Share
Embed
行政プロセスにデータ分析を取り入れるために知っておきたい知識と事例
2020年2月6日に開催された「令和元年度 政策評価に関する統一研修」(埼玉会場)の講義資料です。
(2020-02-09追記)
受講者以外の方々にもたくさんご覧頂いているようでありがとうございます。
注意点として、口頭での説明を前提とした資料であるため、スライド中の文章は最小限にとどめてある点ご了承下さい。
Sayoko Shimoyama
February 06, 2020
Transcript
119 slides
-
ߦϓϩηεʹ σʔλੳΛ औΓೖΕΔͨΊʹ ͓͖͍ͬͯͨ ࣝͱࣄྫ Ұൠࣾஂ๏ਓϦϯΫσʔλ දཧࣄ
5IV ྩݩ ࡦධՁʹؔ͢Δ౷Ұݚम -
࣍ 1. ͳͥɺσʔλΛ͏ඞཁ͕͋Δͷ͔ 2. ެڞσʔλͷڞ༗͕ͨΒࣾ͢ձతΠϯύΫτ 3. ࡦཱҊͷͨΊͷσʔλੳͷྲྀΕ 4. σʔλ׆༻ʹ͓͚ΔΑ͋͘Δצҧ͍ 5.
͓નΊͷจݙɾࢿྉ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 5 -
࣮ࡍʹࢮࣄނʹૺ͏֬ΛௐͯΈΔͱ… ඈߦػࣄނ 0.00004% ࣗಈंࣄނ 0.00279% 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 8
ͷࠃͷࣗಈंަ௨ࣄނʹΑΔࢮऀɿ ૯ਓޱɿ ग़యݩɿܯࢹி ૯ল౷ܭہ ʹੈքͰൃੜͨ͠ඈߦػࣄނ݅ɿؒ૯ϑϥΠτɿ ग़యݩɿ"WJBUJPO4BGFUZ/FUXPSL ສ݅ʹճ ى͜Δ֬ ສ݅ʹճ ى͜Δ֬ ඈߦػͷ ഒ -
ʮՄ༻ੑώϡʔϦεςΟοΫʯ ͱݺΕΔஅͷ͕ݪҼ nਓɺ͋ΔࣄྫΛࢥ͍ු͔͚͢Εɺ ى͜Γ͍͢ͱஅ͍͕͋͢͠Δ nೝࣝɺཧղɺܾఆͷࡍʹɺ ࢥ͍ग़͍͢͠ใ͚ͩʹج͍ͮͯ அ͢ΔΛ ʮՄ༻ੑώϡʔϦεςΟοΫ (Availability heuristic)ʯͱݺͿ
nਓ͕ؕΓ͍͢ʮೝόΠΞεʯ ͷ͏ͪͷ1ͭ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 9 ඈߦػࣄނେ͖͘ใಓ͞ΕΔ͜ͱ͕ଟ͘ɺ ҹʹΓ͍͢ -
ೝόΠΞε =ແҙࣝͳࢥߟͷภΓɾޡΓ ೝόΠΞεʢcognitive biasʣͱɺ ೝ৺ཧֶࣾձ৺ཧֶͰͷ༷ʑͳ؍ऀޮՌ ͷҰछͰ͋Γɺඇৗʹجຊతͳ౷ܭֶతͳޡΓɺ ࣾձతؼଐͷޡΓɺهԱͷޡΓʢڏِهԱʣͳ Ͳਓ͕ؒ൜͍͢͠Ͱ͋Δɻ సͯ͡ೝόΠΞεɺࣄྫূڌ๏తূڌͷ ৴པੑΛେ͖͘ΊΔɻ
ग़యɿ https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E8%AA%8D%E7%9F%A5%E3%83%90 %E3%82%A4%E3%82%A2%E3%82%B9 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 10 -
٬؍త = ୭͕ݟͯେମಉ͡ղऍ͕Ͱ͖Δ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 17 2 ͲͪΒͷೣ͕େ͖͍ʁ
2 ͲͪΒͷೣ͕ՄѪ͍ʁ 0.3m 20m ٬؍త ओ؍త -
Λ͏ͱղऍͷᴥᴪΛݮΒͤΔ ྫʣ͋Δࢢʹ͓͚Δٹٸୂһ๊͕͍͑ͯͨ՝
2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 18 -
Λ͏ͱղऍͷᴥᴪΛݮΒͤΔ ࢢͷ֤ୂͷୂһ1ਓ͋ͨΓͷ ग़ಈ݅※ Λࢉग़ͯ͠ൺֱ ※༻σʔλɿফใͷؒٹٸग़ಈ݅×֤ୂͷଐਓ ࠷େͰ 7.75ഒ ͷࠩ 2020/2/6 Sayoko
Shimoyama, LinkData 19 n ࣈݴ༿ΑΓղऍͷ෯͕ڱ͍ n ղऍͷᴥᴪ͕ݴ༿ʹൺͯ ى͜Γʹ͍͘ ग़యݩɿ$PEFGPS+BQBOσʔλΞΧσϛʔʹ͓͚Δ࣏ࣗମͷνʔϜͷൃදࢿྉ -
ױ ऀ ͷ ੜ ଘ ܦݧΧϯ͚ͩͰͳ͘ɺ ͦΕΛཪ͚Δ٬؍తͳσʔλ͕ඞཁ nEBPMɿEvidence Based
Policy Making …ΤϏσϯεʢՊֶతࠜ ڌʣʹج͍ͮͨࡦཱҊ nEBPMҩֶʢEvidence Based Medicineʣ͔Βੜ ͨ͠ߟ͑ํ • 1989ɺ࣌Ұൠతʹ༻͞Εͯ ͍ͨෆ຺ͷༀͷޮՌΛσʔλΛ औͬͯݕূͨ͠ͱ͜Ζɺ༻ʹ Αͬͯࢮ͕ߴ·Δ͜ͱ͕໌ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 20 ࣌Ұൠతͳෆ຺ͷༀ ϓϥηϘʢِༀʣ ܦݧతࣝͷΈͰஅ͢Δ͜ͱͷ ةݥੑ -
