How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes

Keynote at AEMS Conference 2017, Bangkok

Transcript

1. Stephan Krusche: Keynote AEMS Conference 2017, March 27 How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes s.krusche@tum.de - www.skrusche.de - @skrusche
2. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes 2 What are large classes?
3. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes 3 This a large class …
4. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Traditional courses with large classes 4 Educator Lecture Exercise Student Delay (week)
5. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes 5 Lecture Educator Exercise Student Computer based and experiential learning Delay (day)
6. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Interactive learning 6 delay (min) Delay (min) Educator Theory Student Exercise Interactive class ➡ Multiple iterations in one class
7. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Interactive learning 7 “Tell me and I will forget. Show me and I will remember. Involve me and I will understand. Step back and I will act.” — Chinese Proverb Immediate feedback Definition: Educators teach and exercise small chunks of content in short cycles in class. 
 They provide guidance to prevent misconception and immediate feedback so that learners can reflect on the content and increase their knowledge incrementally. Exercise Example Solution Reflection Theory Student
8. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Typical in-class exercise types Individual exercises • E1 Quizzes with multiple choice questions • E2 Tutorials with step by step instructions • E3 Coding challenges to solve programming assignments • E4 Modeling exercises Team exercises • E5 Project team work (including communication and collaboration aspects) ➡ (Semi-) automatic correction reduces the effort of the instructor 8
9. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Example E1: quiz with checkmarks 9
10. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Example E1: quiz with drag and drop exercise 10
11. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Best practices: quizzes • Alternate different quiz types, e.g. checkmarks, drop down, drag and drop, fill blanks • Double check the correctness of question and answer choices • Avoid too complex questions and answer choices (e.g. avoid double negation) • Avoid too many answer options • Mix easy, medium and difficult questions in each quiz to keep the motivation high • Possible tools: Moodle, edX, Google Forms, … 11
12. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Example E2: tutorials with step by step instructions 12 Teaching assistant
13. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Best practices: tutorials with step by step instructions • Precisely describe each step (distribute slides before class) • Ask whether students can follow during the exercise • Offer optional challenges for experienced students • If possible have teaching assistants (TAs) in class who help the students if they face problems • Repeat crucial steps • Take your time - do not rush through the tutorial 13
14. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Example E3: coding challenge 14
15. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Automatic assessment of coding challenges 15 Student Version Control Server 1 submit solution Continuous Integration Server 2 check for changes 3 compile, run tests 4 notify student with feedback
16. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Best practices: coding challenge • Reward all students (not only the best ones) • Add tasks directly into the source code or next to the source code • Optional challenges for experienced students • Allow successful failures • Put effort in automatic testing and automatic feedback —> less manual correction • Possible tools: AutoGrader, ArTEMiS (https://github.com/ls1intum/ArTEMiS) 16
17. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Example E4: modeling exercise 17 Typical beginner error Good structure that should appear in each solution
18. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Best practices: modeling exercises • Precisely define what should be modeled • Give students the possibility to present their solutions • Show exemplary student solutions (anonymized) and point out typical errors and correct parts • Show intermediate solutions and/or give hints • Let students use the tool of their choice for modeling • Let students be creative 18
19. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Example E5: project team work 19
20. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes 20 Example E5: project team work
21. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Example E5: project team work 21
22. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes 22 46.5 cm Fake
23. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Best practices: project team work • Plan time for finding teams • Integrate all students in the lecture hall • If possible: include assessment metrics to motivate all team members to participate • Clearly communicate the goals, but provide freedom for creative deviations • Plan your time: team exercises are very time consuming ➡They bring a lot of fun! 23
24. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Example: combination of different types of exercises 24
25. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Best practices for in-class exercises • Clearly describe the exercise goals • Avoid complex setups and make it easy for students to participate • Show a timer and give time extensions if necessary • Hire teaching assistants or very good students in your class: • Walk around and help students • Check if they are doing the right things • Take your time and walk around as well to get a feeling • Create a culture that failures are allowed and reward if students learn from such failures 25
26. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Informal communication increases the interaction 26
27. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Courses in which we apply interactive learning (1) Bachelor: Introduction to Software Engineering (~1400 students) (2) Master: Patterns in Software Engineering (PSE) (~400 students) (3) Bachelor / Master: Project Organization and Management (POM) (~400 students) (4) Bachelor / Master: Introduction to iOS and Swift Programming (~100 students) (5) Bachelor / Master: Software Engineering Essentials (MOOC) 27
28. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes 28 What students say about courses where we apply interactive learning … “The course is highly interactive and practical usage oriented. It keeps the mind pacing and makes it easier to understand the concepts.” “The interwoven format of lectures and exercises allow me to activate the obtained knowledge immediately after getting them. 
 I deem this very efficient, as the course itself is rather practical.” “The interactive lectures are very useful and interesting.“ “Best lecture in the Informatics faculty.”
29. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Perceived improved learning 29 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% In the exercises, I was able to improve 
 my skills in agile methods I am confident to apply agile 
 methods in my next team project 3% 3% 9% 12% 88% 85% Agree Neutral Disagree ➡ Similar results for other taught topics
30. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Perceived improved learning 30 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 9% 11% 24% 10% 13% 7% 26% 24% 23% 14% 16% 13% 65% 65% 53% 76% 71% 80% Agree Neutral Disagree The mix of theory and exercises in 
 class contributed to my learning success The mix of theory and exercises 
 improved my understanding during class In-class exercises motivated me to attend the lecture Quizzes motivated me during class to actively listen Interactive tutorials were particularly helpful 
 to understand concepts that I did not know before Team exercises helped me to apply a concept in a different setting to deepen my knowledge and understanding
31. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes 31 0 70 140 210 280 350 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 63 71 62 44 87 109 123 222 104 199 103 149 192 125 199 Participants per class (2014) Total participants: 345 58% 36% 56% 43% 30% 58% 30% 64% 36% 32% 25% 13% 18% 21% 18% Higher participation Traditional teaching 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 154 142 149 153 175 168 192 185 186 217 211 221 203 Participants per class (2016) Total Participants: 272 75% 81% 78% 80% 68% 68% 71% 62% 64% 56% 55% 52% 57% Interactive learning
32. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Finding 3: correlation between participation and grade 32 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 2.0 2.1 2.3 2.5 3.1 2.4 2.5 2.9 3.6 3.9 GPA in POM GPA in PSE Exercise participation 20 % 40 % 60 % 80 % 100 % 0 % POM: χ2 = 82.53 (p < 0.0001) PSE: χ2 = 48.01 (p < 0.0001) (lower grade = better) bad grade good grade
33. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes How should I start with interactive learning? Recommendations • Start with quizzes • Easy to setup and maintain during class • But: don’t overdo it! • Include small live tutorials • Also easy to setup and maintain during class • Try it out and iteratively improve the exercises during class 33
34. Stephan Krusche - Keynote AEMS Conference 2017: How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes Conclusion about interactive learning + Tighter integration of lectures and exercises leads to interactive classes + Higher participation in classes than in traditional courses + Correlation between exercise participation and final exam grade + Scalable and applicable to large classes without increasing teaching effort significantly ✓ Want to adopt this approach? Talk to us or send us a mail: s.krusche@tum.de ✓ More information on www.interactive-learning.org 34
35. How to Integrate Interactive Learning into Large Classes s.krusche@tum.de - www.skrusche.de - @skrusche Thank you! Stephan Krusche: Keynote AEMS Conference 2017, March 27