me • SPC is cross correlation. Teff log(g) Buchhave et al. 2012 see also K. Gullikson PhD thesis in prep -
The Astrophysical Journal, 794:125 (18pp), 2014 October 20 Cottaar et
al. Figure 3. Sample fits of young stars in IC 348 with from top to bottom 2MASS J03442398+3211000 (∼6000 K), 2MASS J03443916+3209182 (∼4500 K), 2MASS J03445096+3216093 (∼3500 K), and 2MASS J03425395+3219279 (∼2900 K). The blue lines show one of the observed spectra for these stars and the red lines the best-fit model spectrum to each observed spectrum. Although high S/N spectra were selected as our example, the S/N clearly increases toward the spectra of fainter CoHaar et al. 2014 Forward Model/χ2 -‐ APOGEE Spectrograph (IN-‐SYNC) INfrared Spectra of Young Nebulous Clusters -‐Uses BT SeWl models, solves for 5 parameters. -‐8859 spectra of 3493 stars at R~22500 -
Advantages of pre-‐computed models • Absolute physical basis •
Lots of physics included • Large spectral grasp (encompasses IGRINS) • Low computa7onal cost to the end user • Standardized: easily reproducible/shareable -
Disadvantages of pre-‐computed models • Inflexible in which physics is
included • Incomplete line lists • Erroneous oscillator strengths • Coarsely sampled parameters -
noun project credits analy7cs by Syafiqa Fickle from the Noun
Project Graph by Crea7ve Stall from the Noun Project Error Bars by Severino Ribecca from the Noun Project Nega7ve Regression Graph by Aenne Brielmann from the Noun Project trend by OliM from the Noun Project grid by useiconic.com from the Noun Project grid by Ates Evren Aydinel from the Noun Project ScaWer Plot by Severino Ribecca from the Noun Project grid by Ates Evren Aydinel from the Noun Project bubble chart by Severino Ribecca from the Noun Project