σʔλੳ݁Ռ͕ܦݧΧϯΛӽ͑ͨྫɿ PredPolʢถࠃͷ൜ࡑൃੜ༧ଌγεςϜʣ nPredPol ΧϦϑΥϧχΞେֶͷݚڀ άϧʔϓ͕։ൃͨ͠൜ࡑ༧ଌγεςϜ nաڈͷେͳ൜ࡑใͷσʔλϕʔεΛ ͱʹɺকདྷʮ͍ͭɺͲ͜Ͱʯ൜ࡑ͕ ى͖Δͷ͔ɺػցֶशΛϕʔεʹ༧ଌ nϩαϯθϧεࢢܯͷϓϩͷ൜ࡑੳͱ PredPolͷ༧ଌΛൺֱͨ͠ͱ͜Ζɺ
൜ࡑੳʹൺ̎ഒҎ্PredPolͷํ͕ ਖ਼֬ʹ༧ଌͰ͖ͨ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 21 ैདྷͷܦݧΧϯཔΓͷํ๏Ͱͳ͘ɺ σʔλʹجͮ͘٬؍తͳࠜڌ͔Βஅ͢Δํ๏γϑτ https://www.predpol.com/ -
σʔλͰࠜڌΛࣔ͢͜ͱͰ߹ҙܗΛਐΊͨྫɿ εʔύʔϒϩοΫߏʢόϧηϩφࢢʣ nόϧηϩφͰࣗಈंͷަ௨ྔ͕ଟ͘ɺԚછ࣭CO2ɺ ૽ԻͳͲʹΑΔެ͕՝ nʮࢢຽத৺ࢢʯΛίϯηϓτʹ͔͔͛ɺஈ֊తʹं͕௨ΕΔಓΛ ੍ݶ͢ΔܭըΛ࣮ࢪ nަ௨ྔڥʹؔ͢ΔηϯγϯάσʔλΛ༻͍ͯੳΛߦ͍ɺ ܭը͕ਐΜͩ߹ʹͲͷ͘Β͍͕վળ͢Δͷ͔ɺ ۩ମతͳͰࣔ͢͜ͱͰ߹ҙܗΛਪਐ •
ަ௨ྔ͕21%ݮ • 94%ͷࢢຽ͕ةݥͳϨϕϧͷཻࢠঢ়࣭ʹࡽ͞ΕΔ͜ͱͳ͘ͳΔ • 73.5%ͷࢢຽʮ65σγϕϧҎ্ͷ૽ԻʯΛܦݧͤͣʹ͢Ή 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 22 https://citiesofthefuture.eu/superblocks-barcelona-answer-to-car-centric-city/ -
αϯϑϥϯγείࢢ º :FMQ͔Βݟ͑Δ σʔλ͕ͨΒࣾ͢ձมֵ nαϯϑϥϯγείࢢͰɺҿ৯ళʹ ର࣮ͯ͠ࢪͨ͠อ݈Ӵੜݕࠪͷ݁Ռ Λσʔλͱͯ͠ެ։͍ͯ͠Δ n:FMQͦΕΛαʔϏεʹऔΓࠐΈɺ l)FBMUI 4DPSFzͱͯ͠ຬ
ͷείΞԽ֤ͯ͠ҿ৯ళͷ ϨϏϡʔϖʔδʹදࣔ n ੈք࠷େڃͷϩʔΧϧϏδωεͷϨϏϡʔαΠτ n ຊͰ͍͏ͱ͜Ζͷʮ৯ϩάʯతͳαʔϏε 4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" -
4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" :FMQϢʔβʔʹΑΓ҆৺ɾ҆શΛಧ͚ΒΕΔ αʔϏεΛఏڙՄೳʹ ۙͷอ݈Ӵੜ ݕࠪʹ͓͍ͯҧ ͕߲͋ͬͨ αϯϑϥϯγείࢢ
º :FMQ͔Βݟ͑Δ σʔλ͕ͨΒࣾ͢ձมֵ -
αϯϑϥϯγείࢢ º :FMQ͔Βݟ͑Δ σʔλ͕ͨΒࣾ͢ձมֵ ͠αϯϑϥϯγείࢢ͕ Ӵੜௐࠪ݁ՌΛαΠτͰެද͍ͯ͠Δ ͚ͩͩͬͨΒʁ Ұ෦ͷਓ͔͠ݟʹདྷͳ͍ ͠:FMQ͕
ಠࣗʹҿ৯ళΛධՁ͢Δ είΞΛ͚͍ͯͨΒʁ ެฏੑ͕୲อ͞Εͳ͍ ڧΈɿళฮͷӦۀσʔλޱίϛ σʔλΛूΊͯɺଟ͘ͷϢʔβ͕ ू·ΔΛ͍࣋ͬͯΔ ڧΈɿࢢຽͷ҆શΛकΔͨΊʹ࣮ࢪ ͨ͠ௐࠪ݁Ռͱͯ͠ɺެฏͳσʔλ ΛఏڙͰ͖Δ σʔλ͕ڞ༗͞ΕΔ͜ͱͰ ʮ৫Λ͑ͯಘҙΛ୲Ͱ͖ΔࣾձʯʹͳΔ 4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" -
“Φʔϓϯσʔλ” ͱɺ ݩʑօ͞ΜͷͷͩͬͨσʔλΛ ฦ͢͜ͱͩͱߟ͍͑ͯ·͢ɻ - Miquel Mateu, Open Data Manager
of Barcelona City 14-18 June 2016, World Data Viz Challenge 2016, Barcelona 4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" -
ຽڠಇʹΑͬͯҬΛ࣋ଓՄೳʹ͢Δ 4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" ߦ ॅຽ ੫ۚ ެڞαʔϏε اۀɾݚڀػؔ
ߦ͕ಘҙͳ෦ɺ ߦʹ͔͠Ͱ͖ͳ͍ ෦ʹूத͢Δ ຽ͕ؒಘҙͳͱ͜Ζ ຽؒʹͤΔ -
ΦʔϓϯσʔλʹΑͬͯɺ ৫Λ͑ͯಘҙΛ୲Ͱ͖Δࣾձ ͕࣮ݱ͢Δ 4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" ߦ ॅຽ ੫ۚ
ެڞαʔϏε اۀɾݚڀػؔ ߦͷ࣋ͭใΛ ʮσʔλʯͱ͍͏ ڞ༗ʹదͨ͠ܗͰ ຽؒʹ։์͢Δ OPEN DATA -
ࣄྫɿʮͣ͠Έͪ*OGPʯ ʢ੩Ԭࢢ º τϤλ*5։ൃηϯλʔʣ 4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB ੩Ԭࢢʮͣ͠Έͪ*OGPʯ nಓ࿏ަ௨ใΛ
