Share
Embed
SREがセキュアなWebシステムを構築、維持するためにやれることはなにか / What can SRE do to build and maintain a secure Web system?
SRE NEXT 2020
2020.1.25
"セキュリティ専門のエンジニアが組織にいない場合、古くなったソフトウェアのメンテナンス、鍵の管理、ファイアウォールの管理を誰が行うのか。それが曖昧な状況が長く続くとサービスが脆弱となり、やがて問題を引き起こすことでしょう。
サービスとシステムの信頼性に対してSREが責任を持つ組織においては、SREが中心となってセキュリティの問題を把握し、安全で堅牢な状態を維持する必要があります。Webアプリケーションやクラウドを使ったシステムをセキュアに保つためにできることは多くあります。
新しくサービスを開発する時、サービスの規模が大きくなってきた時など、セキュリティを意識すべきフェーズで何をすべきなのか、戸惑うことは少なくありません。セキュアなWebシステムを構築、維持するために、最低限知っておきたい知識、応用的な事例について、今までの経験をもとにお話したいと思います。"
Isao Shimizu
January 25, 2020
Transcript
74 slides
-
ਗ਼ਫ܄ʢ͠Έ͍͓ͣ͞ʣ!JTBPTIJNJ[V ॴଐ w גࣜձࣾϛΫγΟ7BOUBHFελδΦΈͯͶࣄۀ෦։ൃάϧʔϓ43&νʔϜ ܦྺ w 4*FSͰडୗ։ൃɺϓϩμΫτ։ൃΛܦݧޙɺʹגࣜձࣾϛΫγΟೖࣾ w 4/4ӡ༻ɺϞϯελʔετϥΠΫͷ43&ΛܦͯɺݱࡏʮՈΞϧόϜΈͯͶʯͷ43& w
݄4PGUXBSF%FTJHO݄߸دߘ 43&ͬͯɼͳʹΛΕ͍͍ͷʁઌۦऀʹ㘤͘ɼ୭͕ͨΊͷ৴པੑ w ݄"844VNNJU5PLZP ίϯςφҠߦͬͯ͜ΜͳʹେมʁʙʮՈΞϧόϜΈͯͶʯΛࢧ͑ΔΠϯϑϥͷཪଆʙ w ͦͷଞʮ43&5FDI5BMLTʯʮICTUVEZʯʮ*OUFSOFU8FFLʯ 2 ࣗݾհ -
ΞδΣϯμ ʮՈΞϧόϜΈͯͶʯʹ͍ͭͯ ͡Ίʹ 43&ʹ͍ͭͯ 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ
ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ ·ͱΊ 3 -
ʮΈͯͶϓϨϛΞϜʯΛ݄ϦϦʔε ֹ݄՝ۚܕͷ༗ྉϓϥϯ ֹ݄ԁ w ϒϥβ͔ΒࣸਅಈըͷΞοϓϩʔυ͕Մೳʹ w ඵಈըͷຖ݄ؒ൛৴ w શ͕ૹྉແྉʢՈશһʣ w
ެ։ൣғΛࡉ͔͘ઃఆՄೳ w ಈըΞοϓϩʔυͷ੍࣌ؒݶΛԆ͔Β ΈͯͶΛ͓͍ͷํɺͥͻ͓ࢼ͍ͩ͘͠͞ʂ 7 ʮՈΞϧόϜΈͯͶʯʹ͍ͭͯ -
8 ʮՈΞϧόϜΈͯͶʯʹ͍ͭͯ AWS Cloud AWS OpsWorks Availability Zone VPC Availability
Zone Availability Zone AWS Cloud Availability Zone VPC Availability Zone Availability Zone Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service Amazon Elastic Container Registry Auto Scaling group EC2 Instances EC2 Instances EC2 Instances Kubernetes Nodes Kubernetes Nodes Kubernetes Nodes Classic Load Balancer Application Load Balancer Before After ΈͯͶͷΠϯϑϥ,VCFSOFUFTʢ"NB[PO&,4ʣͷҠߦத -
