Share
Embed
あなたのWebサービスはAIに自動テストしてもらえる?アクセシビリティツリーで読み解く、AIの『視点』
この1年で、生成AIが自然言語を解釈してブラウザを操作する、Browser UseやPlaywright MCPといった自動テストの仕組みが次々と登場しました。しかし、これらのツールは一体どのようにWebサイトを『見て』、私たちの指示を解釈しているのでしょうか?
本セッションでは、そのAIの『視点』の正体の1つであるアクセシビリティツリーに焦点を当てます。Playwright MCPのソースコードをベースに、自然言語の指示がどのように解釈され、どのUI要素が特定されるのか、その内部プロセスを見ていきます。また、実際にRailsのシステムテストで使用するCapybaraドライバを作って、Railsとのつなぎの部分についても解説していきます。
Yusuke Iwaki
September 26, 2025
Transcript
84 slides
-
ੜ"*ʹΑΔςετࣗಈԽʁ ɾਓ͕ؒ$ISPNFΠϯεϖΫλΛۦͯ͠ϒϥβࣗಈૢ࡞ςετΛ࡞Δ ɹ࣌ऴΘΓ͕ݟ͖͑ͯͨ ࣗવݴޠ ʮϩάΠϯը໘ʯͰ &NBJMZVTVLFJXBLJ!FYʜ 1BTT)PHF)PHF ΛೖΕͯϩάΠϯ͢Δɻ μογϡϘʔυʹભҠͰ͖͍ͯͨΒɺ %FWJDFTλϒΛ։͍ͯ
'VMMZ.BOBHFEσόΠεͷ*.&*͕ ৄࡉը໘ʹग़͍ͯΔ͜ͱΛ֬ೝ͍ͨ͠ɻ ϩάΠϯը໘ʹඈ͞Ε͍ͯͨΒɺ̏ճ·Ͱ ϦτϥΠͯ͠΄͍͠ɻ ࣗવݴޠͰॻ͔ΕͨܭըΛͱʹ ϒϥβܦ༝ͰαΠτΛݟΔɾಈ͔͢ ࣗಈςετ༻ͷࣗಈૢ࡞εΫϦϓτ Λੜࣗಈम෮͢Δ &&ςετεΫϦϓτ ࣗతͳ ίϯςΩετऩू -
ੜ"*ʹΑΔςελϏϦςΟΛղ໌͢Δʂ ࣗવݴޠ ʮϩάΠϯը໘ʯͰ &NBJMZVTVLFJXBLJ!FYʜ 1BTT)PHF)PHF ΛೖΕͯϩάΠϯ͢Δɻ μογϡϘʔυʹભҠͰ͖͍ͯͨΒɺ %FWJDFTλϒΛ։͍ͯ 'VMMZ.BOBHFEσόΠεͷ*.&*͕ ৄࡉը໘ʹग़͍ͯΔ͜ͱΛ֬ೝ͍ͨ͠ɻ
ϩάΠϯը໘ʹඈ͞Ε͍ͯͨΒɺ̏ճ·Ͱ ϦτϥΠͯ͠΄͍͠ɻ ࣗతͳ ίϯςΩετऩू ੜ"*ɺ 8FCαʔϏεΛͲ͏ೝࣝͯ͠ ࣗಈૢ࡞͍ͯ͠Δʁ ͋ͳͨͷ8FCαʔϏε )PHF)PHF"*ͩͱ ͳΜ͔͏·͍͔͘ͳ͍ɻ 'VHB'VHB"*ͩͬͨΒ ͏·͘ಈ͔͘Β͜Ε͓͏͔ -
ੜ"*ʹΑΔςελϏϦςΟΛղ໌͢Δʂ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷͬ͘͟Γͷಈ͖ʢ෦ͷΈʣ Λઆ໌͠·͢ɻ w "*͕Ѳ͍͢͠αΠτߏ͔Ͳ͏͔Λ֬ೝ͢Δํ๏ɺ "*͕Ѳͮ͠Β͍αΠτߏͷࣄྫΛ͍͔ͭ͘հ͠·͢ɻ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͱಉ༷ͷΈͰͷࣗಈૢ࡞Λ $BQZCBSBυϥΠόͰ࣮ͯ͠Έ·͢ɻ
ࠓ͢͜ͱ #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1͕ͳ͘ͳͬͯɺࠓͷ༰ΛݟΕ 3VCZPO3BJMTͰࣗવݴޠͰςετΛॻ͘ΈΛ࡞Ε·͢ʂ -
#SPXTFS6TFͷ෦ϓϩϯϓτ :PVBSFBO"*BHFOUEFTJHOFEUPPQFSBUFJOBOJUFSBUJWFMPPQUPBVUPNBUFCSPXTFSUBTLT:PVSVMUJNBUFHPBMJT BDDPNQMJTIJOHUIFUBTLQSPWJEFEJOVTFS@SFRVFTU JOUSP :PVFYDFMBUGPMMPXJOHUBTLT /BWJHBUJOHDPNQMFYXFCTJUFTBOEFYUSBDUJOHQSFDJTFJOGPSNBUJPO "VUPNBUJOHGPSNTVCNJTTJPOTBOEJOUFSBDUJWFXFCBDUJPOT (BUIFSJOHBOETBWJOHJOGPSNBUJPO 6TJOHZPVS fi