ΦʔϓϯσʔλԽ n௨ߦن੍ࡂൃੜ ͳͲͷσʔλΛ ϦΞϧλΠϜͰ৴ τϤλ*5։ൃηϯλʔ nڞಉ࣮ݧͰʮͣ͠Έͪ *OGPʯͷσʔλΛऔಘ ͠ΧʔφϏͰใ৴ ʢσʔλެ։ݩʣ ن੍ؔ࿈σʔλɿ੩Ԭࢢݐઃہಓ࿏෦ಓ࿏อશ՝ ࡂؔ࿈σʔλɿ੩Ԭࢢ૯ہةػཧ૯ࣨ $&')(!",*1% # "" # 7 #13/-5/6 #.54506/+2 -
ࣄྫɿʮͣ͠Έͪ*OGPʯ ैདྷඞཁͳใΛඞཁͳਓʹಧ͚ΒΕͳ ͔ͬͨ 4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB ௨ߦن੍ ใ νϥγެࣜ8FCαΠτͰ
ใൃ৴ ඞཁͳλΠϛϯάͰ ඞཁͳใ͕ಘΒΕͳ͍ #&'03& ߦ υϥΠόʔ -
ࣄྫɿʮͣ͠Έͪ*OGPʯ ΦʔϓϯσʔλͰϦΞϧλΠϜʹใ͕ಧ ͚ΒΕΔΑ͏ʹ 4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB ௨ߦن੍ Φʔϓϯ σʔλ
Φʔϓϯσʔλͱͯ͠ ௨ߦن੍ใΛެ։ ඞཁͳλΠϛϯάͰ ࠷৽ใ͕ಘΒΕΔ "'5&3 ߦ υϥΠόʔ ຽؒاۀ ΧʔφϏ ։ൃ͍ͯ͠Δʹ ΦʔϓϯσʔλΛࡌͤͯ αʔϏεఏڙ ˞੩ԬࢢͰΧʔφϏͳͲͷػց͔Β ΦʔϓϯσʔλʹΞΫηεͰ͖ΔΑ͏ʹ ͢ΔͨΊʹɺ"1* "QQMJDBUJPO 1SPHSBNNJOH*OUFSGBDF ͱ͍͏Έ Ͱσʔλ͕ެ։͞Ε͍ͯ·͢ -
Φʔϓϯσʔλͷҙٛ ࠃຽࢀՃɾຽڠಇͷਪਐΛ௨ͨ͡ ॾ՝ͷղܾɺܦࡁ׆ੑԽ ߦͷߴԽɾޮԽ ಁ໌ੑɾ৴པͷ্ ʲग़యʳʮΦʔϓϯσʔλجຊࢦʯฏ݄ ߴใ௨৴ωοτϫʔΫࣾձਪਐઓུຊ෦ɾຽσʔλ׆༻ਪਐઓུձܾٞఆ
4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB ΦʔϓϯσʔλԽ ͢Δ࡞ۀͷɺ ࣄ͕૿͑ΔͷͰʜʁ -
τʔλϧίετ͕ߴ͍ͷͲͪΒʁ ใެ։ٻ 74Φʔϓϯσʔλ "ΦʔϓϯσʔλԽ͠ͳ͍߹ ٻ݅ʢʣɿ ݅ ٻ݅ʢʣɿ ݅ ٻ݅ʢʣɿ ݅
ٻ݅͋ͨΓͷରԠ࣌ؒɿ ࣌ؒ ৬һͷ࣌څɿ ԁ #ΦʔϓϯσʔλԽͨ͠߹ σʔλ࡞ରԠʢॳظίετʣɿ࣌ؒ σʔλߋ৽ରԠʢຖ݄ʣɿ ࣌ؒ ٻ݅ʢʣɿ ݅ ٻ݅ʢʣɿ ݅ ٻ݅ʢʣɿ ݅ ٻ݅͋ͨΓͷରԠ࣌ؒɿ ࣌ؒ ৬һͷ࣌څɿ ԁ 4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB ੩ԬࢢͷσʔλͱώΞϦϯά݁Ռ˞Λࢀߟʹɺඅ༻ΛγϛϡϨʔγϣϯ ˞ओʹରԠ࣌ؒʹؔͯ͠ɺ੩Ԭࢢ৬һҬใԽΞυόΠβʔͷ৽ঙେีࢯʹใఏڙ͖·ͨ͠ -
γϛϡϨʔγϣϯ݁Ռɿ ΦʔϓϯσʔλԽ͢Δ͜ͱͰରԠίετΛେ෯ʹݮͰ͖Δ 4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB
"ΦʔϓϯσʔλԽ͠ͳ͍߹ #ΦʔϓϯσʔλԽͨ͠߹ -
4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" ࡛ۄݝجૅ࣏ࣗମͷ Φʔϓϯσʔλਪਐঢ়گ ʢ݄࣌ʣ 68% 43/63 औࡁ
ະऔ https://public.tableau.com/shared/MBGTPWHPZ?:display_count =y&:origin=viz_share_link -
ʮσʔλʯͱʁ ISOٴͼJISن֨ʹΑΔఆٛ "A reinterpretable representation of information in a formalized
manner suitable for communication, interpretation, or processing.” ใͷදݱͰ͋ͬͯɺ ୡɺղऍ·ͨॲཧʹద͢ΔΑ͏ʹܗࣜԽ͞Εɺ ࠶ใͱͯ͠ղऍͰ͖Δͷ ISO/IEC 2382-1:1993 https://www.iso.org/obp/ui/#iso:std:iso-iec:2382:-1:ed-3:en ຊۀن֨ʮX0001 ใॲཧ༻ޠ-جຊ༻ޠʯhttp://kikakurui.com/x0/X0001-1994-01.html 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 55 -
ʮใʯͱʁ ISOٴͼJISن֨ʹΑΔఆٛ "Knowledge concerning objects, such as facts, events, things,
