Punctuated Equilibrium Theory (videocast slides)

Slides from PADMN 6320/POLS 5320 Public Policy Theory and Administration at the University of Utah's Programs of Public Affairs

Transcript

1. Punctuated Equilibrium Theory SLIDES
2. Charles Lindblom (1959) “The Science of Muddling Through”
3. human cognition is imperfect limited information capacity
4. CLOSED POLICY SUBSYSTEM
5. Incrementalism Policy makers build on past policy decisions in small incremental steps
6. Agency budget $ $$$ Time Lots of incremental change Some dramatic changes
7. POLICY CHANGES no change big changes big changes Lots of instances of small, or no, change Few instances of moderate change Some dramatic changes
9. Punctuated equilibrium Long periods of little or no change marked by isolated episodes of dramatic change
10. human cognition is imperfect limited information capacity
11. group decision making is limited institutional friction
12. CLOSED POLICY SUBSYSTEM
13. Congress Bureaucracy Interest group IRON TRIANGLES
14. Congress Bureaucracy Interest group low regulation & special favors congressional support via lobby
15. NEGATIVE FEEDBACK Closed subsystems/iron triangles Limited individual & institutional attention Accepted policy images
16. Framing How policy problems are defined and the associated images, symbols, and concepts
18. IMMIGRATION Future citizens seeking for a better life Taking jobs and government resources POVERTY People that have been harmed by unfair system Lazy people preferring to live off of aid ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONS Necessary to mitigate the harms of progress Threats to economic and human wellbeing
19. NEGATIVE FEEDBACK Closed subsystems/iron triangles Limited individual & institutional attention Accepted policy images POSITIVE FEEDBACK Attractive alternative image Attention from multiple venues Mobilization of “outsiders” PUNCTUATION
21. How do policy subsystem characteristics help to explain a lack of policy change, incremental changes, or major policy changes? How do problem frames and issue attention help to explain a lack of policy change, incremental changes, or major policy changes? How do different types of policies compare in their distribution of policy changes (e.g. incremental and major) and how are the differences explained by attention, problem frames, and subsystem dynamics?
22. PUBLIC POLICY THEORY & APPLICATION P A D M N 6 3 2 0