͜ͷൃදʹ͍ͭͯ w 43&͕ηΩϡϦςΟʹͲ͏औΓΉͱྑ͍͔ʹϑΥʔΧε͓ͯ͠͠·͢ɻ w ηΩϡϦςΟ͕ͳͥॏཁͳͷ͔ʹ͍ͭͯ͋·Γ͠·ͤΜɻ w ΈͯͶͰͷऔΓΈͷࣄྫʹ͍ͭͯҰ෦հ͠·͢ɻ w ΈͯͶͷΠϯϑϥΞϓϦέʔγϣϯ։ൃͷৄࡉʹ͍ͭͯऔΓ্͛·ͤΜɻ w
"84Λ͍ͬͯΔؔͰɺ"84ʹಛԽͨ͠༰͕͋Γ·͕ྃ͢͝ঝ͍ͩ͘͞ɻ w ϋογϡλάTSFOFYUTSFOFYU" 10 ͡Ίʹ -
class SRE implements DevOps 14 43&ʹ͍ͭͯ 43&WT%FW0QTDPNQFUJOHTUBOEBSETPSDMPTFGSJFOET IUUQTDMPVEHPPHMFDPNCMPHQSPEVDUTHDQTSFWTEFWPQTDPNQFUJOHTUBOEBSETPSDMPTFGSJFOET w
l%FW0QTΛϓϩάϥϛϯάݴޠʹ͓͚ΔΠϯλʔϑΣʔεͱଊ͑ΔͱɺΫϥε 43&%FW0QTͷ࣮Ͱ͋Δɻz w l43&ʹɺ%FW0QTͷΠϯλʔϑΣʔεͷ෦ʹݶΒͳ͍ՃͷϓϥΫςΟεͱ ਪࣄؚ߲͕·ΕΔɻ -
DevOps and SRE are not two competing methods for software
development and operations, but rather close friends designed to break down organizational barriers to deliver better software faster. l%FW0QTͱ43&ɺιϑτΣΞ։ൃͱӡ༻͕ڝ߹͢ΔΑ͏ͳख๏Ͱͳ͘ɺ ΑΓྑ͍ιϑτΣΞΛΑΓ͘ఏڙ͢ΔͨΊʹ৫ͷোนΛଧഁ͢ΔΑ͏ʹ ઃܭ͞ΕͨີͳͷͰ͋Δɻz 15 43&WT%FW0QTDPNQFUJOHTUBOEBSETPSDMPTFGSJFOET IUUQTDMPVEHPPHMFDPNCMPHQSPEVDUTHDQTSFWTEFWPQTDPNQFUJOHTUBOEBSETPSDMPTFGSJFOET 43&ʹ͍ͭͯ -
Site reliability engineering (SRE) is a relatively new discipline, having
only been in existence for about 15 years. It originated at Google and has gained popularity recently with more companies advertising SRE positions or trying to implement SRE practices. In the technology field, 15 years may seem like an eternity, but the SRE role is very much still in its infancy. There are still challenges defining the role and understanding exactly what it is. Just look through one of the 1,000-plus job listings on LinkedIn for an SRE in the United States—you will see many different job expectations and requirements. l43&ൺֱత৽͍͠Ͱɺ͔͠ଘࡏ͍ͯ͠·ͤΜɻ(PPHMFͰ࢝·Γɺ࠷ۙͰ 43&ͷ৬छΛએͨ͠Γɺ43&ͷϓϥΫςΟεΛ࣮͠Α͏ͱ͢Δاۀ͕૿͍͑ͯ·͢ɻ ςΫϊϩδʔͰɺ͍࣌ؒͷΑ͏ʹࢥ͑Δ͔͠Ε·ͤΜ͕ɺ43&ͷׂ ·ͩॳظஈ֊ʹ͋Γ·͢ɻׂΛఆٛ͠ɺͦΕ͕ԿͰ͋Δ͔Λਖ਼֬ʹཧղ͢Δͱ͍͏՝ ͕·ͩ͋Γ·͢ɻ-JOLFE*Oͷ Λ͑ΔٻਓϦετͷͭͰถͷ43&ΛௐΔͩ ͚Ͱɺ͞·͟·ͳٻਓͱཁ͕݅දࣔ͞Ε·͢ɻz 17 43&ʹ͍ͭͯ %FpOJOHUIF3PMFPGB43& IUUQTEFWPQTDPNEFpOJOHUIFSPMFPGBTJUFSFMJBCJMJUZFOHJOFFSTSF -
