Share
Embed
Exoplanet population inference: a tutorial
My talk at the KITP exostar conference
Dan Foreman-Mackey
May 22, 2019
Transcript
89 slides
-
Today I'll mostly talk about transiting exoplanets*. The methods can
apply more broadly . * this is what I know about and work on! -
1 10 100 orbital period [days] 1 10 planet radius
[R ] data: NASA Exoplanet Archive -
leteness model 2013; Farr et al. is shortcoming ch pipeline
and igura et al. . hortcoming by eteness of the 2014) through s. In this study, Kepler pipeline rive the planet Kepler planet other highlight the systematic ce rates with ) and Dong & ysis where we recalculate the input assump- Figure 1. Fractional completeness model for the host to Kepler-22b (KIC: 10593626) in the Q1-Q16 pipeline run using the analytic model described in Section 2. t 10 Burke et al. Burke, Christiansen et al. (2015) -
Take these catalogs and get the physics of planet formation
and evolution. -
1 10 100 orbital period [days] 1 10 planet radius
[R ] data: NASA Exoplanet Archive -
Fulton & Petigura (2018) 8. Planets with g grazing transit
covariances w darkening duri After applying these Where possible, properties to the Ke radius and temper parameters. We cou stellar population b directed specificall population. After fil We calculated pla efficiency methodolo the detection sensit recovery tests perfo K02403.01 17.98 K00988.01 60.03 Note. This table contains filters described in Sectio (This table is available in Figure 5. The distribution of close-in planet sizes. The top panel shows the distribution from Fulton et al. (2017) and the bottom panel is the updated distribution from this work. The solid line shows the number of planets per star with orbital periods less than 100days as a function of planet size. A deep -
3 The expected number of planets per star per unit
planet property . -
So. It can be hard to compare and understand how
they relate. -
Them: * "The occurrence rate is 10%." Y'all: "what does
it all mean?!?1?" * including me and others in the room -
Them: * "The occurrence rate is 10%." Y'all: "what does
it all mean?!?1?" * including me and others in the room -
Fulton & Petigura (2018) 8. Planets with g grazing transit
covariances w darkening duri After applying these Where possible, properties to the Ke radius and temper parameters. We cou stellar population b directed specificall population. After fil We calculated pla efficiency methodolo the detection sensit recovery tests perfo K02403.01 17.98 K00988.01 60.03 Note. This table contains filters described in Sectio (This table is available in Figure 5. The distribution of close-in planet sizes. The top panel shows the distribution from Fulton et al. (2017) and the bottom panel is the updated distribution from this work. The solid line shows the number of planets per star with orbital periods less than 100days as a function of planet size. A deep -
Fulton & Petigura (2018) 8. Planets with g grazing transit
covariances w darkening duri After applying these Where possible, properties to the Ke radius and temper parameters. We cou stellar population b directed specificall population. After fil We calculated pla efficiency methodolo the detection sensit recovery tests perfo K02403.01 17.98 K00988.01 60.03 Note. This table contains filters described in Sectio (This table is available in Figure 5. The distribution of close-in planet sizes. The top panel shows the distribution from Fulton et al. (2017) and the bottom panel is the updated distribution from this work. The solid line shows the number of planets per star with orbital periods less than 100days as a function of planet size. A deep what do these numbers mean? -
Fulton & Petigura (2018) 8. Planets with g grazing transit
covariances w darkening duri After applying these Where possible, properties to the Ke radius and temper parameters. We cou stellar population b directed specificall population. After fil We calculated pla efficiency methodolo the detection sensit recovery tests perfo K02403.01 17.98 K00988.01 60.03 Note. This table contains filters described in Sectio (This table is available in Figure 5. The distribution of close-in planet sizes. The top panel shows the distribution from Fulton et al. (2017) and the bottom panel is the updated distribution from this work. The solid line shows the number of planets per star with orbital periods less than 100days as a function of planet size. A deep what do these numbers mean? The expected number of planets per star with a period in the range 0–100 days and radius in the given bin . -
1 Inverse detection efficiency Nexpect = 1 Ntot N X
j=1 1 Pdet(xj) Note: don't do this! -
