Upgrade to Pro — share decks privately, control downloads, hide ads and more …
Sign up for free

80,000 Plaintext Passwords: An Open Source Love...

Avatar for T.J. Schuck T.J. Schuck
June 26, 2014
Programming
1.2k
5

80,000 Plaintext Passwords: An Open Source Love Story in Three Acts

Avatar for T.J. Schuck

T.J. Schuck

June 26, 2014

Other Decks in Programming

See All in Programming
残高管理から台帳サービスへの進化
Avatar for kobaryo artoy
0
180
ソニーのクラウド共通基盤の変遷と AI時代の開発スタイルに合わせた進化 / The Journey of Sony’s Common Cloud Platform and Its Evolution for AI-Native Development
Avatar for KenjiYoneyama kenjiyoneyama
0
240
UPDATE をやめる — EF Core でマスタをバージョン管理する
Avatar for HideyukiKitao panda728
PRO
0
1.2k
contenteditable と日本語入力に向き合う
Avatar for taki colorful12
0
180
Vue Fes Japan 2026 タイムテーブル徹底解説
Avatar for 448jp | OKI Yoshiya 448jp
1
640
Starting & Sustaining Code-Based E2E Testing for Non-Coding QA Teams( #jasstniigata )
Avatar for teyamagu teyamagu
PRO
1
940
Workers Cache を知る
Avatar for syumai syumai
0
350
golang-bob.pdf
Avatar for Yura Iwatsuka iwatsukayura
0
100
個人開発者よ、Honoを使え（おじさんver）
Avatar for tanahiro2010 tanahiro2010
2
150
気持ちぃ〜角丸 Squircle
Avatar for ryu ryu1013
0
150
setup-vp GitLab対応の裏側
Avatar for Naoki Haba naokihaba
0
160
Turning Architecture into Unit Tests in the AI Era (NSSpain XIV)
Avatar for Stelios Frantzeskakis steliosf
PRO
1
140

Featured

See All Featured
Building Better People: How to give real-time feedback that sticks.
Avatar for Will Jessup wjessup
370
20k
A Modern Web Designer's Workflow
Avatar for Chris Coyier chriscoyier
699
190k
We Have a Design System, Now What?
Avatar for Morgane Peng morganepeng
55
8.4k
GitHub's CSS Performance
Avatar for Jon Rohan jonrohan
1033
470k
JAMstack: Web Apps at Ludicrous Speed - All Things Open 2022
Avatar for David Neal reverentgeek
1
620
Skip the Path - Find Your Career Trail
Avatar for Mark Kilby mkilby
1
250
What's in a price? How to price your products and services
Avatar for Michael Herold michaelherold
247
13k
ReactJS: Keep Simple. Everything can be a component!
Avatar for Pedro Nauck pedronauck
666
130k
[Rails World 2026] Durable orchestration on Rails: from continuation to workflow
Avatar for Vladimir Dementyev palkan
1
680
Automating Front-end Workflow
Avatar for Addy Osmani addyosmani
1369
210k
Exploring the Power of Turbo Streams & Action Cable | RailsConf2023
Avatar for Kevin Liebholz kevinliebholz
37
6.6k
Reality Check: Gamification 10 Years Later
Avatar for Sebastian Deterding codingconduct
0
2.3k

Transcript

  1. 80,000 Plaintext Passwords @tjschuck

  2. Act I

  3. mallory@local$ ′

  4. None

  5. T.J. Schuck
 @tjschuck

  6. HARVEST getHarvest.com

  7. I am not a Security Expert™

  8. mallory@local$ ′

  9. Layers Layers Layers Layers

  10. mallory@local$ perl haxor.pl ′

  11. mallory@local$ perl haxor.pl ! +------+-----------------------+------------+ | id | email |

    password | +------+-----------------------+------------+ | 6125 | [email protected] | honeyd | | 6126 | [email protected] | blowfish | | 6127 | [email protected] | peppercorn | | 6128 | [email protected] | md1947 | +------+-----------------------+------------+