An SRE must possess a blend of technical as well
as soft skills and, perhaps most of all, must be adept at communicating effectively and inspiring a teamwide approach to excellence. l43&ٕज़తεΩϧͱιϑτεΩϧͷ྆ํΛඋ͍͑ͯΔඞཁ͕͋Γɺ͓ͦ Β͘ԿΑΓɺޮՌతͳίϛϡχέʔγϣϯʹख़ୡ͍ͯ͠Δ͜ͱɺνʔϜ શମͷӽੑͷΞϓϩʔνΛଅ͢͜ͱ͕Ͱ͖ͳ͚ΕͳΓ·ͤΜɻz 18 43&ʹ͍ͭͯ %FpOJOHUIF3PMFPGB43& IUUQTEFWPQTDPNEFpOJOHUIFSPMFPGBTJUFSFMJBCJMJUZFOHJOFFSTSF -
19 43&ʹ͍ͭͯ /(*/9$POG4JUF3FMJBCJMJUZ&OHJOFFSJOH1BOFM-JOLFE*O %FMM BOE(SFNMJO IUUQTXXXZPVUVCFDPNXBUDI W00%);%H. Ashi Sareen Director
of Engineering, Site Reliability LinkedIn “A lot is people are just renaming their ops teams to call SRE. I don’t think that’s the right approach. SRE discipline requires investment it has a very clear set of practices set of team dynamics that makes a successful SRE team.” lଟ͘ͷਓɺӡ༻νʔϜͷ໊લΛมߋͯ͠43&ͱݺΜͰ͍Δ͚ͩͰ͢ɻࢲͦΕ͕ ਖ਼͍͠Ξϓϩʔνͩͱࢥ͍·ͤΜɻ43&ͷ౷੍ʹɺ43&νʔϜΛޭͤ͞Δ໌ ֬ͳνʔϜμΠφϛΫεͷϓϥΫςΟεηοτ͕ඞཁͰ͢ɻz -
23 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ 43&DPO"NFSJDB.BSDIr -JOLFE*O 4FDVSJUZBOE43&/BUVSBM'PSDF.VMUJQMJFST IUUQTXXXVTFOJYPSHDPOGFSFODFTSFDPOBNFSJDBTQSFTFOUBUJPOTDPUU 'BDFCPPL 4FDVSJUZBTB4FSWJDF IUUQTXXXVTFOJYPSHDPOGFSFODFTSFDPOBNFSJDBTQSFTFOUBUJPOXPKUZOJBL “Remove
single points of security failure like you do for availability” “Understand your threats. Defense in depth. Make it simple And stable.” -
24 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ 43&DPO"NFSJDB.BSDIr 1JWPUBM &YUFOEJOHUIF&SSPS#VEHFU.PEFMUP4FDVSJUZBOE 'FBUVSF'SFTIOFTT IUUQTXXXVTFOJYPSHDPOGFSFODFTSFDPOBNFSJDBTQSFTFOUBUJPOUIPNTPO “Vulnerability budget: How