MFTZTUFNF ff FDUJWFMZUPEFDJEFXIBUUPLFFQJOZPVSDPOUFYU 0QFSBUFF ff FDUJWFMZJOBOBHFOUMPPQ & ff i DJFOUMZQFSGPSNJOHEJWFSTFXFCUBTLT JOUSP MBOHVBHF@TFUUJOHT %FGBVMUXPSLJOHMBOHVBHF &OHMJTI "MXBZTSFTQPOEJOUIFTBNFMBOHVBHFBTUIFVTFSSFRVFTU MBOHVBHF@TFUUJOHT -
#SPXTFS6TFͷ෦ϓϩϯϓτ JOQVU "UFWFSZTUFQ ZPVSJOQVUXJMMDPOTJTUPG BHFOU@IJTUPSZ"DISPOPMPHJDBMFWFOUTUSFBNJODMVEJOHZPVSQSFWJPVTBDUJPOTBOEUIFJSSFTVMUT BHFOU@TUBUF$VSSFOUVTFS@SFRVFTU TVNNBSZPG fi MF@TZTUFN UPEP@DPOUFOUT
BOETUFQ@JOGP CSPXTFS@TUBUF$VSSFOU63- PQFOUBCT JOUFSBDUJWFFMFNFOUTJOEFYFEGPSBDUJPOT BOEWJTJCMFQBHFDPOUFOU CSPXTFS@WJTJPO4DSFFOTIPUPGUIFCSPXTFSXJUICPVOEJOHCPYFTBSPVOEJOUFSBDUJWFFMFNFOUT SFBE@TUBUF5IJTXJMMCFEJTQMBZFEPOMZJGZPVSQSFWJPVTBDUJPOXBTFYUSBDU@TUSVDUVSFE@EBUBPSSFBE@ fi MF5IJTEB JTPOMZTIPXOJOUIFDVSSFOUTUFQ JOQVU BHFOU@IJTUPSZ "HFOUIJTUPSZXJMMCFHJWFOBTBMJTUPGTUFQJOGPSNBUJPOBTGPMMPXT -
#SPXTFS6TFͷ෦ϓϩϯϓτ TUFQ@\TUFQ@OVNCFS^ &WBMVBUJPOPG1SFWJPVT4UFQ"TTFTTNFOUPGMBTUBDUJPO .FNPSZ:PVSNFNPSZPGUIJTTUFQ /FYU(PBM:PVSHPBMGPSUIJTTUFQ "DUJPO3FTVMUT:PVSBDUJPOTBOEUIFJSSFTVMUT TUFQ@\TUFQ@OVNCFS^ BOETZTUFNNFTTBHFTXSBQQFEJOTZTUBH BHFOU@IJTUPSZ VTFS@SFRVFTU
64&33&26&455IJTJTZPVSVMUJNBUFPCKFDUJWFBOEBMXBZTSFNBJOTWJTJCMF 5IJTIBTUIFIJHIFTUQSJPSJUZ.BLFUIFVTFSIBQQZ *GUIFVTFSSFRVFTUJTWFSZTQFDJ fi DUIFODBSFGVMMZGPMMPXFBDITUFQBOEEPOUTLJQPSIBMMVDJOBUFTUFQT *GUIFUBTLJTPQFOFOEFEZPVDBOQMBOZPVSTFMGIPXUPHFUJUEPOF VTFS@SFRVFTU -