  12. “But…”

  13. mallory@local$ perl haxor.pl ! +------+-----------------------+------------+ | id | email |

    password | +------+-----------------------+------------+ | 6125 | [email protected] | honeyd | | 6126 | [email protected] | blowfish | | 6127 | [email protected] | peppercorn | | 6128 | [email protected] | md1947 | +------+-----------------------+------------+

  14. mallory@local$ perl haxor.pl ! +------+-----------------------+------------+ | id | email |

    password | +------+-----------------------+------------+ | 6125 | [email protected] | ubarlq | | 6126 | [email protected] | oybjsvfu | | 6127 | [email protected] | crccrepbea | | 6128 | [email protected] | zq1947 | +------+-----------------------+------------+

  15. Encryption is reversible

  16. Hashing is irreversible

  17. None

  18. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f

  19. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘secret1234’) => bdfc2db0aa599f5919e565c328216a51

  20. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘secret1234’) => bdfc2db0aa599f5919e565c328216a51 => 18ad6448e70b7b0254cad4d77653f2d7

  21. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘secret1234’) => bdfc2db0aa599f5919e565c328216a51 => 18ad6448e70b7b0254cad4d77653f2d7 ?

  22. Hashing is deterministic

  23. None

  24. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f

  25. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f

  26. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f

  27. Hashing is deterministic (but not obvious)

  28. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f !

  29. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f ! hash(‘Peppercorn’) => b8bfa4f1b72ee60755a71dbdf0700fe9

  30. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f ! hash(‘Peppercorn’) => b8bfa4f1b72ee60755a71dbdf0700fe9

    => b8bfa4f1b72ee60755a71dbdf0700fe8

  31. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f ! hash(‘Peppercorn’) => b8bfa4f1b72ee60755a71dbdf0700fe9

    => b8bfa4f1b72ee60755a71dbdf0700fe8 ?

  32. mallory@local$ perl haxor.pl ! +------+-----------------------+----------------------------------+ | id | email |

    password | +------+-----------------------+----------------------------------+ | 6125 | [email protected] | 6ee717a4bc91d99170ce0d0922ab6c43 | | 6126 | [email protected] | b258a419ddbc13d92b8e7fc25c2b9d6c | | 6127 | [email protected] | 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f | | 6128 | [email protected] | 0304432f4c8080781f1b210c6b92b12f | +------+-----------------------+----------------------------------+

  33. Hashing is deterministic

  34. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f

  35. None

  36. Rainbow Tables

  37. mallory@local$ perl haxor.pl ! +------+-----------------------+----------------------------------+ | id | email |

    password | +------+-----------------------+----------------------------------+ | 6125 | [email protected] | 6ee717a4bc91d99170ce0d0922ab6c43 | | 6126 | [email protected] | b258a419ddbc13d92b8e7fc25c2b9d6c | | 6127 | [email protected] | 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f | | 6128 | [email protected] | 0304432f4c8080781f1b210c6b92b12f | +------+-----------------------+----------------------------------+
  38. None

  39. 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f

  40. None
  41. None

  42. Defeating the Rainbow

  43. hash(‘peppercorn’) => 6a58d0ad2619df7d7fabc2603b79063f

  44. hash(‘peppercorn-tc5gplQopZ617zRQ8h9pAg’) => c5dde1b5cc0e6d89bda0f5e350bda319

  45. None

  46. WE DID IT!

  47. (no we didn’t)

  48. Proof of Concept

  49. peppercorn

  50. pepper8 pepper83 pepper88 pepper99 ! pepperdog pepperi1 peppermint peppermint1 pepperoni

    pepperpepper peppers peppers4 peppi123 peppone pepsi pepsi1 pepsi123 pepsi2006 pepsi5 pepsi78bottle pepsicat pepsico pepsii pepsimax pepsione pepsis12 pequot per12fect peralta1 peppercorn