long can we afford to be vulnerable to CVEs in our dependencies? Legacy budget: New enough that it gets support; and not so old that no- one wants to use it.” -
25 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ 43&DPO"TJB+VOF 1BZ1BM &OTVSJOH4JUF3FMJBCJMJUZUISPVHI4FDVSJUZ$POUSPMT IUUQTXXXVTFOJYPSHDPOGFSFODFTSFDPOBTJBQSFTFOUBUJPOKBOBLJSBNBO “1/5th of internet traffic
is bad! Layer 7 Application Defense is the most effective mechanism to detect & mitigate bad traffic” -
26 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ 43&DPO&VSPQF.JEEMF&BTU"GSJDBr0DUPCFS .*5 "4ZTUFNT"QQSPBDIUP4BGFUZBOE $ZCFSTFDVSJUZ IUUQTXXXVTFOJYPSHDPOGFSFODFTSFDPOFNFBQSFTFOUBUJPOMFWFTPO “Looks at system
as whole, not just components. Takes s larger view of causes than just failures.” -
27 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ 43&DPO"NFSJDBT8FTU 4"/5"$-"3" $" 64".BSDIr 43&DPO"TJB1BDJpD 4:%/&: "6453"-*"+VOFr
43&DPO&VSPQF.JEEMF&BTU"GSJDB ".45&3%". /&5)&3-"/%4 43&DPO"NFSJDBT&BTU #0450/ ." 64" -
30 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ #VJMEJOH4FDVSF3FMJBCMF4ZTUFNT 43&BOE4FDVSJUZ#FTU1SBDUJDFz&BSMZ3FMFBTF w ηΩϡϦςΟʔͱ৴པੑΛςʔϚʹͨ͠ॻ੶ɻ w (PPHMFͷΤϯδχΞ໊ʹΑΔࣥචɻ w &BSMZ3FMFBTFͷνϟϓλʔҎԼͷͭͷΈʢͦͷଞͷষݱࡏෆ໌ʣ
w 5IF*OUFSTFDUJPOPG4FDVSJUZBOE3FMJBCJMJUZ w 6OEFSTUBOEJOH"EWFSTBSJFT w 5FTUJOH$PEF -
32 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ w ৴པੑͱηΩϡϦςΟɺιϑτΣΞͱγεςϜͷϥΠϑαΠΫϧʹෆ ՄܽͰ͋Δɻ w ৴པੑͱηΩϡϦςΟΛཱ྆ͨ͠γεςϜΛߏங͢Δͷ؆୯Ͱͳ͍ɻ w ͲͪΒ͋ͱͰ࣮͠Α͏ͱ͢Δͷ͍͠ɻ w
ॳظ͔ΒߟྀͰ͖͍ͯΔ͜ͱ͕·͍͠ɻ w ͕ى͖ͳ͍ͱίετΛ͔͚ͳ͍ྖҬɻ w ͕ى͖͔ͯΒͩͱਂࠁʹͳΓ͕ͪɻ w γϯϓϧͳઃܭɺ࠷খԽ͞Εͨݖݶཧ͕ॏཁͰ͋Δɻ -