#SPXTFS6TFͷ෦ϓϩϯϓτ CSPXTFS@TUBUF #SPXTFS4UBUFXJMMCFHJWFOBT $VSSFOU63-63-PGUIFQBHFZPVBSFDVSSFOUMZWJFXJOH 0QFO5BCT0QFOUBCTXJUIUIFJSJOEFYFT *OUFSBDUJWF&MFNFOUT"MMJOUFSBDUJWFFMFNFOUTXJMMCFQSPWJEFEJOGPSNBUBT<JOEFY>UZQFUFYUUZQFXIFSF JOEFY/VNFSJDJEFOUJ fi FSGPSJOUFSBDUJPO UZQF)5.-FMFNFOUUZQF
CVUUPO JOQVU FUD UFYU&MFNFOUEFTDSJQUJPO &YBNQMFT <>EJW6TFSGPSNEJW aU <>CVUUPOBSJBMBCFM4VCNJUGPSN4VCNJUCVUUPO /PUFUIBU 0OMZFMFNFOUTXJUIOVNFSJDJOEFYFTJO<>BSFJOUFSBDUJWF TUBDLFE JOEFOUBUJPO XJUIaU JTJNQPSUBOUBOENFBOTUIBUUIFFMFNFOUJTB IUNM DIJMEPGUIFFMFNFOUBCPWF XJU MPXFSJOEFY -
#SPXTFS6TFͷ෦ϓϩϯϓτ &MFNFOUTUBHHFEXJUIBTUBSA <ABSFUIFOFXJOUFSBDUJWFFMFNFOUTUIBUBQQFBSFEPOUIFXFCTJUFTJODFUIFMBTUTUF JGVSMIBTOPUDIBOHFE:PVSQSFWJPVTBDUJPOTDBVTFEUIBUDIBOHF5IJOLJGZPVOFFEUPJOUFSBDUXJUIUIFN FHBGUF JOQVU@UFYUZPVNJHIUOFFEUPTFMFDUUIFSJHIUPQUJPOGSPNUIFMJTU 1VSFUFYUFMFNFOUTXJUIPVU<>BSFOPUJOUFSBDUJWF CSPXTFS@TUBUF CSPXTFS@WJTJPO :PVXJMMCFQSPWJEFEXJUIBTDSFFOTIPUPGUIFDVSSFOUQBHFXJUICPVOEJOHCPYFTBSPVOEJOUFSBDUJWFFMFNFOUT5IJT
ZPVS(306/%5365)SFBTPOBCPVUUIFJNBHFJOZPVSUIJOLJOHUPFWBMVBUFZPVSQSPHSFTT *GBOJOUFSBDUJWFJOEFYJOTJEFZPVSCSPXTFS@TUBUFEPFTOPUIBWFUFYUJOGPSNBUJPO UIFOUIFJOUFSBDUJWFJOEFYJTXSJUUF BUUIFUPQDFOUFSPGJUTFMFNFOUJOUIFTDSFFOTIPU CSPXTFS@WJTJPO CSPXTFS@SVMFT 4USJDUMZGPMMPXUIFTFSVMFTXIJMFVTJOHUIFCSPXTFSBOEOBWJHBUJOHUIFXFC 0OMZJOUFSBDUXJUIFMFNFOUTUIBUIBWFBOVNFSJD<JOEFY>BTTJHOFE 0OMZVTFJOEFYFTUIBUBSFFYQMJDJUMZQSPWJEFE *GSFTFBSDIJTOFFEFE PQFOB OFXUBC JOTUFBEPGSFVTJOHUIFDVSSFOUPOF -
#SPXTFS6TFͷ෦ϓϩϯϓτ *GUIFQBHFDIBOHFTBGUFS GPSFYBNQMF BOJOQVUUFYUBDUJPO BOBMZTFJGZPVOFFEUPJOUFSBDUXJUIOFXFMFNFOUT FH TFMFDUJOHUIFSJHIUPQUJPOGSPNUIFMJTU #ZEFGBVMU POMZFMFNFOUTJOUIFWJTJCMFWJFXQPSUBSFMJTUFE6TFTDSPMMJOHUPPMTJGZPVTVTQFDUSFMFWBOUDPOUFOUJT P