  51. un1v3r53 1q2w#E$R fkg7h4f3v6

  52. SALTING

  53. SALTING

  54. hash(‘peppercorn-tc5gplQopZ617zRQ8h9pAg’) => c5dde1b5cc0e6d89bda0f5e350bda319 hash(‘peppercorn-R1XrmmZVRedKMTE9nlIy9Q’) => fc5ad4a64796506086424af78f57df9d

  55. mallory@local$ perl haxor.pl ! +------+----------------------------------+------------------------+ | id | password |

    salt | +------+----------------------------------+------------------------+ | 6125 | 5b5f47a49cdd4386611ee0a63577eccd | CeVDwwrT7saa_cY2rV_qng | | 6126 | a50f4854739e10773c99d5576dbb2f73 | rRWjkN4ioELXIPpQ6aDY4w | | 6127 | 94c91484c8bb05113b28f9da2b7ea624 | XvALmgae9uUGmpikd8sohg | | 6128 | 5d2ee837249e9340624b12e653c5e4a3 | D-ZUYoaSadkCze1fPibbgg | +------+----------------------------------+------------------------+

  56. This is pretty good…

  57. This is pretty good… for 1976.

  58. None
  59. None
  60. None
  61. None

  62. bcrypt ✓ One-way hash
 ✓ Pre-image resistant
 ✓ Deterministic ✓

    Built-in per-password salts

  63. Eksblowfish

  64. Adaptive Cost

  65. mallory@local$ perl haxor.pl ! +-----------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------+ | email | password |

    +-----------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------+ | [email protected] | $2a$10$1ObnU/cPb3AjVU5iu8ntfe77xO83roRhoJMyBqYhlq5ZMMbHCcELK | | [email protected] | $2a$10$CelbCnmBjJez5ego4w.mbusfnZGOn/lRhLjrr37R0iUCr1UIC6ZyC | | [email protected] | | | [email protected] | $2a$10$9WLufYmucbh.yaTHKKUuUeihbcA3hBUiI.XiW7ygmaYcYXtl4MBKy | +-----------------------+--------------------------------------------------------------+ $ 2a 10 LrfFlMh6Yc7JWKlpRwVjUuPCOPU5574fXAVrvLZRFT87cT55oLBEe $ $

  66. $ 2a 10 LrfFlMh6Yc7JWKlpRwVjUuPCOPU5574fXAVrvLZRFT87cT55oLBEe $ $

  67. $ 2a 10 LrfFlMh6Yc7JWKlpRwVjUu PCOPU5574fXAVrvLZRFT87cT55oLBEe $ $

  68. $ 2a 10 LrfFlMh6Yc7JWKlpRwVjUu PCOPU5574fXAVrvLZRFT87cT55oLBEe $ $

  69. $ 2a 10 LrfFlMh6Yc7JWKlpRwVjUu PCOPU5574fXAVrvLZRFT87cT55oLBEe $ $

  70. $ 2a 10 LrfFlMh6Yc7JWKlpRwVjUu PCOPU5574fXAVrvLZRFT87cT55oLBEe $ $

  71. $ 2a 10 LrfFlMh6Yc7JWKlpRwVjUu PCOPU5574fXAVrvLZRFT87cT55oLBEe $ $

  72. $ 2a 10 LrfFlMh6Yc7JWKlpRwVjUu PCOPU5574fXAVrvLZRFT87cT55oLBEe $ $ “Cost”

  73. None

  74. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) =>

  75. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi

  76. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) =>

  77. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$8ONmT2oiKPoPn/KQTrvHq.gWTnqQ5p.T13lw.lCm9d.QoqIZzbHPS

  78. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$8ONmT2oiKPoPn/KQTrvHq.gWTnqQ5p.T13lw.lCm9d.QoqIZzbHPS bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 14)

    =>

  79. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$8ONmT2oiKPoPn/KQTrvHq.gWTnqQ5p.T13lw.lCm9d.QoqIZzbHPS bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 14)

    => $2a$14$4US.NV/qyRkctl.LaYvNzOln70yIaqGfJeMq1deb/bPJMMmtcxOU.