33 43&ͱηΩϡϦςΟ w Α͘Ͱ͖ͨϩΪϯάڴҖͷݕग़ͱোͷඋ͑ͱͳΔɻ w ༗ࣄͷࡍͷࢦشܥ౷ɺνΣοΫϦετɺϓϨΠϒοΫɺϓϩτίϧॏཁɻ w ੬ऑੑύονૉૣ͍ద༻͕ॏཁɻ w ύονͷ༰ʹ࣍ୈͰʢόάɺੑೳྼԽͳͲʣΛى͜͢Մೳੑ͋Δɻ
w ϦεΫΛߟྀͯ͠ɺద༻λΠϛϯάʹ͍ͭͯϏδωεαΠυͱௐ͢Δɻ ଞʹ༷ʑͳϓϥΫςΟε͕ࡌ͍ͬͯΔͷͰڵຯͷ͋Δํ͓ಡΈ͍ͩ͘͞ɻ w ୈষॳΊͷʮ0OQBTTXPSETBOEQPXFSESJMMTʯɻ w &BSMZ3FMFBTF൛ͳͷͰग़൛࣌ʹ༰ʹมߋ͕͋ΔՄೳੑ͕͋Γ·͢ɻ -
ʢࢲ͕ߟ͑Δʣ43&νʔϜʹ͓͚Δίϛϡχέʔγϣϯͷݪଇ w ։ൃνʔϜͳͲɺଞνʔϜͱͷؒʹนΛ࡞Βͳ͍ w ԡ͚͠߹Θͳ͍ w ྫྷ੩ʹ͔ͬ͠Γͱٞ͢Δ w ͓ޓ͍ͷঢ়گͷཧղ͠߹͏ w
Ϗδωεࣄۀʹͱͬͯ༏ઌ͖͔͢Ͳ͏͔͠߹͏ 38 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
ηΩϡϦςΟͷ্ʹߩݙͰ͖Δࢪࡦࣄྫ w ։ൃνʔϜͷώΞϦϯά w *OGSBTUSVDUVSFBT$PEF w ϩάऩूͱݕࡧ w Ξοϓσʔτ w
ϞχλϦϯάɺఆظϨϙʔτ w ϙετϞʔςϜ 40 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
ώΞϦϯά༰ͷྫʢʣ w ͲΜͳϥΠϒϥϦΛ༻͍ͯ͠Δ͔ w ϢʔβʔͷτʔΫϯͷऔΓѻ͍ w ༗ޮظݶ w อଘॴͲ͔͜ w
Ұൠతͳ944ɺ$43'ͷରࡦͰ͖͍ͯΔ͔ w "1*ͷύϥϝʔλΛมߋͯ͠ɺଞਓͷσʔλΛݟΔ͜ͱ Ͱ͖ͳ͍͔ 42 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
ώΞϦϯά༰ͷྫʢʣ w ΞϓϦέʔγϣϯ෦ʹൿಗใΛ͍࣋ͬͯͳ͍͔Ͳ͏͔ w Ϣʔβʔཧͷύεϫʔυ w ฏจͰอଘ͍ͯ͠ͳ͍͔ w ฏจͰૹ৴ʢϝʔϧͳͲʣ͍ͯ͠ͳ͍͔ w
ύεϫʔυͷڧʢจࣈɺจࣈछͳͲʣద͔ w ϦϚΠϯμͷख๏ͲΜͳͷ͔ 43 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
ώΞϦϯά༰ͷྫʢʣ w ΞΫηεϩάϢʔβʔΛಛఆͰ͖ΔܗͰ͍ͯ͠Δ͔ w ϩά্ͷݸਓใʢࢯ໊ɺϝʔϧΞυϨεɺॅॴͳͲʣϚεΫ ॲཧ͍ͯ͠Δ͔ w ύεϫʔυ૯Γ߈ܸΛݕग़དྷΔ͔ w ΞϓϦଆʹ੬ऑੑ͕ݟ͔ͭͬͨͱ͖ɺΞοϓσʔτΛڧ੍Ͱ͖
ΔΑ͏ʹͳ͍ͬͯΔ͔ w Ͳ͜ͷܾࡁαʔϏεΛ͍ͬͯΔ͔ w ͲΜͳ࣮ʹͳ͍ͬͯΔ͔ 45 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
*OGSBTUSVDUVSFBT$PEF *B$ w ΠϯϑϥͷߏஙΛख࡞ۀͰΒͳ͍ w ଐਓతɺมߋཧɺઃఆυΩϡϝϯτͷൈ͚࿙ΕͳͲͷ͕ى͖͍͢ w *B$ͷπʔϧΛ͏ʢ5FSSBGPSNɺ$MPVE'PSNBUJPOͳͲʣ w
1VMM3FRVFTUΛ࡞ΓɺίʔυϨϏϡʔΛड͚Δ w ྫ*".ηΩϡϦςΟάϧʔϓ͕࠷খݶͱͳ͍ͬͯΔ͔ w $*πʔϧͱ࿈ܞͯ͠ESZSVOΛ࣮ߦ͢Δ w 1VMM3FRVFTUͷϚʔδʹΑͬͯΠϯϑϥʹద༻͢Δ 47 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
ϩάऩूͱݕࡧ w ҟৗͳΞΫηεɺτϥϑΟοΫͷݕग़ w ΞΫηεݩͷڴҖݕग़ w ϩάʹೝূใݸਓใͳͲͷػີใࡌͤͳ͍ w ϩάͷྔίετʹӨڹ͍͢͠ʢҰ࣌อଘઌɺظอଘઌʣ w