processes, or ideas, including concepts, that within a certain context has a particular meaning. ࣄ࣮ɼࣄɼࣄɼաఔɼணͳͲͷ ରʹؔͯ͠Γಘͨ͜ͱͰ͋ͬͯɼ ֓೦ΛؚΈɼҰఆͷจ຺தͰಛఆͷҙຯΛͭͷɻ ISO/IEC 2382-1:1993 https://www.iso.org/obp/ui/#iso:std:iso-iec:2382:-1:ed-3:en ຊۀن֨ʮX0001 ใॲཧ༻ޠ-جຊ༻ޠʯhttp://kikakurui.com/x0/X0001-1994-01.html 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 56 -
2020/2/6 σʔλ ϫʔΫγϣοϓ ։࠵ ϫʔΫγϣοϓ ։࠵ॴ ࢀՃొऀ ԣࢢॴ
Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 60 -
ใ⇄σʔλ ํʹมՄೳ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 61 ϫʔΫγϣοϓ ։࠵ ϫʔΫγϣοϓ
։࠵ॴ ࢀՃొ ऀ ԣࢢॴ ԣࢢॴͰ 201811݄23ʹ։࠵͞Εͨ σʔλੳϫʔΫγϣοϓͷ ࢀՃొऀ ਓͰ͢ɻ -
σʔλԽ͢Δ͜ͱͰ ଞͷσʔλͱΈ߹ΘͤΒΕΔ 2020/2/6 ৽͍͠ʮใʯ͕ औΓग़ͤΔ Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 62 30
35 40 24 29 34 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 ԣձٞॴ ਆಸݝி ԣࢢॴ ϫʔΫγϣοϓผ ࢀՃऀͷൺֱ ࢀՃऀ ࢀՃొऀ Qɿ֤ϫʔΫγϣοϓͷ ʮΩϟϯηϧʯ Ͳͷ͘Β͍ʁ -
σʔλੳ = σʔλ͔ΒใΛҾ͖ग़͢͜ͱ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 63 Ωϟϯηϧ
30 35 40 24 29 34 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 ԣձٞॴ ਆಸݝி ԣࢢॴ ϫʔΫγϣοϓผ ࢀՃऀͷൺֱ ࢀՃऀ ࢀՃొऀ -
σʔλੳ తΛఆΊ͓͔ͯͳ͍ͱҙຯ͕ͳ͍ ΠϕϯτӡӦऀ ͦͷଞͷਓ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 64 ͔࣍Β
ఆһ ʙ ͘Β͍ଟΊʹਃࠐΛ ड͚͚ͯ େৎͦ͏ʂ Կͷʹཱͭ ใͳΜͩΖ͏ʁ ୭ʹͲΜͳใΛఏڙ͢Δͷ͔ɺ ୭ͷͲΜͳ՝Λղܾ͍ͨ͠ͷ͔ɺ σʔλੳΛ͢Δલʹઃఆ͓ͯ͘͜͠ͱ͕ॏཁ -
σʔλੳʹΑΔࡦөͷྲྀΕ ԾઆΛ ཱͯΔ σʔλΛ ूΊΔ ੳ ධՁ ࡦཱҊ ࢦඪ࡞ ՝
৽͍͠՝ͷݕ౼ Ծઆͷؒҧ͍Λૣظʹൃݟ ࡦͷਫ਼Λ্͛Δ ඪɺޮՌࢦඪ Λ࡞͢Δ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 65 ग़యݩɿ૯ল ํެڞஂମʹ͓͚Δσʔλར׆༻ΨΠυϒοΫ 7FS ผఴࢿྉɽσʔλΞΧσϛʔʢσʔλੳฤʣͷڭࡐɾࢿྉ $$#:+1 -
σʔλੳʹΑΔࡦөͷྲྀΕ ԾઆΛ ཱͯΔ σʔλΛ ूΊΔ ੳ ධՁ ࡦཱҊ ࢦඪ࡞ ՝
৽͍͠՝ͷݕ౼ Ծઆͷؒҧ͍Λૣظʹൃݟ ࡦͷਫ਼Λ্͛Δ ඪɺ ޮՌࢦඪ Λ࡞͢Δ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 66 ग़యݩɿ૯ল ํެڞஂମʹ͓͚Δσʔλར׆༻ΨΠυϒοΫ 7FS ผఴࢿྉɽσʔλΞΧσϛʔʢσʔλੳฤʣͷڭࡐɾࢿྉ $$#:+1 ཁҙ ϙΠϯτ -
ޮՌࢦඪɿఆੑతޮՌΛͲ͏ଌΔʁ ΞϯέʔτͰฉ͘ ͱ͍͏ํ๏͕Α͘औΒΕΔ ࢦඪͷ1ͭʹ͢ΔͷOK Ξϯέʔτ݁ՌͷΈͰଌΔͱ ٬؍ੑʹ͚ܽΔ߹͕͋Δ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData
67 ॅΈ͢͞ ·ͪͷ ʹ͗Θ͍ ࢠҭͯͷ ͢͠͞ உঁฏ ޙͷ҆৺ -
2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 68 ϙΠϯτɿ ఆੑతޮՌ ఆྔతޮՌʹ ղͯ͠ ࢦඪԽ͢Δ
ྫɿॅΈΑ͞ϥϯΩϯάʢ౦༸ܦࡁʣ -
2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 69 ఆੑతޮՌఆྔతޮՌʹղͯ͠ࢦඪԽ͢Δ ྫɿॅΈΑ͞ϥϯΩϯάʢ౦༸ܦࡁʣར༻σʔλ ॅΈΑ͞ " ҆৺