  80. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$8ONmT2oiKPoPn/KQTrvHq.gWTnqQ5p.T13lw.lCm9d.QoqIZzbHPS bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 14)

    => $2a$14$4US.NV/qyRkctl.LaYvNzOln70yIaqGfJeMq1deb/bPJMMmtcxOU.

  81. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$8ONmT2oiKPoPn/KQTrvHq.gWTnqQ5p.T13lw.lCm9d.QoqIZzbHPS bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 14)

    => $2a$14$4US.NV/qyRkctl.LaYvNzOln70yIaqGfJeMq1deb/bPJMMmtcxOU. 0.0656 seconds

  82. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$8ONmT2oiKPoPn/KQTrvHq.gWTnqQ5p.T13lw.lCm9d.QoqIZzbHPS bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 14)

    => $2a$14$4US.NV/qyRkctl.LaYvNzOln70yIaqGfJeMq1deb/bPJMMmtcxOU. 0.0656 seconds 0.0657 seconds

  83. bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$41JmpddjOSEGWU099uQx7O7Y1EiQMTRQFZCcFqFMlYWekR5pj9xFi bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 10) => $2a$10$8ONmT2oiKPoPn/KQTrvHq.gWTnqQ5p.T13lw.lCm9d.QoqIZzbHPS bcrypt(‘peppercorn’, 14)

    => $2a$14$4US.NV/qyRkctl.LaYvNzOln70yIaqGfJeMq1deb/bPJMMmtcxOU. 0.0656 seconds 0.0657 seconds 1.0481 seconds

  84. Cost Seconds 9 0.0344 10 0.0656 11 0.1333 12 0.2646

    13 0.5236 14 1.0481 15 2.1645 16 4.2801

  85. “Well, actually…”

  86. The Fix

  87. def authenticate(plaintext_password)! if old_hashing_method(plaintext_password) == password_digest! self! end! end

  88. def authenticate(plaintext_password)! if BCrypt::Password.new(password_digest) == plaintext_password! self! end! end

  89. def authenticate(plaintext_password)! return unless convert_old_hash_to_bcrypt(plaintext_password)! ! if BCrypt::Password.new(password_digest) == plaintext_password!

    self! end! end

  90. def convert_old_hash_to_bcrypt(plaintext_password)! return true if BCrypt::Password.valid_hash?(password_digest)! ! if old_hashing_method(plaintext_password) ==

    password_digest! update_column :password_digest,! BCrypt::Password.create(plaintext_password)! end! end
  91. None
  92. None
  93. None

  94. —Act II—

  95. Fat Binary Gems —Act II— You make the rockin’ world

    go ’round

  96. bcrypt-ruby github.com/codahale/bcrypt-ruby

  97. None
  98. None
  99. None
  100. None
  101. None
  102. None
  103. None
  104. None
  105. None
  106. None
  107. None
  108. None
  109. None
  110. None

  111. Well shit.

  112. None
  113. None

  114. rake-compiler-dev-box with Rubies, GCC, JDK, MinGW…

  115. None

  116. LOLOLOLOL NO.

  117. None

  118. rake-compiler#79

  119. Act III

  120. Act III Luis Lavena

  121. None

  122. • One-Click Ruby
 Installer for Windows

  123. • One-Click Ruby
 Installer for Windows • Ruby core

  124. • One-Click Ruby
 Installer for Windows • Ruby core •

    Ruby Hero (2010)

  125. • One-Click Ruby
 Installer for Windows • Ruby core •

    Ruby Hero (2010) • rake-compiler

  126. rake-compiler-dev-box#2

  127. None
  128. None
  129. None
  130. None
  131. None

  132. @luislavena <3 <3 <3

  133. Find your Luis

  134. “Be the Luis you wish to see in the world”

  135. What have we learned?

  136. 1. Just use bcrypt

  137. 2. Distribute a dev box

  138. 3. Release, collaborate, iterate

  139. Thank You @tjschuck getHarvest.com