ff TDSFFOXIJDIZPVOFFEUPJOUFSBDUXJUI4DSPMM0/-:JGUIFSFBSFNPSFQJYFMTCFMPXPSBCPWFUIFQBHF :PVDBOTDSPMMCZBTQFDJ fi DOVNCFSPGQBHFTVTJOHUIFOVN@QBHFTQBSBNFUFS FH GPSIBMGQBHF GPSUXP QBHFT *GBDBQUDIBBQQFBST BUUFNQUTPMWJOHJUJGQPTTJCMF*GOPU VTFGBMMCBDLTUSBUFHJFT FH BMUFSOBUJWFTJUF CBDLUSBDL *GFYQFDUFEFMFNFOUTBSFNJTTJOH USZSFGSFTIJOH TDSPMMJOH PSOBWJHBUJOHCBDL *GUIFQBHFJTOPUGVMMZMPBEFE VTFUIFXBJUBDUJPO :PVDBODBMMFYUSBDU@TUSVDUVSFE@EBUBPOTQFDJ fi DQBHFTUPHBUIFSTUSVDUVSFETFNBOUJDJOGPSNBUJPOGSPNUIFFOUJSF QBHF JODMVEJOHQBSUTOPUDVSSFOUMZWJTJCMF $BMMFYUSBDU@TUSVDUVSFE@EBUBPOMZJGUIFJOGPSNBUJPOZPVBSFMPPLJOHGPSJTOPUWJTJCMFJOZPVSCSPXTFS@TUBUF PUIFSXJTFBMXBZTKVTUVTFUIFOFFEFEUFYUGSPNUIFCSPXTFS@TUBUF $BMMJOHUIFFYUSBDU@TUSVDUVSFE@EBUBUPPMJTFYQFOTJWF%0/05RVFSZUIFTBNFQBHFXJUIUIFTBNF FYUSBDU@TUSVDUVSFE@EBUBRVFSZNVMUJQMFUJNFT.BLFTVSFUIBUZPVBSFPOUIFQBHFXJUISFMFWBOUJOGPSNBUJPOCBTFE UIFTDSFFOTIPUCFGPSFDBMMJOHUIJTUPPM *GZPV fi MMBOJOQVU fi FMEBOEZPVSBDUJPOTFRVFODFJTJOUFSSVQUFE NPTUPGUFOTPNFUIJOHDIBOHFEFHTVHHFTUJPOT QPQQFEVQVOEFSUIF fi FME -
#SPXTFS6TFͷ෦ϓϩϯϓτ *GUIFBDUJPOTFRVFODFXBTJOUFSSVQUFEJOQSFWJPVTTUFQEVFUPQBHFDIBOHFT NBLFTVSFUPDPNQMFUFBOZSFNBJO BDUJPOTUIBUXFSFOPUFYFDVUFE'PSFYBNQMF JGZPVUSJFEUPJOQVUUFYUBOEDMJDLBTFBSDICVUUPOCVUUIFDMJDLXBTO FYFDVUFECFDBVTFUIFQBHFDIBOHFE ZPVTIPVMESFUSZUIFDMJDLBDUJPOJOZPVSOFYUTUFQ *GUIFVTFS@SFRVFTUJODMVEFTTQFDJ fi DQBHFJOGPSNBUJPOTVDIBTQSPEVDUUZQF
SBUJOH QSJDF MPDBUJPO FUD USZUP BQQMZ fi MUFSTUPCFNPSFF ff i DJFOU 5IFVTFS@SFRVFTUJTUIFVMUJNBUFHPBM*GUIFVTFSTQFDJ fi FTFYQMJDJUTUFQT UIFZIBWFBMXBZTUIFIJHIFTUQSJPSJUZ *GZPVJOQVU@UFYUJOUPB fi FME ZPVNJHIUOFFEUPQSFTTFOUFS DMJDLUIFTFBSDICVUUPO PSTFMFDUGSPNESPQEPXOGPS