ਓޱͨΓපӃɾҰൠྍॴපচʢ݄ʣɿްੜ࿑ಇলʮҩྍࢪઃௐࠪʯ ਓޱͨΓհޢਓࢱɾอ݈ࢪઃఆһʢ݄ʣɿްੜ࿑ಇলʮհޢαʔϏεࢪઃɾࣄۀॴௐࠪʯ ʙࡀঁੑਓޱͨΓʙࡀࣇʢ݄ʣɿ૯লʮॅຽجຊாʹجͮ͘ਓޱɺਓޱಈଶٴͼੈଳʯ ࢠͲҩྍඅॿʢରྸɾॴಘ੍ݶͷ༗ແʣʢ݄ʣɿ౦༸ܦࡁௐ ਓޱͨΓܐ๏൜ೝ݅ʢʣɿ֤ಓݝܯௐ ਓޱͨΓަ௨ࣄނ݅ʢʣɿަ௨ࣄނ૯߹ੳηϯλʔௐ # རศ ਓޱͨΓখചൢചֹʢʣɿ૯লɾܦࡁ࢈ۀলʮܦࡁηϯαε׆ಈௐࠪʯ ਓޱͨΓେنখചళళฮ໘ੵʢʣɿ౦༸ܦࡁʮશࠃେܕখചళ૯ཡʯ Մॅ໘ੵͨΓҿ৯ྉখചࣄۀॴʢ݄ʣɿ૯লɾܦࡁ࢈ۀলʮܦࡁηϯαε׆ಈௐࠪʯ ਓޱͨΓҿ৯ళʢ݄ʣ૯লɾܦࡁ࢈ۀলʮܦࡁηϯαε׆ಈௐࠪʯ $ շద సग़ೖਓޱൺʢʙʣɿ૯লʮॅຽجຊாʹجͮ͘ਓޱɺਓޱಈଶٴͼੈଳʯ ਓޱͨΓࡒࡀग़ֹ ʢʣɿ૯লʮࢢொଜผܾࢉঢ়گௐʯ ਫಓྉۚʢ݄ʣɿ౦༸ܦࡁௐ Ԛਫॲཧਓޱීٴʢ݄ʣɿࠃަ௨লɺྛਫ࢈লɺڥলௐ ࢢܭը۠ҬਓޱͨΓࢢެԂ໘ੵʢ݄ʣɿࠃަ௨লʮࢢެԂඋਫ४ௐॻʯ ؾީʢ݄ฏۉ࠷ߴɾ࠷ؾԹɺর࣌ؒʣʢʙʣɿؾிʮϝογϡฏσʔλʯ % ༟ ࡒྗࢦʢʣɿ૯লʮࢢொଜผܾࢉঢ়گௐʯ ࣄۀॴͨΓച্ߴʢ݄ʣɿ૯লɾܦࡁ࢈ۀলʮܦࡁηϯαε׆ಈௐࠪʯ ೲ੫ٛऀਓͨΓॴಘʢʣɿ૯লʮࢢொଜ੫՝੫ঢ়گͷௐʯ ॅͨΓԆচ໘ੵʢ݄ʣɿ૯লʮॅɾ౷ܭௐࠪʯ ࣋ͪՈੈଳൺʢ݄ʣɿ૯লʮࠃௐࠪʯ ॅฏۉՁʢ݄ʣɿࠃަ௨লʮಓݝՁௐࠪʯ -
2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 70 ࢦඪఆظతʹݟͯ͠վળ͢Δ͜ͱॏཁ ྫɿॅΈΑ͞ϥϯΩϯάʢ౦༸ܦࡁʣར༻σʔλ ॅΈΑ͞ ҆৺
පӃɾҰൠྍॴපচʢਓޱͨΓʣɿ݄ݱࡏ ްੜ࿑ಇলʮҩྍࢪઃௐࠪʯ հޢਓࢱࢪઃɾհޢਓอ݈ࢪઃఆһʢࡀҎ্ਓޱͨΓʣɿ݄ݱࡏ ްੜ࿑ಇলʮհޢαʔϏ εࢪઃɾࣄۀॴௐࠪʯ ग़ੜʢʙࡀঁੑਓޱͨΓʣɿ ૯লʮॅຽجຊாʹجͮ͘ਓޱɺਓޱಈଶʯ গਓޱʢʙࡀਓޱʣ૿ݮɿ݄×݄ ૯লʮॅຽجຊாʹجͮ͘ਓޱɺਓޱಈଶʯ རศ খചۀؒൢചֹʢਓޱͨΓʣɿ݄ ૯লɾܦࡁ࢈ۀলʮܦࡁηϯαε׆ಈௐࠪʢۀ౷ܭʣʯ େܕখചళళฮ໘ੵʢਓޱͨΓʣɿ݄ ౦༸ܦࡁʮશࠃେܕখചళ૯ཡʯ ҿ৯ྉখചࣄۀॴʢՄॅ໘ੵͨΓʣɿ݄ ૯লɾܦࡁ࢈ۀলʮܦࡁηϯαε׆ಈௐࠪʢۀ౷ ܭʣʯ շద Ԛਫॲཧਓޱීٴɿ݄ ࠃަ௨লɾྛਫ࢈লɾڥলʮԚਫॲཧਓޱීٴঢ়گʯɺ֤ಓݝࢿྉ ࢢެԂ໘ੵʢਓޱͨΓʣɿ݄ ࠃަ௨লௐ సೖɾసग़ਓޱൺɿʙ ૯লʮॅຽجຊாʹجͮ͘ਓޱɺਓޱಈଶʯ ৽ઃॅணށʢੈଳͨΓʣɿʙ ࠃަ௨লʮݐஙண౷ܭௐࠪʯ ༟ ࡒྗࢦɿ ૯লʮࢢொଜผܾࢉঢ়گௐʯ ํ੫ऩೖֹʢਓޱͨΓʣɿ ૯লʮࢢொଜผܾࢉঢ়گௐʯ ՝੫ରॴಘֹʢೲ੫ٛऀਓͨΓʣɿ ૯লʮࢢொଜ੫՝੫ঢ়گͷௐʯ ॅډਫ४ ॆ࣮ ॅԆচ໘ੵʢॅͨΓʣɿ݄ ૯লʮॅɾ౷ܭௐࠪʯ ࣋ͪՈੈଳൺɿ݄ ૯লʮࠃௐࠪʯ -
ࢦඪ࡞ͷεςοϓ ཁૉʹղ σʔλͱ ݁ͼ͚ͭΔ σʔλΛ ूΊΔ ࢦඪΛܭ ࢉ͢Δ ϏδϡΞ ϥΠζ
2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 71 ߏཁૉͱͯ͠ ߟ͑ΒΕΔͷ Λྻڍͯ͠ πϦʔߏʹ ͳΔΑ͏ʹ ཧ͢Δ ͦΕͧΕͷߏ ཁૉΛଌΔͨΊ ʹͲͷΑ͏ͳ σʔλ͕ඞཁ͔ ߟ͑Δ Ͱݕ౼ͨ͠ σʔλ͕ ࣮ࡍʹ͋Δ͔ ୳ͯ͠ऩू͢Δ ऩूͨ͠σʔλ Λ༻͍ͯɺ ൺֱରผʹ ࢦඪΛܭࢉ͢Δ ࢉग़ͨ͠ࢦඪ Λൺֱ͘͢͠ ͢ΔͨΊʹ ՄࢹԽ͢Δ -
4UFQཁૉʹղ ʮॅΈ͍͢ʯͱ͍͏ঢ়گͲͷΑ͏ͳཁૉͰΓཱ͍ͬͯΔ͔ɺ ᝦࢴΛͬͯڍ͛ͯΈ·͠ΐ͏ 4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" ॅΈ ͍͢ ڥ͕
ྑ͍ ࣏͕҆ ྑ͍ n ʮ͜Ε͕ਖ਼ղʯͱ͍͏ͷແ͍ͷͰɺ ࢥ͍ͭ͘ͷΛͲΜͲΜڍ͛ͯΈ·͠ΐ͏ n ͜͜ͰҰ୴σʔλ͕͋Δ͔Ͳ͏͔ ؾʹ͠ͳͯ͘0,Ͱ͢ ۭؾ͕ ΩϨΠ ͕ଟ ͍ -
4UFQσʔλͱ݁ͼ͚ͭΔ 4UFQͰڍ֤͛ͨཁૉɺͲΜͳσʔλͰଌΔ͜ͱ͕Ͱ͖ͦ͏͔ ڍ͛ͯΈ·͠ΐ͏ 4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" Ԛછ ࣭ ඈࢄྔ
ॅΈ ͍͢ ڥ͕ ྑ͍ ࣏͕҆ ྑ͍ ۭؾ͕ ΩϨΠ ͕ଟ ͍ ެ ۤ ݅ ඃ -
4UFQࢦඪΛܭࢉ͢Δ ࢦඪʹ͏σʔλͷछྨ͝ͱʹ֤۠ͷ ภࠩ Λܭࢉ͢Δ ֤۠ͷ ૯߹ภࠩ Λܭࢉ͢Δ ʢܭࢉͷΠϝʔδʣ
4":0,04)*.0:"." -*/,%"5" ภࠩ@ඃ ภࠩ@Ԛછ࣭ ภࠩ@999 ૯߹ภࠩ த۠ ɾɾɾ ۠ ɾɾɾ ೆ۠ ɾɾɾ ɾɾɾ ɾɾɾ ɾɾɾ ɾɾɾ ɾɾɾ -
4UFQϏδϡΞϥΠζ ࢉग़ͨ͠ࢦඪΛ ൺֱ͘͢͢͠ΔͨΊʹ ՄࢹԽ͢Δ ˞ԣใՊֶઐֶߍͷ ֶੜνʔϜʹΑΔ ʮԣࢢ۠ͷॅΈ͢͞ʯ ࢦඪͷՄࢹԽྫ 4":0,04)*.0:"."