ෆཁͳϩά͕ͳ͍͔Ͳ͏͔ఆظతʹνΣοΫ͢Δ w Ϋϥυଆͷϩάʢྫ4ɺ$MPVE'SPOUɺ&-#ͳͲʣͰ͖Δ͚ͩ༗ޮԽ w ϩάΛऩूɺݕࡧͰ͖Δ4BB4ར༻ݕ౼͢Δ 49 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
Ξοϓσʔτରͷྫ w ΞϓϦέʔγϣϯʹґଘ͢ΔϥΠϒϥϦ w 04ɺ.Z42-ɺ3FEJTɺ/HJOYɺ'MVFOUEͳͲͷϛυϧΣΞɺ֤छύοέʔδ w ϞχλϦϯάͳͲৗ࣌ىಈ͍ͯ͠ΔΤʔδΣϯτιϑτΣΞ w ,VCFSOFUFTΫϥελɺ)FMNνϟʔτ w
5FSSBGPSNɺϞδϡʔϧ ੬ऑੑఆظతʹൃݟ͞Εमਖ਼͞ΕΔɻ͍ͣΕࣗಈԽ͠ͳ͍ͱ์ஔ͞Ε͕ͪɻ ࣗಈԽ͕ࠔͳ߹ɺఆظతͳΞοϓσʔτͷΈ࡞Γ͕େࣄɻ 51 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
ϙετϞʔςϜ w ো͕ൃੜͨ͠ࡍʹࣄରԠΛه͢Δɻ w ηΩϡϦςΟʹݶఆͨ͠ͷͰͳ͍ɻ w αʔϏεͷӨڹͷ༗ແʹؔΘΒͣɺੵۃతʹ࡞͢Δɻ w ϙετϞʔςϜͷ࡞ऀΛশࢍ͢ΔจԽΛ࡞Δɻ w
ઈରʹΊͨΓɺ൷͠ͳ͍ɻ 43&Ҏ֎ʢͰ͖Δ্͚ͩͷ৬ͷਓ͕Α͍ʣר͖ࠐΜͰɺఆظతʹ ϙετϞʔςϜΛৼΓฦΓɺվળΛଓ͚Δ͜ͱ͕ཧɻ 55 ηΩϡϦςΟͷऔΓΈࣄྫ -
59 "848FMM"SDIJUFDUFE'SBNFXPSL ͭͷப w ӡ༻্ͷ༏लੑ w ηΩϡϦςΟ w ৴པੑ w
ύϑΥʔϚϯεޮ w ίετ࠷దԽ ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
60 "848FMM"SDIJUFDUFE'SBNFXPSLʮηΩϡϦςΟʯ ΞΠσϯςΟςΟཧͱΞΫηεཧ ൃݟత౷੍ ΠϯϑϥετϥΫνϟอޢ σʔλอޢ
ΠϯγσϯτରԠ ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
61 ΞΠσϯςΟςΟཧͱΞΫηεཧ w 4&$ೝূใͱೝূΛͲͷΑ͏ʹཧ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ w 4&$ਓҝతͳΞΫηεΛͲͷΑ͏ʹ੍ޚ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ w 4&$ϓϩάϥϜʹΑΔΞΫηεΛͲͷΑ͏ʹ੍ޚ͍ͯ͠·͔͢
ൃݟత౷੍ w 4&$ηΩϡϦςΟΠϕϯτΛͲͷΑ͏ʹݕग़͠ɺௐ͍ࠪͯ͠·͔͢ʁ w 4&$৽͍͠ηΩϡϦςΟڴҖʹରͯ͠ͲͷΑ͏ʹޚ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ w ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
62 ΠϯϑϥετϥΫνϟอޢ w 4&$ωοτϫʔΫΛͲͷΑ͏ʹอޢ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ w 4&$ίϯϐϡʔςΟϯάϦιʔεΛͲͷΑ͏ʹอޢ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ σʔλอޢ w
4&$σʔλΛͲͷΑ͏ʹྨ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ w 4&$อதͷσʔλΛͲͷΑ͏ʹอޢ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ w 4&$ૹதͷσʔλΛͲͷΑ͏ʹอޢ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ ΠϯγσϯτରԠ w 4&$ηΩϡϦςΟΠϯγσϯτʹͲͷΑ͏ʹରԠ͍ͯ͠·͔͢ ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