DPNQMFUJPO %POUMPHJOJOUPBQBHFJGZPVEPOUIBWFUP%POUMPHJOJGZPVEPOUIBWFUIFDSFEFOUJBMT 5IFSFBSFUZQFTPGUBTLTBMXBZT fi STUUIJOLXIJDIUZQFPGSFRVFTUZPVBSFEFBMJOHXJUI 7FSZTQFDJ fi DTUFQCZTUFQJOTUSVDUJPOT 'PMMPXUIFNBTWFSZQSFDJTFBOEEPOUTLJQTUFQT5SZUPDPNQMFUFFWFSZUIJOHBTSFRVFTUFE 0QFOFOEFEUBTLT1MBOZPVSTFMG CFDSFBUJWFJOBDIJFWJOHUIFN *GZPVHFUTUVDLFHXJUIMPHJOTPSDBQUDIBJOPQFOFOEFEUBTLTZPVDBOSFFWBMVBUFUIFUBTLBOEUSZBMUFSOBUJWF XBZT FHTPNFUJNFTBDDJEFOUBMMZMPHJOQPQTVQ FWFOUIPVHIUIFSFTPNFQBSUPGUIFQBHFJTBDDFTTJCMFPSZPVHFU TPNFJOGPSNBUJPOWJBXFCTFBSDI *GZPVSFBDIB1%'WJFXFS UIF fi MFJTBVUPNBUJDBMMZEPXOMPBEFEBOEZPVDBOTFFJUTQBUIJOBWBJMBCMF@ fi MF@QBUIT: ʢ·ͩ·ͩଓ͘ʜʣ -
#SPXTFS6TFͷ෦ϓϩϯϓτ \ UIJOLJOH5IFVTFSSFRVFTUJTUPTFBSDIGPSaϞεόʔΨʔaPOCPUI:BIPP+BQBOBOE3BLVUFO*DIJCB TVNNBSJ[FUIFUPQ SFTVMUTGSPNFBDI BOEPVUQVUUIFNJOB.BSLEPXOUBCMF4JODFUIJTJTBNVMUJTUFQUBTL *TIPVMEDSFBUFBUPEPNE fi MFUPUSB QSPHSFTT$VSSFOUMZ
UIFCSPXTFSJTPOBCPVUCMBOLBOEOPUIJOHJTMPBEFE.Z fi STUHPBMJTUPOBWJHBUFUP:BIPP+BQBO IUUQT XXXZBIPPDPKQ UPCFHJOUIFTFBSDIQSPDFTT FWBMVBUJPO@QSFWJPVT@HPBM/PQSFWJPVTBDUJPOUBLFOZFUJOJUJBMJ[BUJPOPOMZ NFNPSZ5BTLKVTUTUBSUFE/FFEUPWJTJU:BIPP+BQBOBOE3BLVUFO*DIJCB QFSGPSNTFBSDIFT TVNNBSJ[FSFTVMUT BOE PVUQVUJO.BSLEPXOUBCMF OFYU@HPBM/BWJHBUFUP:BIPP+BQBOIPNFQBHFUPTUBSUUIFTFBSDIGPSϞεόʔΨʔ BDUJPO< \ HP@UP@VSM\ VSMIUUQTXXXZBIPPDPKQ OFX@UBCGBMTF ^ ^ -
#SPXTFS6TFͷϒϥβૢ࡞ ࡞ઓձٞ ࣗಈૢ࡞ ใऩू ɾ७ਮͳ$%1 %FW5PPMT1SPUPDPM ʹΑΔ ɹϒϥβࣗಈૢ࡞ ʢͪͳΈʹॳظͷόʔδϣϯͰ1MBZXSJHIUΛ͍ͬͯͨʣ \
HP@UP@VSM\ VSMIUUQTXXXZBIPPDPKQ OFX@UBCGBMTF ^ -
#SPXTFS6TFͷϒϥβૢ࡞ &MFNFOUTZPVDBOJOUFSBDUXJUIJOTJEFUIFWJFXQPSU <4UBSUPGQBHF> ϫϯΫϦοΫͰ :BIPP+"1"/Λ։͘ʹ <>B ࠓ͙͢ઃఆ͢Δ <>EJW <>B ด͡Δ
