Share
Embed
Blindsided by security
Laura Bell
July 25, 2015
Transcript
45 slides
-
O hai there • Britta • Adaptive technology consultant, RNZFB
• Solve hardware, software and information based technology issues • Laura • Security Consultant, Lateral Security • Web application penetration tester and former software developer -
Disclaimer • The examples and organisations referenced in this presentation
are representative of the issues. • This talk isn’t really about them though • This isn’t a witch hunt – focus on the lessons not the companies. -
Before we get into it, let’s sort out some foundations
INTERNET FOR THE BLIND 101 -
Blind people I work with • Parkinsons, control of eyelids
gone • Victims of violent crime • Cancer, optic nerves • Autoimmune conditions affecting eyes • Car accidents • Hereditary and age related eye conditions • Diabetes related vision loss • … -
Technology Options • Use screen reading and zooming software –
Computers – Mobile Phones – Refreshable braille displays/notetakers • Use keyboard, voice, gestures • Don’t generally use a mouse audio mouse and screen coordinates tracking is available in some, not all, screen readers -
Screen reading software • Linux – ORCA , speakup ,
Adriane Knoppix with SBL , Vinux project … • Mac and iOS – Voiceover (free) (iOS triple click Home, Mac Cmd+F5 on/off) • Windows – NVDA (free, open source) , JAWS, Window Eyes, System Access to Go , Supernova … • Android – Talkback (free, open source) , Mobile accessibility (paid) -
Accessibility APIs • Linux AT-SPI 2 • Windows/Linux IAccessible 2
• Windows MSAA • Windows UIA (UIA on Linux, Mono accessibility project) • Mac OS Ax/uiA • iOS UIAccessibility Protocol Reference • Android Accessibility API • Java Access Bridge -
Scripting Screen Readers • Screen readers can be scripted –
NVDA using Python – JAWS using Proprietary pseudo language, has a function library – Window Eyes using VBScript or Jscript – Supernova using Lua – Orca using Python A Screen reader script, only fixes a Web issue locally To fix a Web issue globally, access to HTML and addition of ARIA roles, states, properties needed -
Something you know, Something you have, Something you are MULTI
FACTOR AUTHENTICATION -
User Response : • “I have got around the problem
and I have even owned up to the bank what I have done to circumvent it.” • “Why they can't text me (like Fastnet Classic) I have no idea. Explaining why they can't, appears to be a security breach in itself.” • “Yes, I have complained, so far to no avail.” -
Solution : Multifactor Auth Hardware • OCR cellphone app can
be used, but … • Time factor 60 seconds – Need to detect numbers changing and signal user • Control light conditions -
Kiwibank Keepsafe Challenge Can’t be done on a PC, without
vision : • How many required letters, where in the word ? • Am I done entering required letters yet ? -
Solution : Kiwibank KeepSafe Challenge • Can be made useable
: – Tell user what number letter in the word is currently required to be input – Tell user when they are finished – Tell user what to activate next, when finished – Ability to go back and correct mistakes – The help text does not have to appear visually • Issues with my solution: Added Info = less secure app for the user ? -
Web security Indicators • “You’ll see that your address bar
has turned green. This is called extended validation” BNZ • “You'll also see the address bar is green when you visit our internet banking login page. We've done this to clearly show you're visiting Kiwibank's website, and not a fake.” Kiwibank • “Ensure that there is a padlock symbol in the bottom right corner of your browser.” ANZ -
CAPTCHA Web AIM screen reader user survey May 2012 90.6
% Find CAPTCHAS difficult -
CAPTCHA Audio reCaptcha since June 2012 • Even our best,
Human, RNZFB audio Captcha solver now has difficulties -
CAPTCHA Air New Zealand Make a Bank transfer to pay
for flights But User already Logged In to Air NZ -
User Response : • “My point to Air New Zealand
however is that if you do identify yourself as a customer by logging in with your airpoints number and password, then at that point they do know who you are and there should be no CAPTCHA.” • “the only purpose of the CAPTCHA in that case is to save the time of a human who doesn't want to sift through bogus (Parliament) submissions. I think this is unreasonable” -