"84Λѻ͏ࡍʹؾΛ͚ͭΔ͖جຊతͳϙΠϯτ ༰ʹ͍ͭͯ w هࡌͷ༰ͲΕجຊతͳͷͰ͢ɻ w "84͕ެࣜʹਪ͍ͯ͠ΔͷͰ͋Γ·ͤΜɻ w ࠓ·Ͱͷӡ༻ܦݧ"84ͷυΩϡϝϯτͳͲΛࢀߟʹ͍ͯ͠·͢ɻ w ࠓޙͷ"84ͷΞοϓσʔτʹΑͬͯɺ༰͕มΘΔՄೳੑ͕͋Γ·͢ɻ
w .645͔4)06-%͔Ͳ͏͔ࣗʹͯ͝அ͍ͩ͘͞ɻ 65 ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
ηΩϡϦςΟαʔϏε w "84$MPVE5SBJMɺ"NB[PO(VBSE%VUZɺ"84$POpHͷ༗ޮԽ͢Δɻ w "845SVTUFE"EWJTPSͰఆظతʹηΩϡϦςΟνΣοΫ͢Δɻ w "84$FSUJpDBUF.BOBHFSͰൃߦͨ͠5-4ূ໌ॻΛ͏ɻ w "848FMM"SDIJUFDUFEϨϏϡʔΛड͚Δɻ w
"NB[PO&$3ͷ੬ऑੑεΩϟϯΛ͏ɻ 66 ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
*". w ιʔεϨϙδτϦʹΞΫηεΩʔɺγʔΫϨοτΩʔΛอ࣋͠ͳ͍ɻ w ϚωʔδϝϯτίϯιʔϧϩάΠϯͰ͖Δ*".Ϣʔβʔ.'"Λઃఆ͢Δɻ w ୀ৬ऀҟಈऀͳͲར༻͠ͳ͘ͳͬͨ*".ϢʔβʔΞΫηεΩʔআ͢Δɻ w ϧʔτϢʔβʔʹ.'"Λઃఆ͢Δɻ w
ΞΫηεΩʔɺγʔΫϨοτΩʔΛڞ༗͠ͳ͍ɻ w ֎෦αʔϏεʹΞΫηεΩʔɺγʔΫϨοτΩʔΛઃఆ͠ͳ͍ɻ w "84ΞΧϯτΛڥ͝ͱʹ͚Δɻ w εΠονϩʔϧ͢Δ߹.'"Λඞਢͱ͢Δɻ 68 ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
ͦͷଞʢʣ w ग़ॴෆ໌ͷύϒϦοΫ".*ΛΘͳ͍ɻ w Ͱ͖Δ͚ͩ৽͍͠όʔδϣϯͷ".*Λ͏ɻ w 4όέοτΛΠϯλʔωοτʹެ։͠ͳ͍ɻ w $MPVE'SPOUΩʔϖΞϑΝΠϧΛιʔείʔυϨϙδτϦʹؚΊͳ͍ɻ w
$MPVE'SPOUͷ5-4ηΩϡϦςΟϙϦγʔ5-4WҎ߱Λ͏ɻ 69 ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
ͦͷଞʢʣ w 3%4Πϯλʔωοτ͔ΒΞΫηεͤ͞ͳ͍ɻ w 3%4ͷύονΛఆظతʹద༻͢Δɻ w &$4ίϯςφΤʔδΣϯτΛఆظతʹΞοϓσʔτ͢Δɻ w &,4ΫϥελΛఆظతʹΞοϓσʔτ͢Δɻ w
"84ΞΧϯτΛڥ͝ͱʹ͚Δɻ 70 ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
"84ʹݶΒͣͬͨ΄͏͕Α͍͜ͱ·ͱΊ͓ͯ͘ͱʜ w ڞ༗ϞσϧΛཧղ͢ΔʢΫϥυͷηΩϡϦςΟϢʔβʔͷʣɻ w Ϋϥυʹ༻ҙ͞Ε͍ͯΔηΩϡϦςΟιϦϡʔγϣϯΛ׆༻͢Δɻ w ωοτϫʔΫΛ͢ΔʢΠϯλʔωοτ͔ΒͷΞΫηε࠷খݶʹʣɻ w ෆཁͳϙʔτۭ͚ͳ͍ɻ w
࠷খݶͷ*".ϙϦγʔΛઃఆ͢Δɻ w ΞοϓσʔτͰ͖ΔͷఆظతʹΞοϓσʔτ͢Δɻ 71 ΫϥυΛѻ͏ࡍʹऔΓΉ͖ηΩϡϦςΟରࡦʢ"84ฤʣ -
w 43&͕ηΩϡϦςΟʹߩݙͰ͖Δ͜ͱͨ͘͞Μ͋Δɻ w ৴པੑʢ3FMJBCJMJUZʣͱηΩϡϦςΟͰ͖Δཱ͚͍ͩ྆ͤͨ͞ɻ w ΠϯϑϥɺΞϓϦέʔγϣϯͲͪΒૣ͍ஈ֊͔ΒηΩϡϦςΟΛߟྀͰ ͖Δ͜ͱ͕ཧతɻ w ηΩϡϦςΟʹؔ͢Δ՝ͷରॲͰ͖Δ͚ͩૣ͍΄͏͕ྑ͍ɻ w
Λൃݟ͍͢͠ڥͮ͘Γ͕େࣄɻ w ख͕͔͔ؒΔ͜ͱޙճ͠ʹ͞Ε͍͢ͷͰɺͰ͖ΔݶΓࣗಈԽ͢Δɻ w ΫϥυͰ༻ҙ͞Ε͍ͯΔηΩϡϦςΟιϦϡʔγϣϯΛ׆༻͢Δɻ 73 ·ͱΊ