<>B ϗʔϜϖʔδʹઃఆ͢Δ <>B :BIPP## <>B ͖ͬͣ൛ <>B ΞϓϦ൛ ɾΞΫγϣϯՄೳͳ ɹ%0.ཁૉҰཡ ΞΫγϣϯՄೳͳ%0.ཁૉ ͷҐஔΛϝογϡͰ͔Ϳͤͨ εΫϦʔϯγϣοτ -
#SPXTFS6TFͷϒϥβૢ࡞ BDUJPO< \ JOQVU@UFYU\ JOEFY UFYUϞεόʔΨʔ DMFBS@FYJTUJOHUSVF ^
^ \ DMJDL@FMFNFOU@CZ@JOEFY\ JOEFY XIJMF@IPMEJOH@DUSMOVMM ^ ^ > ^ <> <> ϞεόʔΨʔc -
1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷಈ࡞ղੳ \ CSPXTFS@OBWJHBUF VSMIUUQXXXZBIPPDPKQ ^ .$1αʔόʔ QMBZXSJHIUDISPNJVNMBVODI QBHFCSPXTFSOFX1BHF
QBHFHPUP bIUUQTXXXZBIPPDPKQ 1MBZXSJHIU.$1 .$1ͰϦϞʔτͷϝιουݺͼग़͠ ࣮ߦ݁Ռ -
1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷϒϥβૢ࡞ ɾཁૉͷΫϦοΫจࣈೖྗʁ SFGΛख͕͔Γʹ ϒϥβૢ࡞ ϞεόʔΨʔc SFG<F> SFG<F> CSPXTFS@UZQF FMFNFOUTFBSDICPY SFGF
UFYUϞεόʔΨʔ CSPXTFS@UZQF CSPXTFS@DMJDL -
1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷϖʔδѲ ɾQBHFTOBQTIPUͱΒΛͬͯϖʔδߏΛѲ͍ͯ͠Δ 1BHF5JUMFʮϞεόʔΨʔʯͷݕࡧ݁Ռ:BIPPݕࡧ 1BHF4OBQTIPU AAAZBNM HFOFSJD<BDUJWF><SFGF> HFOFSJD<SFGF> CBOOFS<SFGF> HFOFSJD<SFGF> CVUUPOϝΠϯίϯςϯπεΩοϓ
HFOFSJD<SFGF><DVSTPSQPJOUFS>ϝΠϯίϯςϯπεΩοϓ HFOFSJD<SFGF> MJOL:BIPP+"1"/<SFGF><DVSTPSQPJOUFS> VSMIUUQTXXXZBIPPDPKQ IFBEJOH:BIPP+"1"/<MFWFM> JNH<SFGF> -
1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷͬ͘͟Γ֓ཁ XXXZBIPPDPKQͰ ϞεόʔΨʔ͕݅ͯ͞͠ ใऩू ϒϥβૢ࡞ 1MBZXSJHIU.$1 1MBZXSJHIU ΞΫηγϏϦςΟπϦʔΛϕʔεʹ ϖʔδΛѲͯ͠Β͏ɻ .$1αʔόʔ
1BHF5JUMFʮϞεόʔΨʔʯͷݕࡧ݁Ռ:BIPPݕࡧ 1BHF4OBQTIPU AAAZBNM HFOFSJD<BDUJWF><SFGF> HFOFSJD<SFGF> CBOOFS<SFGF> HFOFSJD<SFGF> CVUUPOϝΠϯίϯςϯπεΩοϓ HFOFSJD<SFGF><DVSTPSQPJOUFS>ϝΠϯίϯςϯπεΩοϓ HFOFSJD<SFGF> MJOL:BIPP+"1"/<SFGF><DVSTPSQPJOUFS> VSMIUUQTXXXZBIPPDPKQ IFBEJOH:BIPP+"1"/<MFWFM> JNH<SFGF> -
ੜ"*ʹΑΔςελϏϦςΟΛղ໌͢Δʂ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷͬ͘͟Γͷಈ͖ʢ෦ͷΈʣ Λઆ໌͠·͢ɻ w "*͕Ѳ͍͢͠αΠτߏ͔Ͳ͏͔Λ֬ೝ͢Δํ๏ɺ "*͕Ѳͮ͠Β͍αΠτߏͷࣄྫΛ͍͔ͭ͘հ͠·͢ɻ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͱಉ༷ͷΈͰͷࣗಈૢ࡞Λ $BQZCBSBυϥΠόͰ࣮ͯ͠Έ·͢ɻ