2 Probabilistic modeling Nexpect = arg maxNexpect p(Nobs, {xj }
| Nexpect, Ntot) -
P(qj ) true number of planets nj, xj observed number
of planets the properties of the planets and the star want have -
P(nj | xj , qj ) observed number of planets
true number of planets the properties of the planets and the star -
value of P(nj | xj , qj ) 1 1–Pdet
(xj ) 0 Pdet (xj ) qj = 0 1 true number of planets nj =0 1 observed number of planets -
P(nj | xj) = X qj 2{0, 1} P(qj) P(nj
| xj, qj) = Q P(nj | xj, qj= 1) + (1 Q) P(nj | xj, qj= 0) -
P(nj | xj) = X qj 2{0, 1} P(qj) P(nj
| xj, qj) = Q P(nj | xj, qj= 1) + (1 Q) P(nj | xj, qj= 0) -
P(nj | xj) = X qj 2{0, 1} P(qj) P(nj
| xj, qj) = Q P(nj | xj, qj= 1) + (1 Q) P(nj | xj, qj= 0) this is the parameter that we want to fit for! -
P(nj = 1) = p(xj) P(nj = 1 | xj)
= p(xj) Q P(nj = 1 | xj, qj= 1) P(nj = 0) = Z p(xj) P(nj = 0 | xj) dxj = 1 Q Z p(xj) P(nj = 1 | xj, qj= 1) dxj = 1 Q P0 systems with no planets systems with detected planets -
P(nj = 1) = p(xj) P(nj = 1 | xj)
= p(xj) Q P(nj = 1 | xj, qj= 1) P(nj = 0) = Z p(xj) P(nj = 0 | xj) dxj = 1 Q Z p(xj) P(nj = 1 | xj, qj= 1) dxj = 1 Q P0 detection probability systems with no planets systems with detected planets -
Q = N1 N0 + N1 1 P0 6= 1
N0 + N1 N1 X j=1 1 Pj the occurrence rate the fraction of stars with observed planets -
Q = N1 N0 + N1 1 P0 6= 1
N0 + N1 N1 X j=1 1 Pj P0 = Z p(xj) P(nj = 1 | xj, qj= 1) dxj the detection probability averaged over the distribution of planet and stellar properties the occurrence rate the fraction of stars with observed planets -
Q = N1 N0 + N1 1 P0 6= 1
N0 + N1 N1 X j=1 1 Pj P0 = Z p(xj) P(nj = 1 | xj, qj= 1) dxj the detection probability averaged over the distribution of planet and stellar properties the occurrence rate the fraction of stars with observed planets -
truth: 50 inverse-detection-efficiency gives: 28.5 ± 5.5 maximum-likelihood gives: 54.0
± 10.4 see: dfm.io/posts/histogram1 -
Instead, take the fraction of detections and divide by the
average detection efficiency*. * averaged over the correct distribution for all planet and star properties -
leteness model 2013; Farr et al. is shortcoming ch pipeline
and igura et al. . hortcoming by eteness of the 2014) through s. In this study, Kepler pipeline rive the planet Kepler planet other highlight the systematic ce rates with ) and Dong & ysis where we recalculate the input assump- Figure 1. Fractional completeness model for the host to Kepler-22b (KIC: 10593626) in the Q1-Q16 pipeline run using the analytic model described in Section 2. t 10 Burke et al. Burke, Christiansen et al. (2015) -
You end up needing to do an integral over all
the properties of all the planets and false positives that you didn't observe . -
Likelihood-free inference is a method for doing rigorous inference with
stochastic models . -
If you can simulate it then you can do inference.
a realistic catalog The promise of "likelihood-free inference". -
PLANET OCCURRENCE RATES 11 Figure 2. Inferred occurrence rates for
Kepler’s DR25 planet candidates associated with high-quality FGK target stars. These rares are based on a combined detection and vetting efficiency model that was fit to flux-level planet injection tests. The numerical values of the occurrence Hsu et al. (2019) -
EPOS; Mulders et al. (2018) no additional s indicate the
Figure 10. Comparison of simulated planets for the example model (blue) with detected planets (orange). The comparison region (black box) excludes hot -
EPOS; Mulders et al. (2018) no additional s indicate the
Figure 10. Comparison of simulated planets for the example model (blue) with detected planets (orange). The comparison region (black box) excludes hot -
Don't sum the inverse detection probabilities for your planets! *
a more reliable estimator is just as easy to compute! -
If you're using a method that seems intuitive , make
sure the math checks out ! -
Likelihood-free inference seems like a promising way forward. * a.k.a.
Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) -
p({nj }, {xj } | Q) = [1 Q P0]N0
2 4 N1 Y j=1 Q p(xj) P(nj = 1 | xj, qj= 1) 3 5 -
log p({nj }, {xj } | Q) = N0 log
(1 Q P0) + N1 log Q + constant -
log p({nj }, {xj } | Q) = N0 log
(1 Q P0) + N1 log Q + constant Q = N1 N0 + N1 1 P0 6= 1 N0 + N1 N1 X j=1 1 Pj -
Note: this is preliminary & really just a toy… assuming:
no mutual inclination only geometric transit probability 0.5 < RP /REarth < 8; 10 < a/Rstar < 30 Kepler data: github.com/dfm/exostar19 -
0.5 < RP /REarth < 8; 10 < a/Rstar <
30 Kepler data: github.com/dfm/exostar19 Note: this is preliminary & really just a toy… assuming: no mutual inclination only geometric transit probability