-*/,%"5" https://public.tableau.com/profile/.48 315447#!/vizhome/7877/sheet7 -
σʔλੳͷྲྀΕશମΛ࣮ࡍʹମݧ͍ͨ͠ํʹΦεεϝ σʔλΞΧσϛʔ nITͰҬ՝ͷղܾΛਐΊΔஂମʮCode for Japanʯ͕࣮ࢪ͢Δɺߦ৬һ͚σʔλ ར׆༻ݚमϓϩάϥϜ n2017ͷ૯লࣄۀʹ͓͍ͯΧϦΩϡϥϜ։ൃΛ࣮ࢪ n͜Ε·Ͱʹ60Ҏ্ͷ࣏ࣗମ͕ࢀՃ nैདྷͷ࠲ֶʹΑΔݚमͱҟͳΓɺ৬һ͕ීஈͷۀͰ༻͍ͯ͠ΔσʔλΛ༻͍ͯɺ ࡦͷཱҊݕূΛ͓͜ͳ͏͜ͱ͕࠷େͷಛ
nσʔλੳʹΑΔࡦөͷ7stepͷྲྀΕΛɺº4ؒͷݚमͰशಘ͢Δ ৄࡉͪ͜ΒˠσʔλΞΧσϛʔݚڀձ IUUQTEBDPEFKBQBOPSH ᶃԾઆ ݱঢ়ੳ ᶄର σʔλ ֬ೝ ᶅੳ ख๏ݕ౼ ᶆσʔλ ੳ ᶇ ධՁ ᶈ ࡦݕ౼ ᶉ ޮՌࢦඪ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 80 -
σʔλ׆༻ʹ͓͚Δ Α͋͘Δצҧ͍ 1. ఆੑσʔλʹཱͨͳ͍ 2. ૬͕ؔ͋ΕඞͣҼՌ͕ؔ͋Δ 3. ΤϏσϯεΛٻΊΒΕͨ࣌ɺ σʔλΛࣔͤOKʂ 2020/2/6
Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 82 -
σʔλ׆༻ʹ͓͚Δ Α͋͘Δצҧ͍ 1. ఆੑσʔλʹཱͨͳ͍ 2. ૬͕ؔ͋ΕඞͣҼՌ͕ؔ͋Δ 3. ΤϏσϯεΛٻΊΒΕͨ࣌ɺ σʔλΛࣔͤOKʂ 2020/2/6
Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 83 -
σʔλੑ࣭Ͱେ͖͘2ͭʹ͚ΒΕΔ ఆྔσʔλ nͰେখΛද͢͜ͱ͕Ͱ͖Δσʔλ n٬؍ੑ͕ߴ͍ ʢ୭͕ݟͯେମಉ͡Α͏ʹղऍͰ͖Δʣ nϚΫϩͳࢹͰͷੳʹ༻͍Δ ʢௗͷʣ ఆੑσʔλ nͰදݱͰ͖ͳ͍จষͳͲͷσʔλ nओ؍ੑ͕ߴ͍
ʢղऍͦͷਓͷ࣋ͭईʹҕͶΒΕΔʣ nϛΫϩͳࢹͰͷੳʹ༻͍Δ ʢͷʣ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 84 -
ఆྔσʔλͷྫɿ Ξϯέʔτͷબ߲ ࢢʹ͓͚Δߦ৬һ͚σʔλ׆༻ݚमͷΞϯέʔτΑΓ ͋ͳͨɺʑͷۀͷதͰɺσʔλΛ׆༻ग़དྷ͍ͯΔͱࢥ͍·͔͢ʁ ̍ɽेʹग़དྷ͍ͯΔ ̎ɽग़དྷ͍ͯΔ ̏ɽ͋·Γग़དྷ͍ͯͳ͍ ̐ɽ·ͬͨ͘ग़དྷ͍ͯͳ͍ ̍ɽेʹग़དྷ͍ͯΔ
̎ɽग़དྷ͍ͯΔ ̏ɽ͋·Γग़དྷ͍ͯͳ͍ ̐ɽ·ͬͨ͘ग़དྷ͍ͯͳ͍ ूܭͯ͠ԽͰ͖Δ ఆྔσʔλ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 85 -
ఆྔσʔλͷ͍Ͳ͜Ζ ʮ၆ᛌʯ nͰൺֱ͢Δ͜ͱͰɺঢ়ଶΛ၆ᛌతʹѲͰ͖Δ n౷Ұ͞Εͨج४ͰൺֱͰ͖Δ શडߨऀͷ ͕ৗͷ ۀͰσʔλΛ׆༻Ͱ͖͍ͯΔ 2͋ͳͨɺʑͷۀͷதͰɺ σʔλΛ׆༻ग़དྷ͍ͯΔͱࢥ͍·͔͢ʁ
ݚमͷ ࣮ࢪ ݚम࣮ࢪલ શडߨऀͷ ͕ৗͷ ۀͰσʔλΛ׆༻Ͱ͖͍ͯΔ ݚम࣮ࢪޙ 2͋ͳͨɺʑͷۀͷதͰɺ σʔλΛ׆༻ग़དྷ͍ͯΔͱࢥ͍·͔͢ʁ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 86 -
ఆੑσʔλͷྫɿ Ξϯέʔτͷࣗ༝هड़߲ ࢢʹ͓͚Δߦ৬һ͚σʔλ׆༻ݚमͷΞϯέʔτΑΓ σʔλ׆༻ʹ͍ͭͯɺ՝͕͋Εڭ͍͑ͯͩ͘͞ɻʢࣗ༝هड़ʣ ԽͰ͖ͳ͍ ʹఆੑσʔλ σʔλऩूɺ׆༻ɺఏڙͷϊϋෆ ݱࡏͷۀ༰্ɺ͋·Γଟ͘ͷσʔλΛѻΘͳ͍ͨΊɺ׆༻ํ๏ʹΜͰ͍Δ Φʔϓϯσʔλͷ֓೦͕શ͘ਁಁ͍ͯ͠ͳ͍ɺࣄσʔλλςׂΓ ̥̘ɺϋʔυɾιϑτڥ͕ෆ͍ͯ͠Δʢॲཧೳྗʣ
ීஈͷۀ͔Β׆༻ͨ͠ޙͷΠϝʔδ͕Θ͔Βͳ͍ σʔλΛݟͯԿ͔Λײ͡ͱΔɺѲ͢Δ͜ͱʹۤखҙ͕ࣝ͋Γ׆༻·ͰࢸΒͳ͍ɺηϯεʁ׳Εʁ ະͷ༗ޮ׆༻͞Ε͍ͯͳ͍ிσʔλ͕ଘࡏ͢ΔͱࢥΘΕΔ ɾɾɾ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 87 -
ఆੑσʔλͷ͍Ͳ͜Ζ ʮਂ۷Γʯ nఆྔσʔλΑΓใྔଟ͍ͨΊɺݸʑͷঢ়ଶΛΑΓਂ۷Γͯ͠ѲͰ͖Δ n࣍ͷΞΫγϣϯΛݕ౼͢Δ্Ͱͷ͕ࣔࠦಘΒΕΔ σʔλऩूɺ׆༻ɺఏڙͷϊϋෆ ݱࡏͷۀ༰্ɺ͋·Γଟ͘ͷσʔλΛѻΘͳ͍ ͨΊɺ׆༻ํ๏ʹΜͰ͍Δ Φʔϓϯσʔλͷ֓೦͕શ͘ਁಁ͍ͯ͠ͳ͍ɺࣄ σʔλλςׂΓ ̥̘ɺϋʔυɾιϑτڥ͕ෆ͍ͯ͠Δʢॲཧ
ೳྗʣ ීஈͷۀ͔Β׆༻ͨ͠ޙͷΠϝʔδ͕Θ͔Βͳ͍ σʔλΛݟͯԿ͔Λײ͡ͱΔɺѲ͢Δ͜ͱʹۤख ҙ͕ࣝ͋Γ׆༻·ͰࢸΒͳ͍ɺηϯεʁ׳Εʁ ະͷ༗ޮ׆༻͞Ε͍ͯͳ͍ிσʔλ͕ଘࡏ͢Δ ͱࢥΘΕΔ ɾɾɾ 2σʔλ׆༻ʹ͍ͭͯɺ՝͕͋Εڭ͍͑ͯͩ͘͞ɻ ྨɾ ཧ σʔλΛࣗ༝ʹ͑Δڥ͕ ͍ͬͯͳ͍ ࣗͷۀͱ݁ͼ͚ͯ ߟ͑Δ͜ͱ͕ࠔ σʔλΛ͏͜ͱʹର͢Δ യવͱͨۤ͠खײ͕֮͋Δ ݸผͷΠϯλϏϡʔͰΑΓঢ়گ Λਂ͘Ѳ ϐοΫΞοϓ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 88 -