ࠓ͢͜ͱ #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1͕ͳ͘ͳͬͯɺࠓͷ༰ΛݟΕ 3VCZPO3BJMTͰࣗવݴޠͰςετΛॻ͘ΈΛ࡞Ε·͢ʂ -
ੜ"*ʹΑΔςελϏϦςΟΛղ໌͢Δʂ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷͬ͘͟Γͷಈ͖ʢ෦ͷΈʣ Λઆ໌͠·͢ɻ w "*͕Ѳ͍͢͠αΠτߏ͔Ͳ͏͔Λ֬ೝ͢Δํ๏ɺ "*͕Ѳͮ͠Β͍αΠτߏͷࣄྫΛ͍͔ͭ͘հ͠·͢ɻ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͱಉ༷ͷΈͰͷࣗಈૢ࡞Λ $BQZCBSBυϥΠόͰ࣮ͯ͠Έ·͢ɻ
ࠓ͢͜ͱ #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1͕ͳ͘ͳͬͯɺࠓͷ༰ΛݟΕ 3VCZPO3BJMTͰࣗવݴޠͰςετΛॻ͘ΈΛ࡞Ε·͢ʂ -
ϖʔδߏѲͷͨΊͷ"95SFF ݕࡧΆ͍ཁૉͱɺΞΫηγϏϦςΟπϦʔ͔Β ʮԡͤͦ͏ʯʮೖྗͰ͖ͦ͏ʯͳ%0.ཁૉΛ ΨΠυͱͯ͠දࣔ 1BHF5JUMFʮϞεόʔΨʔʯͷݕࡧ݁Ռ:BIPPݕࡧ 1BHF4OBQTIPU AAAZBNM HFOFSJD<BDUJWF><SFGF> HFOFSJD<SFGF> CBOOFS<SFGF>
HFOFSJD<SFGF> CVUUPOϝΠϯίϯςϯπεΩοϓ HFOFSJD<SFGF><DVSTPSQPJOUFS>ϝΠϯίϯςϯπεΩοϓ HFOFSJD<SFGF> MJOL:BIPP+"1"/<SFGF><DVSTPSQPJOUFS> ΞΫηγϏϦςΟπϦʔΛϕʔεʹ ϖʔδΛѲɻ࣍ΞΫγϣϯΛܾΊΔ ੜ"*ʹΑΔѲͷ͢͠͞㲈ΞΫηγϏϦςΟπϦʔͷ໌շ͞ -
ಠ࣮ࣗͨ͠ΞίʔσΟΦϯ UFYUΑ͘ݟ͔͚Δ$44POMZΞίʔσΟΦϯͰ͢ɻݟ ͨඒ͘͠ಈ࡞͠·͕͢ɺΞΫηγϏϦςΟͷ؍ Ͱଟ͘ͷ͕͋Γ·͢ɻΑ͋͘Δ࣭αʔϏε ͷར༻ྉۚʹ͍ͭͯ˝جຊϓϥϯֹ݄ ԁ͔ Β͝ར༻͍͚ͨͩ·͢ɻϓϨϛΞϜϓϥϯͰՃػ ೳΛ͝ར༻͍͚ͨͩ·͢ɻৄࡉͳྉۚମܥʹ͍ͭͯ ɺྉۚϖʔδΛ֬͝ೝ͍ͩ͘͞ɻΑ͋͘Δ࣭ ΞΧϯτͷ࡞ํ๏˝τοϓϖʔδͷʮ৽نొʯ
Ϙλϯ͔ΒΞΧϯτΛ࡞Ͱ͖·͢ɻϝʔϧΞυϨ εͱύεϫʔυΛ͝ೖྗ͍͖ͨͩɺ֬ೝϝʔϧΛ͓ૹ Γ͠·͢ɻΑ͋͘Δ࣭σʔλͷ҆શੑʹͭ -
ੜ"*ʹΑΔςελϏϦςΟΛղ໌͢Δʂ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷͬ͘͟Γͷಈ͖ʢ෦ͷΈʣ Λઆ໌͠·͢ɻ w "*͕Ѳ͍͢͠αΠτߏ͔Ͳ͏͔Λ֬ೝ͢Δํ๏ɺ "*͕Ѳͮ͠Β͍αΠτߏͷࣄྫΛ͍͔ͭ͘հ͠·͢ɻ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͱಉ༷ͷΈͰͷࣗಈૢ࡞Λ $BQZCBSBυϥΠόͰ࣮ͯ͠Έ·͢ɻ
ࠓ͢͜ͱ #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1͕ͳ͘ͳͬͯɺࠓͷ༰ΛݟΕ 3VCZPO3BJMTͰࣗવݴޠͰςετΛॻ͘ΈΛ࡞Ε·͢ʂ -