Solution Resistor CAPTCHA Demo • Can be made useable :
– Ability to sample colour of each resistor band – Ability to jump to sliders and emulate mouse – Tell user how many down arrows to press • Issues with my solution: – Lot of instructions to listen to – Haven’t programmed ability to correct mistakes -
Solution Web Visum Text Captcha Cracking • Firefox plugin •
Need invite or go through vetting process • 10 Captcha a day limit • Does reCAPTCHA well, averages 33 seconds to solve, 6 out of 28 wrong -
Sometimes it takes the human touch • CAPTCHA cracking services
• Pay humans to do it for you • Cheap and fast • Ethically dubious but effective • May breach T&Cs • If we are resorting to this – we have done something very wrong -
Learning to stay safe online, one error message at a
time INSTRUCTIONS AND ERROR MESSAGES -
Signalling a problem • UI or Web app change •
Notifies screen reader • Queries accessibility object to present to the user Screen shots of some Silent Notifications -
Web Security Advice … for Mouse users • Home Internet
User, Smartphone advice got to know the info is available, to Search for the text • Mouseified Menus and Widgets can be activated by screen readers, but got to Know it’s a Menu not just a link, to action it - Chicken and Egg scenario. -
Solution 1. CSS Hack CSS Hack for screen readers .nav
li ul { position: absolute; left: -999em; (before was display: none;) overflow: hidden; } .nav li:hover ul ul, .nav li:hover ul ul ul, .nav li:hover ul ul ul ul { display: none; overflow: hidden; } .nav li:hover ul, .nav li li:hover ul, .nav li li li:hover ul, .nav li li li li:hover ul { left: auto; (before was display: block;) overflow: visible; } -
Solution 2. Less Hacky Keyboard equivalent event handlers • onmouseover
also has onfocus • onmouseout also has onfocusout/onblur • deal with the onhover and onclick on non focusable elements -
Solution 3. ARIA • ARIA, for a web developer, means
never having to say, “I’m sorry, but I don’t have time to study all those accessibility APIs”. role="menuitem" aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded ="false“ Browser interprets ARIA roles to Accessibility APIs for screen reader to consume properly • ARIA, for a web developer, means having your current Web design cake, and screen readers being able to consume it, too. -
Security Product Decisions When a Security Product is implemented: 100
% useable by a certain type of user. ? % useable for someone without vision. Example – RNZFB new VPN app -
Security Product Decisions No keyboard access – hacky screen reader
script. Script RnzfbVPNAccess () ;Control+Alt+V var string sWindowName, int iXCoord, int iYCoord, int iXOffset, int iYOffset, int iXVPNWindow, int iYVPNWindow let sWindowName = GetWindowName (GetFocus()) if (sWindowName=="Shrew Soft VPN Access Manager") ;Get Coordinates of the Shrewsoft Window let iXVPNWindow=GetWindowLeft (GetFocus()) let iYVPNWindow=GetWindowTop (GetFocus()) SaveCursor() JAWSCursor() ;Add the never changing offset, for emulated mouse to jump on the RNZFB vpn connect button. let iXCoord=iXVPNWindow+25 let iYCoord=iYVPNWindow+110 MoveTo(iXCoord,iYCoord) ;Double Click the RNZFB vpn connect button LeftMouseButton() LeftMouseButton() RestoreCursor() SayString("Rnzfb Username and password required.") else SayString("You are not focussed on the VPN Window.") Endif EndScript -
Security Features Chrome Multiprocess Browser • Browser Process and Renderer
Processes separate Renderer processes have: • the webpage DOM and accessibility info • don’t interact directly with OS • can’t send or receive events = Screen reader can’t talk. “No UI” -
Security Features Chrome Multiprocess Browser Solution 1 : Chrome Vox
• lots of support calls because … Default Chrome Vox navigation commands, Control+Alt+arrow keys, on Windows, Flips users Screens instead Solution 2 : Security Feature limbo dance • Chrome web browser handles comms between DOM and screen reader. -
Summary • Web applications can be challenging for those users
with visual impairments. • Simple implementation choices can make the difference between an inclusive and enjoyable and complete exclusion • Catering to the needs of the blind however, need not be difficult, expensive or at the cost of innovation