σʔλ׆༻ʹ͓͚Δ Α͋͘Δצҧ͍ 1. ఆੑσʔλʹཱͨͳ͍ →ఆྔσʔλͱఆੑσʔλతʹԠ͍͚ͯ͡Δ 2. ૬͕ؔ͋ΕඞͣҼՌ͕ؔ͋Δ 3. ΤϏσϯεΛٻΊΒΕͨ࣌ɺ σʔλΛࣔͤOKʂ
2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 89 -
σʔλ׆༻ʹ͓͚Δ Α͋͘Δצҧ͍ 1. ఆੑσʔλʹཱͨͳ͍ →ఆྔσʔλͱఆੑσʔλతʹԠ͍͚ͯ͡Δ 2. ૬͕ؔ͋ΕඞͣҼՌ͕ؔ͋Δ 3. ΤϏσϯεΛٻΊΒΕͨ࣌ɺ σʔλΛࣔͤOKʂ
2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 90 -
૬ؔ≠ҼՌؔ ྫʣΞΠεΫϦʔϜͷചΓ্͛ͱనࢮऀͷʹ૬͕ؔ͋ͬͨ ΞΠε͕ചΕΔ ͜ͱʹΑͬͯ నࢮऀ͕૿͑Δ ؾԹͷ্ঢ ڞ௨ཁҼ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama,
LinkData 92 ؾԹ্͕͕Δ ͜ͱʹΑͬͯ ΞΠε͕ചΕΔ ؾԹ্͕͕Δ ͜ͱʹΑͬͯ ʢւͰӭ͙ਓ͕ ૿͑ͯʣ నࢮऀ͕૿͑Δ -
૬͕ؔ͋ͬͯҼՌ͕ؔͳ͍έʔεᶃɿ ڞ௨ͷཁҼ͕͋Δʢަབྷʣ nྫʣʮίʔώʔΛҿΉྔʯͱʮ৺ےߎ࠹ͷൃʯʹਖ਼ͷ૬͕ؔ͋ͬͨ 2020/2/6 Sayoko
Shimoyama, LinkData 94 ίʔώʔΛΑ͘ҿΉਓͰ λόίΛٵ͏ਓ͕ଟ͔ͬͨ ٤Ԏ͕৺ےߎ࠹ൃͷ ཁҼʹͳ͍ͬͯͨ -
૬͕ؔ͋ͬͯҼՌ͕ؔͳ͍έʔεᶅɿ બόΠΞε nྫʣ࣮ٕࢼݧͷͱֶྗࢼݧͷͷ߹ܭͰ߹൱͕ܾ·Δࢼݧʹ͓͍ͯɺ ߹֨ऀͷʮ࣮ٕࢼݧͷʯͱʮֶྗࢼݧͷʯʹෛͷ૬͕ؔ͋ͬͨ
2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 98 -
σʔλ׆༻ʹ͓͚Δ Α͋͘Δצҧ͍ 1. ఆੑσʔλʹཱͨͳ͍ →ఆྔσʔλͱఆੑσʔλతʹԠ͍͚ͯ͡Δ 2. ૬͕ؔ͋ΕඞͣҼՌ͕ؔ͋Δ →૬͕ؔ͋ͬͯҼՌ͕ؔͳ͍߹͕͋Δ 3. ΤϏσϯεΛٻΊΒΕͨ࣌ɺ
σʔλΛࣔͤOKʂ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 101 -
σʔλ׆༻ʹ͓͚Δ Α͋͘Δצҧ͍ 1. ఆੑσʔλʹཱͨͳ͍ →ఆྔσʔλͱఆੑσʔλతʹԠ͍͚ͯ͡Δ 2. ૬͕ؔ͋ΕඞͣҼՌ͕ؔ͋Δ →૬͕ؔ͋ͬͯҼՌ͕ؔͳ͍߹͕͋Δ 3. ΤϏσϯεΛٻΊΒΕͨ࣌ɺ
σʔλΛࣔͤOKʂ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 102 -
ϥϯμϜൺֱԽࢼݧ (Randomized Controlled Trial: RCT) nରΛϥϯμϜʹάϧʔϓ͚ͯ͠ࢦඪΛܭଌ͠ൺֱ 1. ࢪࡦΛ࣮ࢪ͢Δάϧʔϓʢॲஔ܈ʣ 2. ࢪࡦΛ࣮ࢪ͠ͳ͍άϧʔϓʢରর܈ʣ
nϥϯμϜɾάϧʔϐϯάʹΑͬͯଞͷཁҼʹΑΔӨڹΛഉআ ର ॲஔ܈ ରর܈ ࢦඪΛܭଌ ࢦඪΛܭଌ ࢪࡦޮՌ ࠩΛൺֱ ϥϯμϜʢແ࡞ҝʣ ʹάϧʔϐϯά 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 104 -
ΤϏσϯεͷڧ͞ͷ֊ nʮΤϏσϯεʹجͮ͘ҩྍ (Evidence-Based Medicine) ʯʹ Λൃͨ͠ΤϏσϯεͷ֊ (Ϩϕϧ) ͕ࣾձՊֶʹԠ༻͞Ε͍ͯΔ nϨϕϧ্͕͕Δ΄ͲΑΓਖ਼֬ʹҼՌؔΛਪఆͰ͖Δͱݟͳ͞ΕΔ ग़యɿਖ਼๎ɺ୩تҰʢʣʮΤϏσϯεʹجͮ͘ҩྍʢ&.#ͷܥේͱํੑɿอ݈
ҩྍධՁʹՌͨ͢ίΫϥϯڞಉܭըͷׂͱະདྷʣʯʰຊධՁݚڀ ୈרୈ߸ʱQQ 4 b a 1b 1a ෳͷϥϯμϜԽൺֱࢼݧͷϝλɾΞφϦγε গͳ͘ͱ̍ͭͷϥϯμϜԽൺֱࢼݧ গͳ͘ͱ̍ͭͷඇϥϯμϜԽൺֱࢼݧ গͳ͘ͱ̍ͭͷ४࣮ݧతݚڀ ඇ࣮ݧతݚڀɺهड़తݚڀ ઐՈͷใࠂҙݟɺݖҖऀͷܦݧ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 105 -
ࣄྫɿਆಸݝ༿ࢁொͷ ์ஔ͝ΈݮࢪࡦͷޮՌݕূ n༿ࢁொ2008ɺຊͰ3൪ʹʮθϩɾΣΠετࡦʯʢ͝ΈͷపఈతͳࢿݯԽɾݮྔԽʣΛಋೖ nࢿݯ͝ΈͷऩूڌͰ͋ΔࢿݯεςʔγϣϯͷཧɺθϩɾΣΠετͷୡʹ͚ͨॏཁࢪࡦ nࢿݯεςʔγϣϯͰͷ์ஔ͝Έ͕ݮΒͳ͍͜ͱʹொɾॅຽ͕಄Λ·͍ͤͯͨ →ࢪࡦ࣮ݧΛ࣮ࢪ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData
106 ϞχλϦϯάର εςʔγϣϯ ରࡦɿνϥγ ରࡦɿ൘ܝࡌ ରࡦͳ͠ ࣄલϞχλϦϯά ʹج͖ͮϥϯμϜ ʹάϧʔϓԽ ࠩແ͔ͬͨ ʢޮՌͳ͠ʣ ଟ͘ ݮͰ͖ͨ ʢݮޮՌ͋Γʣ ϞχλϦϯά Λ࣮ࢪ͠ɺ ݁ՌΛൺֱ ग़యɿࡦͷޮՌΛͲ͏ଌఆ͢Δ͔ʁɿւ֎ʹ͓͚ΔʮΤϏσϯεʹجͮ͘ࡦʯͷ࠷৽ಈ IUUQTXXXSJFUJHPKQKQFWFOUTCCMIUNM શொల։ -
ࣄྫɿਆಸݝ༿ࢁொͷ ์ஔ͝ΈݮࢪࡦͷޮՌݕূ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 107 ग़యɿʮΤϏσϯεΛࡦʹͲ͏͏͔ ΠΪϦεͷಈͱຊͷద༻ࣄྫ͔Βͷࣔࠦʯ খྛ༱ฏ
IUUQTXXXSJFUJHPKQKQFWFOUTCCMQEG -
ࣄྫɿਆಸݝ༿ࢁொͷ ์ஔ͝ΈݮࢪࡦͷޮՌݕূ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 108 ग़యɿʮΤϏσϯεΛࡦʹͲ͏͏͔ ΠΪϦεͷಈͱຊͷద༻ࣄྫ͔Βͷࣔࠦʯ খྛ༱ฏ
IUUQTXXXSJFUJHPKQKQFWFOUTCCMQEG -
ࣄྫɿਆಸݝ༿ࢁொͷ ์ஔ͝ΈݮࢪࡦͷޮՌݕূ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 109 ग़యɿʮΤϏσϯεΛࡦʹͲ͏͏͔ ΠΪϦεͷಈͱຊͷద༻ࣄྫ͔Βͷࣔࠦʯ খྛ༱ฏ
IUUQTXXXSJFUJHPKQKQFWFOUTCCMQEG -
ྫʣΧϦϑΥϧχΞभʹ͓͚Δ ిྗফඅྔͷੳ ग़యɿࡦͷޮՌΛͲ͏ଌఆ͢Δ͔ʁɿւ֎ʹ͓͚ΔʮΤϏσϯεʹجͮ͘ࡦʯͷ࠷৽ಈ IUUQTXXXSJFUJHPKQKQFWFOUTCCMIUNM nੳͷతɿ ʮిྗͷྉۚΛ্͛Δͱɺফඅऀ͕Ͳͷ͘Β͍ͷྔΛઅి͢Δͷ͔Γ͍ͨ ʯ nੳ࣮ࢪऀɿγΧΰେֶެڞࡦେֶӃ ҏ౻ެҰ࿕ࢯ nڠྗػؔɿ
CaIifornia Energy Commission (), SCE, SDG&E (ిྗձࣾ) nར༻σʔλɿੈଳ͝ͱͷ݄ؒిྗফඅσʔλ10 pΧϦϑΥϧχΞभͷ͋ΔࢢͰೆͰ ిྗձ͕ࣾҟͳΔ p྆ํͷిྗձࣾͷిྗྉ͕ۚಉ༷ʹ มԽ͍ͯͨ࣌͠ظͱɺೆ෦͚ͩ ిྗྉ্͕͕ۚͬͨ࣌ظ͕͋Δ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 111 -
ྫʣΧϦϑΥϧχΞभʹ͓͚Δ ిྗফඅྔͷੳ ྆ํͷిྗձࣾͷిྗྉ͕ۚಉ༷ʹมԽ͍ͯͨ࣌͠ظͱൺֱ͢Δͱɺೆ෦Ͱిྗྉ্͕͕ۚͬͨ ࣌ظͷిྗফඅྔ12-13%ݮগ͍ͯͨ͠ →ిྗྉ্͕͕ۚΔͱফඅऀઅి͢Δ ྆ҬͰྉ͕ۚಉ༷ͩͬͨ࣌ظ ೆ෦͚ͩྉ্͕͕ۚͬͨ࣌ظ ෦ ೆ෦ ෦
ೆ෦ Koichiro Ito, American Economic Review 2014, 104(2): 537–563 http://dx.doi.org/10.1257/aer.104.2.537 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 112 -
σʔλ׆༻ʹ͓͚Δ Α͋͘Δצҧ͍ 1. ఆੑσʔλʹཱͨͳ͍ →ఆྔσʔλͱఆੑσʔλతʹԠ͍͚ͯ͡Δ 2. ૬͕ؔ͋ΕඞͣҼՌ͕ؔ͋Δ →૬͕ؔ͋ͬͯҼՌ͕ؔͳ͍߹͕͋Δ 3. ΤϏσϯεΛٻΊΒΕͨ࣌ɺ
σʔλΛࣔͤOKʂ →ΤϏσϯεʹ࣭ͷϨϕϧ͕ଘࡏ͢ΔͨΊɺ ͨͩσʔλΛ͚ࣔͩ͢ͰՊֶతࠜڌͱͯ͠ऑ͍߹͕͋Δ 2020/2/6 Sayoko Shimoyama, LinkData 113 -
σʔλΛར׆༻ͨ͠ࡦཱҊϓϩηεΛֶͼ͍ͨํ σʔλ׆༻ͰҬͷϛϥΠΛม͑Δʂ ՝ղܾͷ4UFQ 4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB nҎ্ͷ࣏ࣗମ͕डߨͨ͠ σʔλར׆༻ݚम lσʔλΞΧσϛʔz
ͷΤοηϯεΛ ʹू n݄ʹൃച͞Ε͔ͨΓ ͷ৽ץ IUUQTTIPQHZPTFJKQQSPEVDUTEFUBJM -
ޮՌతͳΞϯέʔτௐࠪͷख๏Λֶͼ͍ͨํ ࣾձڭҭௐࠪϋϯυϒοΫ 4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB nʮࣾձڭҭௐࠪʯͱ͞Ε͍ͯΔ͕ɺ ࣮ࡍΞϯέʔτௐࠪશൠʹ͑Δߟ͑ํ UJQT͕ղઆ͞Ε͍ͯΔ nಛʹʮୈᶚ෦
ௐࠪථͷ࡞Γํʯ ΞϯέʔτΛઃܭ͢Δํඞݟʂ n1%'ͰμϯϩʔυՄೳ IUUQTXXXOJFSHPKQKJTTFODIPTBIBOECPPLIUN -
ݸਓใͷѻ͍ʹ৺Λ͍࣋ͬͯΔํ ݸਓใΛؚΉσʔλ׆༻ݕ౼ͷͨΊͷϫʔΫγʔτ 4BZPLP4IJNPZBNB -JOL%BUB n૯লʮํެڞஂମʹ͓͚Δσʔλ ར׆༻ΨΠυϒοΫʯͷͱͯ͠ެ։ ͞Ε͍ͯΔ nݸਓใΛؚΉσʔλ׆༻Λݕ౼͢Δࡍ
ʹɺ࠷ݶ֬ೝ͖͢ࣄ߲Λཧ͢ΔͨΊ ͷϫʔΫγʔτ nઍ༿ࢢͱඣ࿏ࢢͰͷ࣮ূͷࡍͷݕ౼ྫΛ ܝࡌ IUUQXXXTPVNVHPKQNFOV@TFJTBLV JDUTFJTBLVJDUSJZPVCJHEBUBIUNM