ੜ"*ʹΑΔςελϏϦςΟΛղ໌͢Δʂ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷͬ͘͟Γͷಈ͖ʢ෦ͷΈʣ Λઆ໌͠·͢ɻ w "*͕Ѳ͍͢͠αΠτߏ͔Ͳ͏͔Λ֬ೝ͢Δํ๏ɺ "*͕Ѳͮ͠Β͍αΠτߏͷࣄྫΛ͍͔ͭ͘հ͠·͢ɻ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͱಉ༷ͷΈͰͷࣗಈૢ࡞Λ $BQZCBSBυϥΠόͰ࣮ͯ͠Έ·͢ɻ
ࠓ͢͜ͱ #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1͕ͳ͘ͳͬͯɺࠓͷ༰ΛݟΕ 3VCZPO3BJMTͰࣗવݴޠͰςετΛॻ͘ΈΛ࡞Ε·͢ʂ -
3VCZ3BJMTͰ͑ΔΈ͕ແ͍ #SPXTFS6TF 1MBZXSJHIU.$1 ɾࣗવݴޠͰϒϥβΛ͙Γ͙Γͱಈ͔ͤΔϥΠϒϥϦ 1ZUIPOͷ"HFOU͕ ੜ"*"1*ͱ$%1ͱΓͱΓ /PEFKTϕʔεͷ࣮ɻ 3VCZ3BJMTͰಉ͜͡ͱΔʹ શͳ࠶࣮͕ඞཁ 3VCZ3BJMT͔Β͏ʹɺ
$BQZCBSB͕.$1ΫϥΠΞϯτͱ ੜ"*"1*ͱΓͱΓ͢Δʁ ݱ࣮తͰͳ͍ -
վળϙΠϯτ"3*"TOBQTIPUͷಋೖ ϒϥβը໘ ࣍ͷΞΫγϣϯ &NBJMʜ 1BTT Λೖྗ ੜ "* 3VCZίʔυ εΫϦʔϯ
γϣοτ ݱࡏͷ63- $BQZCBSB ϒϥβ ૢ࡞ "3*" 4OBQTIPU "3*"SFG ϕʔεͰͷૢ࡞ ESJWFSDBQUVSF@TDSFFOTIPUͱಉ༷ʹ ESJWFSBSJB@TOBQTIPUΛར༻Մೳʹɻ ESJWFSFYFDVUF@TDSJQU@XJUI@SFG F FMFMGPDVT z ͷΑ͏ʹ"3*"SFGࢦఆͰεΫϦϓτΛ࣮ߦՄೳʹɻ -
ੜ"*ʹΑΔςελϏϦςΟΛղ໌͢Δʂ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͷͬ͘͟Γͷಈ͖ʢ෦ͷΈʣ Λઆ໌͠·͢ɻ w "*͕Ѳ͍͢͠αΠτߏ͔Ͳ͏͔Λ֬ೝ͢Δํ๏ɺ "*͕Ѳͮ͠Β͍αΠτߏͷࣄྫΛ͍͔ͭ͘հ͠·͢ɻ w #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1ͱಉ༷ͷΈͰͷࣗಈૢ࡞Λ $BQZCBSBυϥΠόͰ࣮ͯ͠Έ·͢ɻ
ࠓ͢͜ͱ #SPXTFS6TF1MBZXSJHIU.$1͕ͳ͘ͳͬͯɺࠓͷ༰ΛݟΕ 3VCZPO3BJMTͰࣗવݴޠͰςετΛॻ͘ΈΛ࡞Ε·͢ʂ -
࠶ܝ ੜ"*ʹΑΔςετࣗಈԽ ɾਓ͕ؒ$ISPNFΠϯεϖΫλΛۦͯ͠ϒϥβࣗಈςετΛ࡞Δ ɹ࣌ऴΘΓ͕ݟ͖͑ͯͨ ࣗવݴޠ ʮϩάΠϯը໘ʯͰ &NBJMZVTVLFJXBLJ!FYʜ 1BTT)PHF)PHF ΛೖΕͯϩάΠϯ͢Δɻ μογϡϘʔυʹભҠͰ͖͍ͯͨΒɺ
%FWJDFTλϒΛ։͍ͯ 'VMMZ.BOBHFEσόΠεͷ*.&*͕ ৄࡉը໘ʹग़͍ͯΔ͜ͱΛ֬ೝ͍ͨ͠ɻ ϩάΠϯը໘ʹඈ͞Ε͍ͯͨΒɺ̏ճ·Ͱ ϦτϥΠͯ͠΄͍͠ɻ ࣗવݴޠͰॻ͔ΕͨܭըΛͱʹ ϒϥβܦ༝ͰαΠτΛݟΔɾಈ͔͢ ࣗಈςετ༻ͷࣗಈૢ࡞εΫϦϓτ Λੜࣗಈम෮͢Δ &&ςετεΫϦϓτ ࣗతͳ ίϯςΩετऩू -
কདྷతʹɺςετࣗಈԽͷࣗಈԽ ɾਓ͕ؒ$ISPNFΠϯεϖΫλΛۦͯ͠ϒϥβࣗಈςετΛ࡞Δ ɹ࣌ऴΘΒͤΑ͏ʂ ࣗવݴޠ ʮϩάΠϯը໘ʯͰ &NBJMZVTVLFJXBLJ!FYʜ 1BTT)PHF)PHF ΛೖΕͯϩάΠϯ͢Δɻ 8FC%SJWFS #J%J
ݱঢ়ϥϯλΠϜͰ"*ʹฉ͍ͯϒϥβૢ࡞ ɹˠ͗͢Δɻίετ͔͔Δɻ ࣗવݴޠ ʮϩάΠϯը໘ʯͰ &NBJMZVTVLFJXBLJ!FYʜ 1BTT)PHF)PHF ΛೖΕͯϩάΠϯ͢Δɻ 8FC%SJWFS #J%J 8FC%SJWFS #J%J ։ൃ࣌ɿ"*ʹฉ͍ͯςετίʔυੜϝϯς ϥϯλΠϜɿੜࡁΈͷίʔυΛ࣮ߦ͢Δ͚ͩ